Software
Houzz Logo Print
tealeaf1012

help, I am a moron!!!

17 years ago

Hi,

I hope someone might be able to give me some advice. I am a new gardener. We bought a house recently that needs tons of landscaping help, so I have been a little overwhelmed lately trying to learn about plants, flowers and gardening....

Over the past two weeks I have been doing some planting outside. Apparently I hadn't really done any reading on SOIL !! I was using potting soil (usually miracle grow) to help amend my soil outside. Is this really that bad? I didn't realize that this was only for containers. I have no idea why the word "potting" didn't clue me in! Actually when I bought the soil at home depot I didn't see a lot of other options for some reason, so I assumed this was the right stuff.

So now I am worried.... I planted a knock out rose using this (actually seems to be doing beautifully at the moment)... I also planted a bridal wreath using this. Today I planted about seven perennial flowers in an area that I am beginning to try to turn into a nice flower bed. After I planted about 4 of them I finally realized my mistake. I didn't know what to do. I had a different bag in my backyard that I had bought at a gardening store...it is a organic soil amendment product. So I dug back out my perennials and added this instead.

My soil here is very sandy and doesn't look like it has a lot of nutrients, so when I dug the holes I really tried to use mostly these products with just a little of my sandy soil mixed in.

Is this ok? is it ok if there is still a lot of the potting soil mixed in? Will the problems occur later on down the road?

Do I have to dig out the rose and bridal wreath and fix these too? What is the major problem with using potting soil when planting in an outdoor garden?

Sorry for the zillion questions!!!! I appreciate your expertise. This is hard work but I really am enjoying learning about gardening. I think I jumped the gun and began planting too soon without researching enough, but we really needed to get moving on fixing this house up!

Thank you so much!!!

Tara

Comments (7)

  • 17 years ago

    I doubt you will have any problems, especially since your soil is sandy. What you did do, was spend more money than you really needed to, since potting soil is usually more expensive. I would just keep a close eye on what you've planted, and your flowers will let you know if they are unhappy. Relax and enjoy your new yard! Remember that you should never be "finished" with your gardens. They should be ever evolving environments!!

  • 17 years ago

    thanks tasymo! I just breathed a sign of relief when I read your response.

    I will keep an eye on these. I also planted some tall phlox which is not in bloom yet and they look good with the exception of one that didn't look so great. We just had torrential rain for the past couple days... so I am hoping that might be why one is looking a little haggard....

  • 17 years ago

    Don't you worry about it Tara! There isn't anything in potting soil that should hurt anything. Potting soil really isn't soil so much as a mix of peat, vermiculite, and either compost or mulch.
    But next time you start digging or amending the soil go with bags of compost, as it has more nutrients.
    One of the best investments you can make in buying a composter. Just throw in your veggie scraps (peelings, rinds, etc), leaves, any extra soil and you are cookin'! You can always buy bagged compost, but it is cheaper to make your own!
    Take care.
    CMK

  • 17 years ago

    I agree with the other posters that you shouldn't really have any problems with what you've already planted. The areas with mostly potting soil will likely dry out more slowly than the surrounding sandy soil, so keep this in mind when watering (and avoiding overwatering - check the soil around your plants a couple of inches down to see what conditions are in the planting hole).

    Compost is an excellent amendment, if you can find a good source, like a soil supplier who deals in bulk compost. Starting your own compost pile is a good idea too.
    One potential problem with using bagged potting soil, in addition to the expense, is that in mixes containing lightweight materials like perlite, the stuff will tend to rise to the soil surface with repeated waterings, and can look unsightly. This is really just a cosmetic problem, though.

  • 17 years ago

    I don't see a problem with it either other than expense. Most of my plants would do better if I did that, just that it costs too much more.

    I asked my daughter to pick me up 2 bags of Miracle Gro for potting and 2 bags of topsoil. She came back with the Mir Gro but another brand of potting soil, didn't know the difference. Rather than the hassle of exchange, I'll just use it in or out.

    The only problem I see is how deep you went. Plants that sink deep roots might be fooled by the super rich soil on top, then I don't know what they would do, form shallower roots to take advantage of the richer soil or go deeper and suffer culture shock. The added nutrients will trickle down to some extent.

    Or not miss a beat. Plants are funny. People did not used to fuss like we do now, and stuff still grew, depended on rainfall for water like most midwest farmers do now. I think some of us try to grow things that our forebears might not have; they went tried and true. We want to grow some plants that are fussier and ones that weren't available then.

    The only thing I remember is that my father used to rotate crops. Somewhere I read that if you have problem soil, plant buckwheat for one growing season. It'll loosen it up and condition it.

  • 17 years ago

    And when you improve soil, you improve a bed, not just holes in the existing soil.

  • 17 years ago

    Tara, no worries, everything will be fine. I know how you feel though. I had been using potting soil for awhile and didn't realize I was wasting money but almost all of my plants are thriving, so no real harm done. Don't dig anything out. I think the reason they call it "potting soil" is that basically it would be too expensive to use the quantities you need outdoors in all the beds, so most people use it for houseplants indoors only. But I guess I was a moron too! LOL