Software
Houzz Logo Print
nanderso_gw

too much phosphorus

17 years ago

I recently had the soil tested in my raised vegetable garden box. The test results state that there is an extremely high level of phosphorus in the box. Per the attached guidance from the extension office, excess phosphorus can lead to an iron deficiency. Could this be why my tomato plants are somewhat stunted looking and the leaves are yellow-ish? And why my zucchini plants are barely a foot in diameter while my neighbor's (with whom I shared a six pack of plants) has zucchini that's about three feet wide? Other than the excess phosphorus, I hope the soil is basically fine? 6.9 pH and medium - high levels of potassium, magnesium and calcium. Any thoughts?

Comments (9)

  • 17 years ago

    Excess soil Phosphorus levels can keep your plants from uptaking Zinc, Iron, and Cobalt, all essential micronutrients and that could be why your tomatoes are stunted and chlorotic.
    What is the level of organic matter in your soil?

  • 17 years ago

    Definitely can be the problem, hinders Mn and Zn uptake also.

  • 17 years ago

    I don't believe I've ever seen a cobalt deficiency. Not saying it doesn't happen but what would it look like?

  • 17 years ago

    Cobalt is a micro nutrient that can contribute to chlorosis, yellowing of the plant leaves.

  • 17 years ago

    It's my understanding that cobalt is a non-essential element and that plants can get along just fine without it, but may derive some small benefit if it's there. I can't seem to find a single documented case of cobalt deficiency causing chlorosis in plants.
    This best I could come up with was this:
    "cobalt probably participates in chlorophyll b formation"

    But there is nothing about cobalt being vital to the process, only that it "probably participates". (Earlier in the article it actually states that decreasing cobalt increases 'chlorophyll a' and chloroplast production). Nor are there any documented cases of a cobalt deficiency or a statement of what symptoms might be expected if cobalt uptake were low.

    Can you help me out and point me towards any documentation supporting the claim that cobalt deficiency leads to chlorosis, or any other symptom, in plants?

    By the way, if you read through that article there is all kinds of fun stuff. Like this: "Apical application of COC12 (50-100 ~tg/plant) to female plants of Cannabis sativa
    caused drying of the shoot tip and formation of axillary branches which bore male,reduced male, and intersexual flowers along with female flowers."

    In other words, you better not spill your cobalt on your pot plant unless you want to give it a sex change.

    See kids? Who says science ain't fun?

  • 17 years ago

    I heard that germanium and tellurium do the same thing.

  • 17 years ago

    kimmsr, can you help me out?

  • 17 years ago

    since plants only need miniscule amounts of Cobalt there has been very little research into what it does for plants, except for some notes that it can contribute to chlorosis and might be necessary for proper development of chlorofil.
    Soils with adequate levels of organic matter will seldom have Cobalt deficiencies.

  • 17 years ago

    My understanding is that cobalt is known to be part of the structure of vitamin B12. B12 is produced by bacteria, not by plants and animals. One can imagine how B12 gets into fish tissue, working its way up the food chain. I am not clear, however, how it gets into land animals, like cows, for instance. Either it is taken up by plants, which end up as forage for the cow, or it is produced by bacteria living in the gut, and absorbed into the bloodstream of the animal, across the intestinal wall. It seems possible that cobalt is essential to maintain a full spectrum of soil bacteria, and that this could contribute to plant health. I think there is more that we don't know about soil bacteria, than there is that we do know. As if knowledge could be counted and quantified.