Software
Houzz Logo Print
bebemarie_gw

Anyone using Manure tea?

17 years ago

Hi all,

I've just begun to use manure tea with some added alfalfa pellets as my fertilizer.

Wondering what people's experience is with this method of fertilizing.

How often do you use it and how much do you apply each time?

A lot of my roses are in half wine barrels and 20 gal pots.

Thanks for any info.

Diane

Comments (7)

  • 17 years ago

    Diane, I added a bit of composted manure to my alfalfa tea for my very first batch of "tea" several months ago and the smell was horrendous! I managed to get it distributed - gagging the entire time! - but have since left the manure out of the alfalfa tea batch. In a book on composting (The Complete Compost Gardening Guide), it states that it is better, when brewing COMPOST tea, to leave animal manures OUT of the process due to the possibility of e.coli.........

    You can use a mesh bag of non-manure compost to brew your tea for a couple of days. The book (and several posters on this forum) recommend aerating the tea, either using an aquarium pump or even just stirring it a lot; this will help cut down on the odor and help keep anaerobic conditions from developing. This particular book also states that you should use your tea right away after brewing because "the longer the tea sits, even with aeration, the less biologically active it becomes. Without other food sources, microorganisms will feed on one another and gradually die off".

    Hope this helps!

    Lynn

  • 17 years ago

    Hi Lynn,

    Thanks for responding.

    I've been stirring my batch every day and really don't have much smell.

    Diane

  • 17 years ago

    Diane, A good clematis friend gave me this recipe that I've used for two years now. In a five gallon bucket put in 4 cups of alfalfa pellets, fill with water. Cover and stir once a day for 7 days. When I'm ready to fertilize I add 2 cups Epsom salt and 1 cup fish emulsion. All roses and clematis get 1 cup with climbers getting 2 cups of the recipe. I just put out 3 five gallons of it last weekend. It smells horrible but the roses love it.
    Arlene

  • 17 years ago

    There are actually two different "teas" - compost tea, which is brewed from compost and there's alfalfa tea, brewed from alfalfa pellets. I am no expert by ANY means but I think the compost tea is super good for the soil in providing microonutrients and beneficial.....things (somebody help me here!) for the soil. The alfalfa contains a type of mild growth stimulant for the plant. I have heard of manure tea but have decided that I will just stick to the compost or alfalfa variety (although I use manure in my compost pile, for sure).

    Lynn

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks Arlene and Lynn

    A number of older books about roses talk about manure tea and I did a Google search too.

    Hopefully they're all good.

    Diane

  • 17 years ago

    I would definitely stay away from manure tea. The objective of a tea is to "breed" the microorganisms (bacteria, fungus) that are in the substance that is brewed. Manure is poo! you don't want to brew poo, there is way too many pathogens in it.

    I have brewed compost tea in a rather elaborate way and I have done some tests (watered an identified area of lawn with it every 2 weeks for 6 months) and have seen no effect. I didn't conclude that it didn't work, there is too many different factors involved. I continue to dilute some compost in my watering cans.

    I brew alfalfa tea and stinging nettle tea (about 1 week). I use all these different teas irregularly and I also use home made compost and alfalfa pellets in the spring and summer.

    My garden is lush and I have very litte diseases notably on the roses. I have never sprayed anything chemical and I can't be bothered with fish emulsion, epson salts or any "external" products. Basically the only thing that goes in from the outside is alfalfa pellets and mulch (shredded green wastes).

    I water very little, mostly in the spring and only with rain water (and watering cans).

  • 16 years ago

    Oh, yes, love the effects of manure tea in my garden...and I've written a blog about it too! I know of a wonderful source to get some good quality manure tea made from pesticide and antibiotic free, grass fed livestock from the Haven Ranch in San Juan Capistrano, California. You can purchase it online, see link. Here is the blog about Butterfly Gardening With Manure Tea: http://www.obsessionwithbutterflies.com/blog/2010/11/gardening-with-manure-tea/

    Here is a link that might be useful: Haven ManureTea