Software
Houzz Logo Print
crystalgeorgia

Fragrant cloud, Just Joey OPINION needed

18 years ago

Anyone grow these roses in GA?

Please opinion needed..

Fragrant cloud, Just Joey, P.Meilland

cherry parfait, peace, glowing peace, arizona

apricot nectar

Thanks in advaNCE

Comments (5)

  • 18 years ago

    Well, I'm not in GA, but Maryland is quite hot and humid.

    P meilland: I have 5 plants 3 own root, 2 grafted from 4 different sources (I love Papa!) Fragrant, very good repeat. Own-root stays around 3 feet tall, bushy and not very leggy. Grafted can easily get 5 plus feet, stout caned and somewhat upright and leggy. Very good BS resistance, but I do spray every 2 weeks.

    Fragrant Cloud - own root, only 2 years old, about 3 feet tall, great fragrance, I like this plant better w/ afternoon shade so the color doesn't get too orangey. Clean w/ spraying every 2 weeks.

    Peace - I have supposedly one of the older Peace plants from an old mother plant from the 50's. (From the nice people in Laurens, SC - can't recall the nursery's name) I know this is supposedly a classic, but it doesn't do much for me. It does get BS, even w/ spraying, and the color just washes out. Barely any fragrance to my nose. Maybe it doesn't like the heat?

    Just Joey - I've tried this one 2 x's, but ended yanking it both times for poor production, BS, and general puny-ness. Own-root both times, so maybe it is worth getting grafted?

    Hope this helps.

  • 18 years ago

    I have Fragrant Cloud, it's one of my favorites. Mine took a few years to get really vigorous, before that it was kind of spindly. I do spray, and if not FC will blackspot.

    The blooms are beautiful and plentiful. The fragrance is to die for. The color for me is a very dark coral that can appear almost red. It does brighten up to a nice orange in hot weather.

  • 18 years ago

    Will my experience in TN and NC do?

    Fragrant Cloud is still my favorite HT. Once established it is a robust plant with great bloom production. The petals have heavy substance and the fragrance is incredible. Must be sprayed for BS in the South. I've grown it both grafted and ownroot.

    Just Joey - I have two ownroot in my garden. I've had it grafted also. Its winter tender, spindly and not all that productive. It does have the most incredibly beautiful fragrant blooms. I have it still because it was my mother's favorite rose. I'm about to pull both out and buy Martha (a sport of ZD) as a replacement tribute to my mother.

    Cherry Parfait - a sprawling, very productive bush that just pumps out blooms even in heat and drought. It is really more of a shrub than a grandiflora in habit. I love all the color variations in the blooms. No fragrance. Must be sprayed for BS in the south, although it has decent resistance.

    Peace - I have (finally) a good ownroot clone. Although its currently unhappy because I moved it. The bush is sort of awkward, but its hard to argue with the blooms. There is a reason this rose is so well known, and it is the beauty of the bloom. It is a robust bush once established, but requires very regular protection against BS.

  • 18 years ago

    I have/have had all of them. I love Fragrant Cloud and Papa Meilland. Well, I love Just Joey as well but Just Joey is very winter tender, even in my hot zone but I suspect it is the swings in temperature that make it hard to grow here, from 80 to 10 in a few hours but I grow Abbaye de Cluny, which is very similar which has the same color a Just Joey and what I think is a prettier bloom and it has Just Joey and Fragrant Cloud in its DNA, and besides I think it is a Meilland rose.

    I think Abbaye de Cluny is head and shoulders above Just Joey but that is just MHO.

    Papa Meilland requires someone who loves it to grow it, who can tolerate its ugly legs, someone who will give it TLC because it requires high culture.

    Fragrant Cloud takes time to settle in but in the south, give it room and time, so that it can become an 8 x 8 bush.

  • 18 years ago

    Another Marylander with hot humid conditions - there's some posts on the forum about Just Joey doing best in hotter, drier conditions like California - it may be popular but mine just limped along, finally got the SP - too bad, the flowers are gorgeous. Cherry Parfait, on the other hand, seems happily oblivious but I do need to spray for BS.

    Arizona was a mildewed MESS of a bush for me - I was HAPPY when I got rid of it! Maybe it is another that needs low humidity - but none of my bushes mildewed the way this did.