Software
Houzz Logo Print
whaas_5a

Good Evening Tree Connoisseurs

16 years ago

I'm wondering if anyone can help me decide between these three trees. I have the space...plenty of sun...good soil...average moisture (not wet, not dry).

Liriodendron Tulipifera

Quercus bicolor

Fagus grandifolia

Leaning towards Liriodendron Tulipifera

Comments (19)

  • 16 years ago

    Planting BIG trees, my favorite.

    Hmmmm. how much room do you have? I think Fagus grandifolia will eventually have the largest spread, maybe 100 foot. I think of this as footprint. Impressive. My neighbor has a Quercus macrocarpa, burr oak, off to the side of his 250 foot wide front yard. Boy would I love to have that massive tree. Someday the a beech would probably get that wide with its low branching habit. Do you have the room for that?

    Speaking of someday, around here I would bet the Liriodendron Tulipifera is the fastest growing of the three, then the Quercus bicolor with the Fagus grandifolia slowest. I have no patience lol.

    The flowers of the Liriodendron are a big positive for me. Even on big trees in parks I notice them.

    Fruit...acorn litter doesn't bother me. Tulip tree seeds seem to stay on the tree until they go....decay or whatever. Beech nuts, edible I read. Wonder if their pokey selves are annoying as I don't own one. Will this overhang a walkway where this is important even?

    Fall color: Last year the Liriodendrons were attractive yellow around here, usually they're just ok. Beech turn a decent color also. Them and the oak hold their leaves sometimes if that bothers you. The White Oak sometimes has pretty good darker color. Type of understated classy thing that makes the local forests look good in late fall.

    Bark? Beeches stay smooth. The other two are more generic tree like. Local Tulip trees have IMPRESSIVE trunks when old.

    Structure? Got a favorite branching pattern of the 3? The Beech is probably the lowest and widest.

    Personally what would I choose? My neighbor has a Liriodendron so I can watch it, its even on my side of his yard. There are 4 oaks also between my yard and my two neighbors, no white oaks though. Probably the Fagus if I had the room. The White oak if it had to go anywhere near ANYTHING else.

  • 16 years ago

    Well, personally, of the three, I'd go with a Tulip Tree as well. The flowers are just so beautiful, and it is a nice tree overall.

    I had one going that was planted in the late 1970's, and it was just getting large enough it was starting to flower well, and, wouldn't you know it, it was hit by lightning and then spent 2 years slowly dying.

    I planted a new one 2 years ago, but of course, they don't grow all that fast here in the northern edge of their range.

  • 16 years ago

    The beech, hands down.

  • 16 years ago

    Liriodendron - It's redolent of the long lost Arcto-Tertiary forests.

  • 16 years ago

    Liriodendron. Sometimes breaks up, in the manner of a poplar - plant well away from structures etc.

  • 16 years ago

    Reminder, Lirodendron is not a poplar, it's a magnolia.

  • 16 years ago

    I typically try to stick with the scientific name for trees that have multiple accepted common names.

    Tree is going to the back lotline in the corner, which butts to a commercial easement and berm that can never be built on. Closest structure is 90' away.

    It will however hang over my neighbors lot line at some point.

    Should I be responsible now and not get something that will cause litter issues down the road? We're talking at least 20 years down the road before the trees overhangs the neighbors lotline. Right now there are several unattended natives growing in his area...Black Cherry, Hawthron, Viburnum.

    Are acrons from Q.bicolor an annoyance? I rarely see squirrels now...not sure if I should invite them in our not, lol.

  • 16 years ago

    I have a beech and it grows about a foot each year,it,s the slowest grower of all my trees, even slower than burr oak, my soil is good so thats not an issue.Just thought I,d mention it to you if you want something to give shade in your lifetime.

  • 16 years ago

    It doesn't sound like you've got the site for swamp white oak. And you're really on the fringe for tuliptree. Beech is indeed slow growing but they are magnificent trees. Old growth stands are breathtaking. They are the type of tree to plant for future generations to enjoy. I rarely see American Beech planted in cultivation but they are common around here in the woods. I always take notice of them.

    If you can find a b&b size, I'm already jealous.

  • 16 years ago

    Its a tree I'm planting for the future...a foot actually isn't too bad compared to my gingko's 8"!lol!

    Sounds like I'd be set with either the liro or the fagus.

    The beeches I've seen at the Morton Arb are quite majestic.

    My only concern is the hardiness of the liro...I've been told juvenile plants in our area are marginal hardy and adults are hardy.

  • 16 years ago

    If it's supposed to last for a long time you don't want a tree that could die back or crack open during a record winter that may occur 50 or 100 years from now.

  • 16 years ago

    Here is what I'm looking at...they all seem fairly reasonable.

    1.75" Swamp White Oak = $140
    1.75" American beech = $130
    1.75" Tulip tree = $120

    I just might make the call once I see the stock and actually INSPECT the rootflare. All three seem like good trees (the beech and oak are WI natives but I rarely seem them in landscapes).

  • 16 years ago

    Why not just plant a white oak, q. alba? Why bicolor?

    Tuliptree is a rapid grower and fun to watch. I have to actually thin stands of them behind my house where they pop up all over the place but one of my favorite trees none the less. If you said you primarily wanted a tree for shade while you'll be living in that house, I'd say plant something like tuliptree.

    But since you've now come out and said you are looking to plant a legacy tree, that's more along the order of slower growing trees like beech, white oak, sugar maples et cetera.

    Prices sound reasonable if they are retail prices.

    I saw that a park about 45 mins from here planted an allee of American beeches with about 15' spacing and it was a really cool looking effect. It created a lot of shade and the trees didn't look that old.

    Some things you might be concerned about with beeches,
    * easily damaged bark/ easily invaded by insects
    * difficulty in transplanting
    * surface roots and suckers
    * spring raking
    * not much grows under them
    * their fruit can leave a cleanup job but then so can oak acorns.

  • 16 years ago

    I think the only thing I'd be concerned about would be the insects. Do you mean "easily" as in more susceptible than other trees?

    I understand every tree is susceptible to problems but for example a Ginkgo is much much less susceptible to insect damage than a Black Cherry.

    I'm not worried about breakage on the tuliptree, just the hardiness.

    I just want a good solid tree that will likely be free of pest and disease. If there are other trees out there that you'd recommend that may be a better choice I'm all ears!

    Its full sun, somewhat protected from southwest winds, average moisture. And it can really be any size...but at least 30 x 20.

  • 16 years ago

    I know it seems like break-up on the tuliptree might not be an issue, but I just paid to have a 60 feet tall one dropped, that had been damaged gradually by wind, to the point it looked terrible. Many of the younger tuliptrees around it are also damaged, and will have to go. Maybe we just get a lot of wind here, but having seen what I've seen, I'd never use them as a legacy tree. Just sayin'.

  • 16 years ago

    I think beech is relatively trouble free but is susceptible to the beech scale insect that attacks the bark, resulting in beech bark disease. Aside from that, aphids which are not a big deal.

    If you're open to other legacy tree ideas, take a look at red oak, white oak, sugar maple, hickories. You might also be interested in sycamore. They're rapid growers. Very adaptable and can live hundreds of years.

  • 16 years ago

    I'd say in my area the best looking trees planted from the 60/70s are definitely the bur oaks and sugar maples.

    red oak is another consideration just don't know how I feel about is higher susceptibility to oak wilt.

  • 16 years ago

    Got back from the nursery. The Tuliptrees where all sold, and they looked really good so I'm not surprised.

    The American Beech in stock were all poorly branched.

    The Swamp White Oak I found had amazing peely bark and a branching structure to be envied...I guess I'll be dealing with acorns.

    Everyone, thanks for all the help!

    Another tree I came across was a Pagoda Dogwood...I can't believe how amazing all the specimans looked. I wish I had a spot for it!

  • 16 years ago

    Ok, so I'd pick the Fagus grandifolia. It doesn't looks like yours will be in the front yard so you won't have to worry about growing grass under it. (Nothing really grows under the American Beech once established as the shade is VERY dense).