Software
Houzz Logo Print
rosecats_gw

Water not penetrating compost layer

17 years ago

Hi,

I applied a layer of compost on top of my sheet composting layers. I found that water isn't penetrating the compost - when I stir it up after watering thoroughly, it's dry underneath. It's fine-textured compost (purchased), consisting of composted garden waste, chicken feathers, brown rice hulls & duck manure. I didn't have enough homemade stuff to use & this stuff is cheap but highly regarded locally.

I'd love to hear what y'all think - will this problem sort it self out, or should I do something? I thought I might rake in some other compost or scatter a bit of some other compost on top.

Thanks!

Comments (21)

  • 17 years ago

    Give us some more information. How deep are your sheet compost layers, and what are they made of? Is there paper or cardboard on the bottom, and did you soak it befor building on top of it? Did you water each layer very well as you built the sheet compost? This is how it should be done; once the hump is built dry it's next to impossible to moisten.

    Also how much compost is on top of the layers?

    Karen

  • 17 years ago

    The pertinent thing is that the water isn't penetrating past the very top of the compost - the compost layer is about an inch thick, and only 1/16 of an inch or so of the compost was wet. It appears to be a water-repelling compost.

    The layers aren't thick; in fact, I'll probably build it up more as the veggies grow (I'm getting a late start on this garden!). I used 1 layer of cardboard or used grocery bags, an inch or so of alfalfa & then an inch of compost.

    This compost reminds me of some potting soils I've used for containers - the kind that lets the water run off rather than absorbing the water.

    Thanks for any help.

  • 17 years ago

    I have had similar problems using peat moss as a mulch on blueberry shrubs. It dries out eventually, and then it is nearly impossible to get any water down into the roots. I got rid of the peat moss, and started using shredded cypress. That was several years ago. Now I use shredded maple leaves, from our own tree. This material always accepts water. In your situation, I would remove the offending compost, but I wouldn't throw it away. I would put the material on a compost pile, and add garden refuse and weeds, whatever the yard & garden produce, and maybe it will be useable next season. Our garden is mulched with straw, but I think shredded tree leaves would also work as a mulch in a vegetable garden.

  • 17 years ago

    Any type of organic matter that is allowed to get too dry will become hydrophobic, water repelling, because it has formed a crust that is meant to help retain the soisture that was in the soil. You will notice the same problem with just soil. To rewet that can take much time and effort.
    How long have you been applying water in an attempt to rewet that compost? A few minutes of a few hours?

  • 17 years ago

    I haven't spent much time yet in trying to rewet it. Maybe 10 minutes, something like that. I guess I'll get out there with the hose for as long as I can stand to water!

  • 17 years ago

    Do you have a sprinkler or a soaker hose?

    Where do you live? It helps when giving gardening advice to know your climate. Do you live near Phoenix, AZ, Seattle, WA or Washington DC.

  • 17 years ago

    I forgot about a sprinkler - we're in a drought, so I haven't used them this year. I'll set that up for one-time use. I'm in northern CA, so I can't hope for rain to help out - we won't have that until October.

  • 17 years ago

    Rosecats: I made the mistake this spring of piling fresh grass clippings around the apple trees for mulch and extended it out past the drip lines. Stupid me I knew better but didn't think about it. Worked great last year but we had rain all summer last year. This year has been extremely dry and the mulch matted down and dried out. About 3 weeks ago I started sprinkler watering the trees not realizing the water wasn't penetrating the mulch. By last week, the trees appeared to be suffering drought stress, didn't make any sense to me. Next I sprinkled them again, this time for 1 hr 45 min.. Fortunately, immediately after I pulled back a small portion of the mulch to check for penetration, dry as a bone! Duh! That mulch is now pulled back away from the drip line but I since realized that all I needed to do was break up the mat so the water could run through the dried grass.

    Lesson re-learned.

  • 17 years ago

    Have you tried forming a water basin around the plants?

    I have to do this in my pure-sand soil because otherwise the water just runs off and its the same in the beds that are halve sand and half compost -- once its dry the water runs off so everything MUST be planted in a basin or trench.

  • 17 years ago

    Rosecats: Assuming you don't have watering bans, a slow drip with a soaker hose might be your best bet. Poke and mix it to get the layers moist. If you feel energetic, you could carry buckets of gray water from the house to add too.

    I assume there are no plants in this area yet? If not, it might be best to wait until the weather is ready to rain and help you along. But if that stuff is dry, it's not going to break down.

    Karen

  • 17 years ago

    Thank for your input, everyone! Our watering restrictions aren't stringent (yet), so I can set up the sprinkler for a period of time in the early morning. This plot is actually at a community garden, so I probably won't shlep my grey water there - in fact, I'm using it for the lawn. Great idea, tho!

    The funny thing about this compost is that it looks finished. There's a lot of fine-textured stuff, and every gardener who sees it wants it. It has a fairly strong ammonia smell, so maybe that means it's still a bit hot?

  • 17 years ago

    Spraying water on anything for 10 minutes will not accomplish anything worthwhile. If the soil, or compost, is quite dry it can take an hour, minimum, for that soil to even begin allowing water the penetrate. Anytime you do water your garden plant on about 2 hours if watering in any once place, which is about how long it would take with most watering systems to get 1 inch of water down.

  • 17 years ago

    rosecats if it smells like ammonia it is not finished.

    For sure 10 minutes is too short but I think that the 2 hours that kimmsr mentioned is probably too much. If you're using sprinklers then place out some old tuna fish cans, cat food cans or something similar then you'll be able to measure how much water you're putting on.

  • 17 years ago

    Re gjcores suggestion, the more cans the better.

  • 17 years ago

    With the water system I have, 50 psi, it takes 2 hours for a sprinkler to deliver 1 inch of water in any location in the yard. since the criteria most eveyone uses is that you need to apply 1 inch of water each week that is how long it takes. Each system could be somewhat different, and if you do have on your outside faucet that vacuum breaker that the plumbing code requires today how much water is delivered in how much time will change from before that was installed.
    But yes, set out some straight sided cans, or other containers, in several locations to catch the water your sprinkling system delivers and time how long it takes to get that 1 inch of water in each of those containers.

  • 17 years ago

    Rice hulls! They are slightly waxy.

    Try putting a soaker hose or drip line UNDER them and it's a great moisture retainer.

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks again for your input.

    I ended up hand watering for about an hour & I could see that the compost was starting to absorb the water, tho the alfalfa layer below was dry. I decided to apply a little more alfalfa, thinking that having another layer on top might help the compost to absorb the water since a little less would evaporate. In any event, I felt badly about watering so long during our drought.

    I'll take out some tuna cans (I planned to make tuna salad soon anyway!) to see how much water is being applied. Great idea! Michael, you're right - I should have a number of cans, since I'm hand-watering - it'll help me check whether I'm watering evenly.

    The roots probably are getting adequate water, since the plants were set a tad low - newbie problem w/ homemade gopher cages - also I suppose they're getting some of the runoff that the compost isn't absorbing?

    I guess I'll water a little extra every time I water until all the lasagne layers have asborbed their share of water.

  • 17 years ago

    sorry- posted a similar question above _but_

    you folks are talking about 1-2 _hours_ of watering!

    1-2 hours of watering, unless it is only a couple of times a year is a thing of the past for many of us (worldwide.)

    i am interested in those rice hulls though

  • 17 years ago

    I had this exact problem with some purchased compost made from stable stall sweepings. Mine was mostly pine shavings and horse urine, with some horse manure and bits of hay/feed, and I used most of it to mix in a raised bed.

    The left over pile from where the truck dumped it was sitting there, and I was tired, so I planted directly into it cos the seller advertised that you could and I really wanted to believe him.

    I got the same problem you describe, and I was so surprised! I thought all compost attracted water like a ShamWow. My stuff was like Teflon compost. It took long, long, slow waterings to wet it, and over the last two years the parts that remain unmixed have not improved on their own. I have to mix it with some mineral dirt (read: clay) to make it behave normally, and it has to be at about 1/4-1/3 dirt. Then it's great stuff. That's the way nature works, so I shouldn't have been so surprised, but I was.

  • 17 years ago

    There is no need to stand there for two hours. Water for a few minutes. Let it soak in. Come back later. Water.

    Dan

  • 17 years ago

    You need to get enough water into the soil for the plants to use and that can take, depending on your water delivery system, 2 hours to get that 1 inch of water into the soil. Since there are options other than overhead sprinkling (one is not simply standing there with a nozzle in hand and spraying with that) such as soaker hoses, or drip irrigation systems that is something that needs to be looked at as well as a good thick mulch on the garden.
    Mel Bartholomew, in his Square Foot Gardening" book tells you that you need to apply somewhere between 4 cups of water every 3-1/2 days to 10 cups of water every 9 days depending on the type of soil your have. However that is also if you have a good, healthy soil that is well mulched.

Sponsored
Miller Woodworks
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars23 Reviews
Franklin County's Trusted Custom Cabinetry Solutions