Software
Houzz Logo Print
bouvard_gw

Which Tractor to Buy?

19 years ago

I just bought a house with 2 acres of lawn to mow (on a pretty consistent 17% slope with an average number of obstacles). I'm used to mowing 1/2 acre; so I've got to buy some new equipment. Given the size of the lawn, I probably need a 48+" deck. ZTR models are expensive and (I've heard) don't do well on hills; so I've pretty much decided to go with a tractor. Price is definitely an issue (since the house already comes with a bunch of new expenses); but I don't want to buy a cheapo machine that'll break in a year or two. Consumer Reports likes JD's LA130, Craftsman's 28724 (and 27690), and Husqvarna's YTH2348. The guy at Home Depot was pushing the Cub Cadet 1550. (Ideally, I'd like to buy the tractor at a local dealer instead of a big box store; but the dealer's pushing Toro's, which don't do so well in the ratings and are pricey). Any thoughts?

Comments (13)

  • 19 years ago

    With 2 acres to mow, I'd go for a 54" deck if possible, but nothing less than 48". It will take a few hours to mow 2 acres with a lawn or garden tractor, so a few more inches per swath will help.

    For 2 acres with consistent slopes, you'd be well-advised to find a gently used garden tractor with a heavy duty hydro transmission instead of a lawn tractor. Those slopes may wear out a light-duty lawn tractor hydro tranny prematurely.

    Of the models you listed, I'd probably go with the Craftsman 27690 if that's the DGS6500 with the Tuff Torq K66 tranny. But there are mixed reports on that tractor. Some people have it and love it. Others seem to have problems, most often immediately after purchasing it (which may indicate a setup problem).

    I recently bought a gently used John Deere GT235E with a powerflow bagger for about the same money, and it's a more heavily built machine with a better motor and heavier tranny. Good use garden tractors are out there if you are patient. And if you're really lucky, you might find a real deal on one. You just have to do your research and be ready to snap it up because they usually don't last long if they're in good shape and priced right.

  • 19 years ago

    As with "MOST" advice, there is good and bad. Some ZTRs don't work all that well on hills, some handle them with ease. The best way to know is to have a few brought out and drive them on your own lawn. A good reputable dealer will accomodate that request, before expecting you to part with $4000+ dollars. Make sure you look a models with low centers of gravity. Ones that have that have the deck out in front, not down under the rider.

    I think you will find that investing a couple of thousand dollars more will be money well spent, unless you are only going to live there for a year or so.

    I have a ZTR like I described, and I started out mowing 3.5 acres with lots of trees and flower beds, then went down to 1.5 acres, and now mow 3/4 acres. Still have the same mower, and it will last me as long as I will ever need it. I only have 200 hrs on it in 6 seasons, and it should last 2500-3000 hours with ease.

  • 19 years ago

    I would definitely go for a ZTR. It is rubbish to say they do not handle slopes well. They have a lower center of gravity and always pull with both drive wheels, except when you tell it not to.

  • 19 years ago

    I think the biggest factor in deciding between a tractor or a ZTR is whether you will use it for cutting grass and nothing else, or doing much more than that. With a new home, you'll probably be doing a lot of landscaping, and might want a tiller, blade, or other ground-engaging attachment. Nothing saves time on cutting grass like carving out small flower beds around obstacles (without borders) and around the house. It's a short-term expenditure in back pain for a long-term savings in time. With most lawns, it's not the wide open cutting that takes up the time, it's the trimming. You have MA as your zone. That tells me you'll probably be doing a little snow removal and possibly hauling a little firewood. Between belt-driven attachments, sleeve hitch accessories, blades, dethatchers, and towable equipment, the goodies you can buy for a big garden tractor will satisfy your every gounds maintenance need (as I'm sure you know). By comparison, the accessories available for a $10k John Deere 737 Z-trak include: a spark arrester, a front light kit, a suspension seat, a ROPS, a mulch kit, and a roller striping kit. Of course there's always the option of buying a new ZTR (for a small fortune) just to cut grass, and an old Wheelhorse, JD or CC tractor on eBay for $50--save $$ by finding one with a swiss-cheese-looking deck--to satisfy your grounds maintenance needs (better have a big shed).
    Don't forget the Husqvarna and Craftsman are both made by the same group with a lot of similar components. Probably get more for your money with the less-impressive Craftsman stickers on the side.

  • 19 years ago

    If you have a JD, Kubota, & a Simplicity dealership nearby you, I would make an effort to go to each one, see what they reccomend, and ask them each to bring that particular one to your house to try it. I believe if they are within a 25 mile radius of you they will be more than happy to please you since you would be spending money with them...Then make your decision...

  • 19 years ago

    Try out CC

  • 19 years ago

    My lawn is 6200 sq. fet and am thinking of buying a Craftsman DLS 3500 20-HP with B& S engine. Does anyone have any experience with this?

  • 19 years ago

    For 2 acres, I would be looking at a good used diesel machine with either a 54 or a 60 inch deck - The fuel savings alone over a 5 year period would probably pay the difference in the upfront cost

    Don

  • 19 years ago

    get the best the first time and you'll never be sorry
    kubota diesel 4x4 60" mower or bigger

  • 19 years ago

    Posted by rosarama (My Page) on Tue, Aug 14, 07 at 19:39

    My lawn is 6200 sq. fet
    ============================

    Mine is 101,495 Sq. Ft.

  • 19 years ago

    bouvard,
    I have a craftsman DSG 6500 and I love it but it does not have a locking rear differential or positraction. I haven't had problems but I just don't know how well it'd do on 17% grade. Popular Mechanics (last yr?) seemed to like the Massey Furgussen and Kubota. Anyone have experience with MF?

  • 19 years ago

    OK, I looked it up, MF is Simplicity. Don't I feel like a dummy!

  • 19 years ago

    I'd go tractor everytime for its flexibility in service. You'll quickly discover that cutting grass is just one useful thing that the tractor does

Sponsored
CHC & Family Developments
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars6 Reviews
Industry Leading General Contractors in Franklin County, Ohio