Software
Houzz Logo Print
curtg_gw

best chipper / shredder for mulch?

19 years ago

I have a pile of branches, the largest are 2" diameter, that I would like to chip up and use a mulch. However, the basic chipper machines that I see at the store all seem to produce chips that are too small to make good mulch. When I buy wood mulch in a bag they are larger chunks of wood around 2 inches long, but the chippers I've seen all produce much smaller chips, about 1/2 inch long.

Will the small chips made by a basic chipper work okay for mulch?

It seems to me the small chips will decompose too quickly to make a long-lasting mulch. Are there chippers available that will produce larger chunks of wood more similar to store-bought mulch?

Comments (8)

  • 19 years ago

    MTD Yard Machines used to make a 10 HP machine (I found mine on craigslist because they stopped selling them in our stores) that works great on branches up to about 2.5-3". The chips are usually 3/4-1.5", when put through the chipping shoot, and the brush shredder gives larger chips.

    The smaller chips don't seem to haven't disappeared in over a year, but I'm sure a lot of that is dependent on what kind of soil you have. Nothing disappears very quickly in our clay.

    Tree services and cleanup companies can do it faster and cheaper than the $300-600 you'd pay for a chipper and will leave you a nice batch of mulch for it, too.

  • 19 years ago

    You mention tree services. Is it likely that the local equipment rental shop would have a chipper that would make good mulch?

  • 19 years ago

    I know that our HomeDepot rents out large chippers, I think, for around $150/day. Ours has some nice Vermeers. There is also an equipment rental or two in my area that has chippers for rent.

    I recently got a quote on my huge pile (several holly trees, split bradford pear, miscellaneous), and it was around $200 to clear it out and leave the mulch.

  • 19 years ago

    Watch out at a rental yard. I'd take in a piece of material and have them run it through the machine to see if the knives were sharp enough to do the job.

    If you decide to buy, check to see that you can physically co-exist with the machine. I have a Mackissic SC 183 B that is hard on the body. I'm 5' 11" and feeding the hopper using an ensilage fork with one arm while opening and closing the lid with the other is a stress. I do not see that anyone shorter would be able to accomplish the task since I'm at the limit. Though the chipper is lower on the machine, I can see that a person of short stature might have difficulty feeding a large branch into the machine considering the angle that the material feeds into the mechanism.

    Terran

  • 19 years ago

    Watch for tree services working in your neighborhood, when ever I see them I run over and tell them that if they need a place to dump chips they can over at my place. I've gotten some great huge piles of chips from a few different services when the people having the work done didn't want them for themselves.

    The tree services chips are going to be of varrying size/quality all depending on what equipment they have, what types of trees/brush they are cutting, and the size of the stuff they are cutting. We have everything from beautiful chips for ornamental areas to sticks, twigs, palm frond chippings and leaves all mixed into a few different piles. beware of the strong smell (you may like or dislike it) that can come from fresh chipped green wood and leaves. The big piles can also get quite hot for a time since there are usually green leaves and a huge moisture content in a new pile.

    Something some friends of mine found out, what looks like a huge pile of brush can turn into a rather measly pile of mulch after chipping, hardly worth the effort in their opnion.

    My uncle's answer when asked about chipper/shredders "not worth the effort since they usually jam up and you have to spend all day turning branches into single sticks before you can feed them into the machine anyway." If you must get a chipper/shredder get something with far more HP than you think you need. Yes, a major investment, unless you will be needing to use it a couple times a month, you are probably better off renting.

  • 19 years ago

    prob gonna be some pricey wood chips
    you might be better off to just buy them
    chipper too

  • 19 years ago

    umm - cheaper too ;-)

  • 19 years ago

    All chipper/shredders have a screen at the discharge that regulates the size of the finihsed product. Some of these screens are removable/replacable and that is what you want to see on any machine you are considering. If you have a use for a chipper/shredder at least once a month that investment may be a good idea, but if the only time you would use it is for this pile of wood a rental would be a better expense since you would not have storage and maintenance to consider.