Software
Houzz Logo Print
deervssteve

An idea for deer protection

13 years ago

Deer repellant is not looking good. Fence is not an option.
I've been reading here about cages to protect against rabbits.

I thought I could get some wire fencing and make cylinders between five and six feet in diameter and anchor them to stakes in the ground with removable connectors so the cages can be removed and the roses taken care of.

This is acceptable to my wife.

Comments (13)

  • 13 years ago

    They'd have to be really tall or have tops on them to keep the deer out but it could work.

  • 13 years ago

    When I lived in Colorado Springs where deer roamed the neighborhoods, grazing freely. I saw roses caged like that. It seemed to work. Worth a try.

  • 13 years ago

    I think that they would need to be about a foot higher than the top of the growth and not need a top. eight feet would definitely do it and seven feet might and be easier to work with.

  • 13 years ago

    It worked quite well for me, but I have the ideal circumstances to make it work. In my front yard, the previous owners created two tiers to hold up the soil near the house for a lawn and as a transition down to the street level.

    I widened the top bed from 8" to 3" and caged the 5 roses Mrs. J had planted in that tier. Even tho' I made the cages much larger than the roses, once caged, the roses outgrew their cages twice in one season.

    I didn't like the look of the caged roses as well as I like what I have in place, now. This spring, I caged the whole top tier into one big cage with "gates" so I could get in and care for the plants on the lawn side. It's a much softer look and the roses really look a lot better than when I had them in individual cages. Besides, when I opened the cage to work on the rose it kept biting me in the back side of the lap.

    Smiles,
    Lyn

  • 13 years ago

    I'm glad you found this thread, Lyn! When I began reading it, I was thinking you needed to see it as it's precisely what you did to protect your front garden roses. Thanks! Kim

  • 13 years ago

    Oops... I meant to write that I widened the bed from 8 inches to 3 feet in the upper tier of the roses in front of the house.

    Kim, I've made the cage for 'Linda Campbell' wider all the way around by at least 2 to 3 feet on each side of the rose. As you know, this rose is located down on the street level. It's already reaching out and has the potential to make a big statement ... except in curculio season. I am thinking when it's in full bloom, folks will be able to see it from Main Street down below the park.

    I'll take photos after I've finished weeding down there.

    Steve, the link below is a photo of LC a couple of years ago. The rose is more than twice as tall and outgrew it's cage last year. When I made the new cage this year, the rose is more than twice as tall and the cage reaches beyond the santolinas all the way back to the wall covered by the vinca and forward to the edge of the road. It was almost as tho' I had freed the rose to really grow much, much larger.

    This was the first rose I caged. I've since learned how to make the posts almost disappear by painting them sage green and I use old wire instead of new shinny wire. I have a "gate" built in and can work inside the cage quite easily.

    Smiles,
    Lyn

    Here is a link that might be useful: Caged Linda Campbell

  • 13 years ago

    For ease of use and "disappearing into the landscape", I've found that welded wire fencing coated with black-colored (my preference; there's green, too) PVC works well.

    If you google "PVC vinyl coated welded wire fencing 6' ", you can see a range of heights and colors available on the Academy Fence Co. site, for example, or further down, others offer "Yard Gard" brand of that fencing. The tallest height I've found in stock at local hardware stores is 4', but they might order taller for you if asked.

    I've used this kind of fencing for for cat-inclusion devices (in-leaning wire fence flaps attached to tops of fences to keep the cats from going out of the yard) and tree-trunk protection from over-zealous claws. Has held up for 10 years, at least.

    Fencing cylinders are de rigueur for shrubs at restoration sites in San Mateo where I currently have some jobs. Typical dimensions of 4' diameter and max. 5' height are adequate for deer protection in that case (meant to be removed in a few years when the shrub is large enough to withstand normal browsing). For roses, where browsing is just not acceptable, it would depend on the anticipated size of the rose, I guess.

    Debbie

    This post was edited by catspa on Sun, May 5, 13 at 14:02

  • 13 years ago

    Try Milorganite. Renew it once in a while, or after a heavy rain. It seems to work for me. Your roses will like it too. No kidding.

  • 13 years ago

    Steve: In your other recent thread on this subject ("The Deer Win . . .") you indicated that you have been using Liquid Fence, the same product that I've used successfully for years. You stated that when using the product you "spray lightly". That, I think, may be your problem. Spraying lightly just wonâÂÂt do it, even if you spray lightly on a regular schedule.

    I keep the pre-mixed product on hand for use on new plantings, but I rely on regular applications of Liquid Fence that I mix at the strength suggested on the container of concentrate.

    I'm linking to a similar recent thread on the Antique Roses Forum. In response to a post there by Hartwood regarding the positive results members of her garden club have had with Liquid Fence, I chimed in to give my experience and to discuss how the product must be used if it's going to deliver on its promise. Perhaps you'll find it useful.

    It would be terrific if spraying the stuff lightly did the trick, but it simply does not. Using it that way is a waste of your time and resources. And it casts a negative light on a product that some of us have found beneficial.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Antique Forum 'Deer-Once Bloomers'

  • 13 years ago

    windeaux:

    The roses are now being drenched. I won't be confident in the effectiveness of the product until a couple blooming cycles are complete. Of the three HT only one is currently undergoing any new growth. The deer started on some unsprayed roses and moved on to ones that had been sprayed. One of the roses away from my little rose garden was munched on slightly a few days ago and it had been sprayed reasonably. I'm still not optimistic.

  • 13 years ago

    Steve...

    For what it's worth, Mrs. J's HTs and floribundas were chomped on by deer for three years before I got them caged. I've left 'Margo Koster' uncaged simply because I don't like the color of the blooms and haven't gotten around to re-working that bed and the deer still chomp and the rose always comes back.

    Good luck with your project.

    Smiles,
    Lyn

  • 13 years ago

    When I had over 100 bushes they always came back, but the deer got almost all the flowers, so what's the point.

    The deer leave my lemon tree alone, so I can always make lemonade.

  • 13 years ago

    Steve,
    If the deer leave your lemon tree alone, why not try putting cut lemons among your roses' canes? Or buying some lemon oil and applying that to the roses instead of smelly Liquid Fence? Who knows--it might work. I sure hope it does. Diane

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Columbus' Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting