Software
Houzz Logo Print
dicouris

Planting Austins in threes

14 years ago

Hi,

Next year, I'm thinking of planting some Austin Roses in groups of threes as recommended on their website, and I'd like to hear from folks who have done this. I see that the suggested planting distance is 18" apart. I assume this means I place them at the three corners of an 18" sided triangle; is that correct? Then they suggest to space the groups about three feet apart. I'm looking at Lady of Shalott & LD Braithwaite, maybe Munstead Wood. What dimensions (across) would I expect this these cluster-shrubs to grow? How do you like this approach? Related question - has anyone grown Munstead Wood in a cold climate, and how well has it weathered?

Thanks! Di

Comments (12)

  • 14 years ago

    One of the reasons for this recommendation could be to increase sales for DA Ltd. Remember also that most of these varieties grow much larger in most US locales than they do in the UK. I do have Prospero planted in a group of 3 because it is so small. Some others that would be suited to this treatment are Wife of Bath, Pretty Jessica, Sophy's Rose, and Fair Bianca (but I don't recommend Fair Bianca).

    In my climate, LDB grows too big for that treatment. If you are a true zone 5, of course, winter damage might change the calculation.

  • 14 years ago

    In Southern California, L.D. Braithwaite grew canes to the top of my 12-ft retaining wall. The idea of planting three of them boggles the mind.

    But that's CA. Maybe that Z5 climate might change the situation.

    Jeri
    Coastal Ventura Co., SoCal

  • 14 years ago

    Munstead Woods is 4x4 here, very nicely bushy. I think planting it in groups of 3 18" apart would be too close. It may be smaller in your zone but I think the shape is still quite full on its own.

    I tried planting a group of 3 once with William Shakespeare 2000 and it was ok and grew together, but one of the roses struggled and it looked a little off-balanced. I ended up removing one and relocating one to grow as a single rose shape and liked it better.

  • 14 years ago

    I grow almost thirty varieties of Austin roses in a borderline zone 5 climate. If you already grow roses and have to winter protect the tender varieties, then you should have no worries about planting virtually any Austin variety in groups of three. I have two semi formal rose beds with groups of Austin roses planted 18 to 24 inches appart and they do well and put on a good massed display that way. Even some of those who want to climb in milder places such as California, or the Pacific Northwest, such as Abe Darby, TEasing Georgia and the Pilgrim are small shrubs here, no more than 3 feet tall.

    So my answer to your question would be yes, in a cold climate. Plant them close and you will get a much better display IMHO.

    You will also likely have to winter protect, mulch with manure and fertilize and water every second day in hot weather to get them to grow and bloom well under difficult climatic conditions. Don't be suprised if they are cut virtually to the ground in winter even with mulch. The best ones will come back and do just fine. It is a lot of work to grow tender roses well in a difficult climate, but my Austins are worth the effort.

    {{gwi:278887}}

    A bed containing mostly Austins in June.

    {{gwi:278888}}

    Same bed ready for winter in early December.

    I don't grow any of the three you mention here, but suspect both L D Braithwaite and Munstead Wood would do fairly well. Braithwaite is a bit of a sprauler in a warmer climate though and the best Austin roses to fill out a bed in a cold climate are the more upright growers.

    Some of my best performers for both habit and rebloom are:

    Evelyne, Saint Cecilia, Charles Darwin, Redoute, Crocus Rose and Mary Rose.

    Cheers,

    Rideau Rose Lad, aka Rick

  • 14 years ago

    Uh-oh.I tried planting a group of three Falstaffs together on a sort of tripod, in the hopes of getting them to climb. But here in Italy, my climate is certainly NOT cold!!!Wonder what will happen...I just planted them last fall, so can't really judge how they are doing really; it's too soon. bart

  • 14 years ago

    Great input, so very helpful. It does sound like Braithwaite is too big for what I'm planning, at least not three together!

    Last year I planted my first Austins, Falstaff & Graham Thomas, against a south facing wall. Rick, thanks for the pics of your winter prep. I actually used hay last year, but not nearly as much, this year I won't be so shy. Luckily we had an extremely mild winter. Silly Falstaff tried to sprout leaves all winter long. Now Falstaff is reaching 6' ft high without support - time to get a trellis behind it though. So Bart, Falstaff in a group of three will be a mammoth, I'd love to see pictures, assuming your tripod holds up. The growth of GT has been more horizontal, a problem in this spot because he gets battered by rain rainfall from the roof edge above and looks cramped against the wall. Definitely needs a trellis or a new home.

    Here's little more info on my scheme for next year. For color - deep crimson contrasted with apricot. I'm growing Grace this year, which is lovely, but I'm looking for a deeper apricot for the new bed. It will be abut 20' long in a wide open area (no wind breaks, so hardy is important). It's a border between lawn and street, about 10' in from the road. I don't have a lot of depth to work with, and I don't want it to look like a hedge. I imagine I could go 2 plants deep, and I got wondering about the planting in 3s approach. The look I want is like the GT, broad plants with arching growth rather than the upright Falstaff. Tall is ok if there will be horizontal balance.

    Lady of Shalott is touted as very hardy and in photos I've seen, it's the perfect color. Munstead's color looks wonderful but I thought it might be a bit short next to LoS, so Lori it's encouraging to hear you say 4x4. Is it as deep a color as advertised, and does it fade much? Wilt? Michael, could you tell me more about Prospero? I found that when I search for red/crimson on the DA website, Prospero is not in the results. So I now realize that their filtered search is not showing me nearly all that they have, and wondering all that I might be missing. I'm open to any suggestions, not just Austins. I would like good repeat blooming for this bed.
    Thanks! Di

  • 14 years ago

    'Prospero' is listed by DA USA for next season, and it is sold by many vendors. It is a very good rose, but the plant is small and slow-growing. I have an own-root plant that grows as well as those grafted on multiflora. It repeats well and has nearly continuous scattered bloom. It has above-average disease resistance. Flowers are delightful, a flat rosette with many petals neatly arranged; true dark red that ages through garnet to mauve in concentric zones on the same flower; fragrant and OK for cutting. My plants are 3' x 2' wide. Mike_rivers grows it in central Michigan zone 5.

  • 14 years ago

    Yes, Munstead Woods is a nice deep crimson-red color. I like it very much and the scent is rich and strong old-rose fragrance too. I also grow Prospero which is a lot smaller here -- 2' high range. It is a bright red to me.

  • 14 years ago

    Yes, when Austins are planted in 3s, that means in sort of a triangle shape. Personally, I would only do that with a somewhat narrow or more vertically growing rose--which is what I did with Molineux. I loved the blooms, but they weren't making much of a statement with the one 3-ft somewhat narrow bush, so I planted 2 more, about 18 inches apart (maybe just a bit more) so that they formed a triangle. Loved the result. To visitors, it looks like one big lush semi-sprawling bush--just the effect I wanted.

    I might also plant an Austin like Queen of Sweden in 3s since she also is more upright, but I don't think I'd ever try planting a sprawler like Shakespeare 2000 in 3so--you'd have to plant them about 2.5 ft apart and in 3s, they would probably take up half your garden all by themselves. That is why I would only consider 3s for slimmer roses bushes that don't make a big enough impact by themselves.

    Don't know if Lady of Shalott in 3s is a good idea or not. Mine is just a few months old, but is already beginning to form a nice full bush. True, it doesn't sprawl like Shakespeare 2000, but I'd fear that the Lady in threes would end up as too big, too full. I'm anticipating that the Lady will make a fine impression all by herself. (She's one of my favorite roses--great rebloomer, no disease--don't know how winter hardy yet, but she's just about perfect in every other respect so far!).

    One other consideration: The Lady's shape and size are very different than the other Austins you mention. Perhaps you are looking for contrasts in size and shape? If not, you need to select Austins that have similar growing habits.

    Good luck with your planning--planning if often half the fun!

    Kate

  • 14 years ago

    I think I need a field trip to Albrighton to see all these plants in person... Is there a crimson that is very much like Lady of Shalott in size and shape?
    Thanks,
    Di

  • 14 years ago

    Sorry, Di, but right off hand, I don't know a crimson like Lady of Shalott. The only crimson Austin I grow is Shakespeare 2000 which is certainly NOT like Lady of Shalott and is planted on the other side of the back yard, no where near her.

    Good luck with your planning.

    Kate

  • 14 years ago

    ratdogheads - unfortunately not, would be nice if there was. I planted Wollerton Old Hall last year because I like the chalice shape - that is a really nice rose. You guys can't get it yet but if they release it over there it is definitely worth growing. I have just planted Heathcliff, the new crimson so will post a pic of that when it gets going. Re groups of three - I think it is a very good way of getting a 'show' and makes a better shape early on. I have some planted in a three and they do look good. As with spacing, even the larger varieties go close together, so they form a tight group. Down at his nursery they grow them in threes in pots even the bigger varieties. If you planted two feet apart they would look like three roses planted together not one big rose. To be fair though, they take up more room and therefore you can grow less varieties and it is expensive!!