Software
Houzz Logo Print
gardningscomplicated

Help!!!! Is my compost too alkaline?

My city's composting center was selling compost really cheap this year, so I just had 12 yards delivered. They said a large order was canceled--something to do with the bad economy--so they were selling the compost they had this year really cheap, to make room for next year's. So I got 12 yards of compost for $174, including the delivery charge.

Then I happened to notice the compost's test results on the city's website. So I looked it over, and now I'm kinda concerned. This is a link to the test results pdf: 7-page PDF. In particular, I'm worried about the pH of 8.3. I also bought a couple of those diy pH test kits, and I can't really tell, but I think both of them are telling me my compost is very alkaline.

I was planning to use this compost for 2 things.

1) I'm trying straw bale gardening this year. I'm growing tomatoes in straw bales, and I was going to put some of this compost on top of the bales.

2) I'm also trying some kind of "lasagna gardening". I was going to mix approximately equal parts compost and straw to make some raised beds. And I'm planning to grow corn, beans, squash, cucumbers, and maybe some melons.

But now I'm worried that my soil is going to be too alkaline. And I read that alkaline soil can give you some pretty bland tasting tomatoes. If I'm SOL, I'd rather just get the bad news out of the way quickly, so I have time to find some better compost before it's too late to plant anything. But if this compost will work, it would be a lot easier. Otherwise, what am I gonna do with this huge pile of dirt I just had delivered? Does anyone have any advice? Thanks.

Comments (15)

  • 17 years ago

    1. My experience with tomatoes grown in a bale of straw is they have no taste, just like those you buy in at the grocers.
    2. Compost and straw could be a start of a Lasagna bed but much more diverse material is needed to complete that bed.
    Something is wrong with that compost if it does have a pH of 8.3 since good finished compost will be around 7.0, maybe they add large volumes of wood ash to the compost.

  • 17 years ago

    Elemental sulfur will drop the pH, but probably not quickly enough to use this year.

  • 17 years ago

    That stuff has a bunch of lime in it. 310 lbs. per ton to be exact. To put it into perspective (using the bulk densities provided), if used as a soil amendment at a typical use rate of 5 cubic yards per 1000 sq. ft. to a 6 inch depth, this compost would be adding about 600 lbs. per 1000 sq. ft. of lime (yikes).
    Another thing that I find a little wonky is that when planting cucumbers in a control (vermiculite and peat) and in this stuff, the seeds in the compost only had 50% germination and their growth was significantly stunted compared to the control (hence the vigor of 0%).
    I didn't look super close at the data but those are two things that jumped out at me.

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks everyone for the input. I talked to the guy who did the analysis, and I'm doing some more research on my own. Right now, I think I'll probably be able to use the compost with ok results.

    Here's what I'm thinking...

    1) The results were a couple months old, so maybe it's cured more since then. I _think_ that would help with the germination problem. And maybe some of the lime washed out? I'm not sure about the wood ash though. Is this just wishful thinking?

    2) I'm going to go ahead with my original plans, and then do some testing of the resulting soil, and ammend it if it really seems necessary. I just don't want to find out after it's too late that the pH screwed things up, and gave me bland tasting tomatoes.

    3) I'm hoping compost tea, nettles tea, and various companion plants mixed in will give the tomatoes enough nutrients, so they don't end up tasting like those orange tennis balls you get from the grocery store.

    I'm aware that the compost is probably less than perfect. But it may be good enough for now. One of my biggest concerns is, if I use it, will I end up raising the pH of the soil, so it's difficult to correct later on, like next year?

  • 17 years ago

    It should equalize eventually with all that organic matter in there. Just may take some time. If it really is ash or lime, the effects of those will dissipate eventually. Did the guy you talked to have any explanation for the high pH? We're just guessing.

  • 17 years ago

    Good luck with your compost.
    I just wanted to say thanks for the tip about alkaline soil making tomatoes taste bland. I never researched why my tomatoes tasted.... like.. well... nothing since moving back to Wisconsin. But, I do have slightly alkaline soil. Thanks for the aha! moment. :-)
    I think I'll add tomatoes to the list of things that get fed leftover coffee.
    THX

  • 17 years ago

    toxcrusadr,

    Thanks. Now I'm not worried that I'll be screwing up my soil permanently:) The guy could only say what _may_ have caused the high pH. He couldn't tell me anything for sure. But if the lime and wood ash will eventually dissipate, I think I can find a way to acidify it in the short term.

    cantstopgardening,

    Your welcome. And thanks for the idea about the coffee. That may be just what I need to acidify my soil while I'm waiting for it to neutralize on its own. I was reading that Starbucks will package up their used coffee grounds in their empty coffee bean bags, and give them to you for free if you ask. I guess it's one of their company policies now. And they have a web page about using it in your garden: Grounds for your garden.

  • 17 years ago

    coffee is acidic, but coffee grounds aren't, so if you're looking to acidify your soil, adding coffee might help to a small extent, but adding the grounds won't help.

  • 17 years ago

    bpgreen,

    I've read that some people who used coffee grounds tested their soil, and it did become more acidic. I know that the grounds themselves are pretty much neutral, but I'm thinking there's still enough "acidic coffee" in them that leeches out when they get wet. And maybe that's enough to temporarily acidify the soil so the plant roots can absorb what they need. I don't really know if that's true, I'm just guessing. But according to everything I've read, coffee grounds do help for some reason. So, even if they don't actually lower the pH, they may still help the plants get the nutrients they need. And that's my real concern. I may do some experiments to see what really happens to the pH of the soil. Both short term in the root zone shortly after watering, and long term. I just need to find a cheap reliable way to do the testing. I have 2 soil test kits, and I don't trust either one. I'm thinking about just getting some litmus paper.

  • 17 years ago

    What ever you do don't use elemental sulfur to alter pH. It's an antibiotic, so would be counterproductive.

    Terran

  • 17 years ago

    I don't plan to use sulfur, since it probably wouldn't work in time. But I did find this about coffee grounds, saw dust, and pine needles: wikibooks tomato info

    The relevant part is:
    ------
    Tomato plants need acidic (5.0 to 6.0 pH) soil, a balance between the three primary fertilizer nutrients, and thrive in warm weather. Inexpensive ways to naturally increase soil acidity include using pine needles as mulch, and mixing either used coffee grounds or sawdust into the soil. Pine needles (and the soil under pine trees) are very acidic, and though used coffee grounds are not very acidic, they and sawdust cause a chemical change in the soil, lowering its pH. Fresh coffee grounds, or a 4:1 dilution of water:coffee, can be used for a quick, direct acidity boost.
    ------

    They just say it works, without giving any supporting info. So who knows if it's really true. But it sounds reasonable, and goes along with what I was thinking. So I think it's worth trying. And I have lots of pine needles in my yard, so maybe I'll try that too if I can't get enough coffee.

  • 17 years ago

    I was just reading that coffee grounds may be a squirrel deterrent too. Does anyone know if that's true? I just started a new thread in the pests & diseases forum, since it's getting off-topic here pests & diseases thread

  • 17 years ago

    That's interesting. I've spread a lot of used grounds on my lawn and the pH is lower, but not a lot lower. I've been attributing that to added organic matter moving the pH closer to neutral. I've been composting a lot of them and using the compost around a tree that doesn't like the alkaline soil I have, so maybe I should spread more of them as-is.

  • 17 years ago

    Research done by Dr. Abigail Maynhard at the New Haven Agricultural Research Station in New Haven, Conn. found that even after years of adding Oak leaves and pine needles to garden plots there was no significant change in the soils pH, so I doubt that coffee grounds or peat moss wil have any significant affect on soil pH either.
    Soil pH is the result of how many free, radical Hydrogen ions are floating around in your soil, or not. The more there are the lower your soils pH and the fewer there are the higher your soils pH. Lime can change how many of those Hydrogen ions are floating freely while sulfur can add more, but the balance between the Calcium and Magnesium in your soil can also influence your soils pH because you need those in balance just like all the other nutrients in yoru soil.

  • 17 years ago

    kimmsr,

    Do you know the specifics of the research? I'd be interested to find out if she measured the short term effects, or just long term. And what the pH was to begin with. For example, there may not be a significant effect long term on a soil with a pH of 6. But maybe there is a significant short term effect on soil with a pH of 8. And maybe not. And generalizing her findings for pine needles and oak leaves, to coffee grounds, may not be valid. I think you'd need to do coffee specific research, to know the effects of coffee. There are a lot of complex interactions going on, and a slight variation in who knows what may change the entire outcome.