Software
Houzz Logo Print
canadian_rose

which would you Shovel Prune?

19 years ago

Here's a hypothetical question for you all. Say the "rose police" come to your yard and insist upon digging up 5 roses, which ones would you sacrifice?

I would have a hard time with 5 since I only have 43 rose bushes, but here are my choices:

1. Blanc Double de Coubert (hasta la vista, babee)

2. Gertrude Jekyll

3. Sweet Chariot (just too cold here for it to grow higher than 8 inches every year).

4. Day Dream (puny and flowers are small and nondescript)

5. Henry Hudson (just not doing very well for me)

Whew that feels good to hypothetically spade those suckers! :)

Once I get my yard all full of flowers (couple of years I'll get up to 100), then I can dig those I don't care for as much. Until then, well, they fill a space. LOL

Let's see yours (pictures are welcome)

Carol

Comments (32)

  • 19 years ago

    Marie Pavie, but I think she's already dead.
    Yves Piaget, just to get it out of its extended misery.
    Honey Perfume, because I never have a flower that isn't crispy as soon as it opens.
    Gertrude Jekyll, because she has drawn too much of my blood over the years; and I don't like the way she just throws long blind canes after her first flush.
    Nicole, because she has consistently underwhelmed.
    Now, if I wasn't so busy getting ready for the second wedding of the summer in my backyard, I would be getting the shovel ready. Instead, everyone is on probation for another year. I did get rid of Louise Odier, so now everyone knows I mean business.

  • 19 years ago

    Nothing--so far--but then look at where I live.

    However, while virtually anything will grow here, that just serves to increase the competition for available space--makes it that much easier to dispense with anything that doesn't "hit the ground running."

    I can tell one that I would NOT dream of replacing--Distant Drums--it's (they) are absolutely unbelievable here.

    Stunning in every way.

    MichaelAT

  • 19 years ago

    William Baffin (it attracts too many bees).
    Pretty soon I will have to put on a bee suit with head goggles just to walk by or to deadhead it. It scares the heck out of me.

    Sunsprite(have to baby it too much)
    We are in the middle of summer and its only now leafing out. Also its a foot and a half in height
    Wasn't like that last year. I don't know whats going on with it.

    Outta the Blue-should get Outta Ta Here.

    Since early June it has given me about 5 blooms.
    It gets plenty of sun, and treats it like my other roses.

    On the Pickering site it says that it is a very generous repeater. Well hello, I am still waiting to see the next set of blooms
    It now the middle of July and sitting there trying to look cute with just leaves.
    I will say that the cold snap really did a number on my roses. Some of my roses are just there struggling.
    Niecey

  • 19 years ago

    Well, I've already done it this season, but there are more on the watch list. I'm still learning so I make mistakes when buying roses, but I'm not going to live with a mistake ;-)

    Aloha--4 plants and every bloom so far has been vegetative
    Radiant Perfume--blooms not pretty
    Belinda's Dream--underwhelming so far
    Sunsprite--ditto
    Clotilde Soupert--balls horribly

    There are more but you only asked for 5 ;-)

    Barbara

  • 19 years ago

    Madam Issac Periere-she's virused (I think) but mostly because she is the rose midge dream rose; therefore, she rarely reblooms!

    Rogue Royale-Proliferates profusely and the petals turn brown in the sun. Big UGG!

    Compte de Chambord-Gets that yucky leaf fungus in spite of spraying and the spider mites love him. Course spider mites aren't his fault. I have to spray for midge therefore get spider mites.

    Sky Rocket-never been more than 2' high probably because it was stunted by the black walnut tree. I should replace this one with a healthy specimen.

    Lavendar Lassie-See Sky Rocket.

    Barbara, becomming tougher every year with my expectations from roses.

  • 19 years ago

    currently, I have 5 on "death-watch" -

    3 old roses that I suspect have reverted to rootstock (planted long before I knew anything about roses)

    Seven Sisters - she fails to bloom, fails to impress
    Baronne Prevost - another failure to bloom this year

    I'll probably give Seven Sisters and Baronne Prevost a different spot next year, but if they don't start blooming they are out of here!

    Jeri in Texas

  • 19 years ago

    Denver Dream (mini) - planted last year, but still looks like a band. Has only produced one flower this season!

    Burgandy Iceberg - throwing small, ugly magenta flowers on a ratty pathetic bush.

    Champlain - has a touch of mildew, which is rare in my garden. It does throw up beautiful candelabras of flowers and it overwintered very well. SIGH.

    Red Scentsation (mini) - mildews.

    William Baffin - no rebloom and the canes are reaching out to grab me. Very pretty Spring flush and it is absolutely hardy.

    There, I said it!

    Cheers,
    Michelle

  • 19 years ago

    Well, I've recently shovel pruned quite a few so I don't have alot left to get rid of, but...

    Fame! - It's a great rose if you spray, but I don't anymore
    and it's not making it.

    Yves Piaget - One of the prettiest blooms I've ever seen,
    but it's also not making it in my no spray garden

    Laurie

  • 19 years ago

    I have only two that I don't like.

    The Pilgrim. Octopus arms to 5 feet, ugly bush, and only 4 blooms since I planted it last year, all of which shattered in a day.

    Silverado. The silvery bud form is very pretty. But once it opens (too quickly) the petals develop a (IMO) garish clown pink all over the edges. Awful. So far I kept it for the smell (very nice), the many blooms, and my husband really likes it (because he's a sucker for underdogs!!).

  • 19 years ago

    Niecey,

    Wow, shocked by your choices... There must be something wrong with both your Sunsprite and Outta the Blue.

    I have 2 Outta of the Blue's and they are continual bloomers all summer. Very rarely are they without blooms for any more than a few days. It is a very prolific bloom machine. Could the graft have suffered winter damage on both Sunsprite and OTB?

    As for my own list, the Shovel prune watch has Simon Fraser on it. The blooms, growth habit and foilage don't really do a lot for me, although this rose is always in bloom which is shocking considering both reside in a rather shady north bed. It is completely cane hardy as one might expect.

    Lilian Austin. I adore the blooms, fragrance, disease resistance and above average winter hardiness, but hate her growth habit and the fact that the canes are brittle as can be and easily break at the base in high wind and/or rain, when loaded with blooms. For the past 3 years i have lost countless canes and I'm fed-up staking her. I have two and will try to find a home somewhere else in the garden for one of them this year and will find a good home for the other. Two Ebb Tides will be replacing Lilian.

    Morden Fireglow- I have 2 and these have been on SP watch for about a year now. They are both being pulled out this fall to make room for Hot Cocoa and Benjamin Britten which I have been trialing in pots since the spring. Hot Cocoa was exactly what I have been looking for in the one particular spot occupied by one of the MF's. Hot Cocoa has been simply outstanding to date and is such an attractive plant too when not in bloom. The foilage is beautiful and in direct contrast to Morden Fireglow. Benjamin Britten has been ok, but I liked what i saw from the plant in DA's garden and will give it more time to prove itself.

    That's it really.

  • 19 years ago

    This is tough, but Marilyn Monroe is the only bush I
    have with a big rust problems. So I'm teter-totering
    'cause the blooms are more than beautiful.
    I usually get good results with the new English Roses,
    but Harlow Carr is not reblooming. I just got this
    one in March, so maybe I'm being impatient. It started
    off great, blooming in clusters in May, and then is
    seems to have gone dormant. No new growth. The catalog
    said it was one of the most free-flowering in the
    collection. I'll keep it and see if next year it comes
    to life. But if it does'nt, it may have to go.

  • 19 years ago

    Exactly Tim
    I have seen lots of pics of your Outta The Blue
    and I can only say that I am so green with envy just seeing your pics. At this time I am not overly excited about having it.
    Tim on Sunsprite yes, I think it has suffered a great deal from winter damage.
    OTB it foliage is pretty healthy but just not doing a heck of a lot.
    Niecey

  • 19 years ago

    I really do need to get rid of some this fall in order to make a bit more room for at least some of the bigger roses I've got in pots ... here's what's on my list so far:
    Perfume Perfection - the blooms blow too fast for me, and I have bad rebloom, it's the only one that's not putting out new buds as yet.
    Ronald Reagan - lovely, but I don't like the look of it when it fades ...
    Melody Parafumee - same reason as RR - and it's taking up way too much space!
    Kordes Perfecta - it's already dieing
    Dainty Bess - I've got 3, I might keep one, but really my blooms don't look half as nice as the pictures I've seen, and they are PM magnets here
    Perfect Moment - too thorny and fades into a really ugly colour ..

    I've also given fair warning to my Strawberry Gauva plant that I planted 4 years ago and not had a single fruit ... it's been warned 2 years in a row, but if I don't see any fruit this year it's going - that should make room for about 4-5 more roses!!

    Aprille

  • 19 years ago

    I could only pick two (but a VERY easy two):

    Radiant Perfume - blows after a few hours! Doesn't even make it a day. Doesn't seem to repeat bloom above 90 degrees for me.
    Sunsprite - same as above, but the blooms at least last 2 days.

  • 19 years ago

    These are the ones that more than one person would like to do the "hard" prune:

    Gertrude Jekyll - 2 people
    Yves Piaget - 2
    Sunsprite - 3
    Radiant Perfume - 2

    Michelle - I'm not surprised about Champlain. I had 3 bushes in Fort McMurray - gah did they look putrid from mildew. I would NEVER get that rose again. Blech.

    Honey Perfume is one that I like quite well. We're cooler here so that's probably why mine has longer lasting flowers. Mine's always in bloom.

    Carol

  • 19 years ago

    Hmmmm...

    For today at least (lol) they would be:

    Starry Night - pathetic twig of a rose

    Ink Spots - stingy with blooms

    Magic Carousel - awards be darned, it hates me

    Scentimental - flowers open and two seconds later shatter

    Sunsprite - about one foot high after 4 years and a jb magnet to boot

  • 19 years ago

    Can I just hit the rose police over the head with my shovel???? LOL.... I'm just kidding.

  • 19 years ago

    SDLM - balls, powdery mildew, thrips... not a good rose for my climate

    Francis Dubrueil (sp??) - Nice attractive shrub but shuts down in summer and blooms get crispy in the heat. Too many other great roses that do well in the heat for this one to occupy space

    Archduke Charles - Same as FD

    Golden Celebration - on the watch list. A handful of blooms in 2 years. It has one more year.

  • 19 years ago

    OK, this is really hard for me. I have never, ever shovel pruned a rose. I'm weak and cannot bring myself to kill a living plant. Besides that I figure if it makes it through the winter it deserves a chance.

    That being said here's what I would ditch if I had the gumption.

    Climbing Peace. I've had it 3 years now. It gave me one bloom the first year and that's it. It also just gave me two big fat healthy basal breaks. Drat!

    Sunsprite, is only a foot high, hardly ever blooms for me and when it does it blows in a flash.

    JFK, I've never had a clean bloom on it yet. You just look at it and it spots and browns.

    Hot Cocoa, love the blooms, hate the plant, gawky awkward growth.

    Angel Face, another one I love the blooms on but it's the worst black spot magnet I have and spends most of it's time nekked.

  • 19 years ago

    Funny, I have had great luck with Sunsprite, even after it was totally knocked back from the late freeze. It blooms like crazy for me though the JB's do love it.

    Morden Fireglow--in a bucket as I type,I'm slowly letting it die...it has ugly, ugly foliage and the blooms would always ball before opening:(

    Wild Plum-miniature-I'v really discovered I just don't like mini's; maybe I just haven't found the right one?

    Pat Austin--this is its second year. It really hasn't done much for me but sit there looking anemic with thin nodding flower stems. Maybe one more year, I am giving it leeway due to our weather this year...

    Scentimental--blooms blow WAY to quickly, though pretty

    Purple Tiger--this is gorgeous, but a black spot magnet

    Simply Marvelous--not really marvelous; puny bush--but it is own root; giving it a few more years!

  • 19 years ago

    Rugosa Alba- it has done well, is healthy, but it only blooms once and it is not big enough to make a good companion to the rose next to it. Actually, I'm going to pass it on to a neighbor come fall. (Don't want to kill it, it's been a good plant- just a poor choice on my part.) Brandy

  • 19 years ago

    Update on the "let me at it with an axe" group

    Gertrude Jekyll - 2 people
    Yves Piaget - 2
    Sunsprite - 5
    Radiant Perfume - 2
    William Baffin - 2
    Scentimental - 2

    Sunsprite seems to be the leader of the dog pack!

    Carol

  • 19 years ago

    I would SP:
    Chicago Peace--think it is just a dud bush--scrawny.
    Color Magic--ditto to Chicago Peace
    Cabana--Good bush, flowers are only striped for 1/2 day then just a muddled mess. Not attractive at all.
    Chris Evert--Second year bush is disappointingly not growing at all. One bloom all year so far.
    About Face--Great bush, consistently the ugliest blooms in the garden by far--raggedy with no form or fragrance.

    These 5 are safe for the remainder of this year, but next Spring they better watch out if there is no improvement.
    It is a good thing I don't have any in the pot ghetto ready to transplant to any of these garden spots!!
    John

  • 19 years ago

    I hope by "shovelprune" that you mean you carefully dig up a nice rootball with each bush and that the rose police take them into protective custody until suitable adoptive homes are found. I'm sure you meant that, right?

    I'm hopeless. I can't kill a bush unless is already looks like it's on its way out.

  • 19 years ago

    Golden Showers and Mr lincoln are my worst performers but I will give them one more season.

    I am surprised by the ones who said honey perfume. It does great here and it is only the first year! the JB's love her though....

  • 19 years ago

    We threaten our two Intrigues every year....this year they had some nice blooms, then nothing....but I think a lot of our lack of bloom is due to the cool temperatures.

    Othello is another one...a $5 J&P box sale rose we've had 3-4 years. Storm took down a huge cane, still hasn't recovered.

    I almost gave up on Teasing Georgia, Geoff Hamilton and Pat Austin a year ago, but this year they are getting huge (year 5 I think!)

    Lagerfeld I rarely get a decent bloom due to it being the fav of all the JBs, and unless I get it at the right stage, the bloom edges get brownish etc.
    :0)Phyl

  • 19 years ago

    Yves Piaget
    Rosetti Stone
    Maybe Pat Austin - I just don't like a rose I have to squat down like a 1 year old to enjoy. :)

    Plus I need room to plant Jeri Jennings and maybe make room for a Hot Cocoa.

  • 19 years ago

    Why would too many bees be a problem? It is good when bees are in your garden.

  • 19 years ago

    Zyp, don't get me wrong
    I love to see the bee in my garden like one or two
    but Billy attract quite a number of big huge bumble bees
    and at time in my garden I find my self running away and ducking to get away cuz they are every where, especially if I'm trying to deadhead or weed.
    Niecey

  • 19 years ago

    Mike - Yeah, that's what I meant!! I would never imply that any of these roses would be HARMED!! Gosh, no!! So the update on the roses that the Rose Police are going to "rehome" is:

    Gertrude Jekyll - 2 people
    Yves Piaget - 3
    Sunsprite - 5
    Radiant Perfume - 2
    William Baffin - 2
    Scentimental - 2
    Pat Austin - 2

    John - love your comment on About Face - too funny. :) I love that rose, but then I'm in a cooler zone.

    Sunnishine - I agree!! I love Honey Perfume.

    Carol

  • 19 years ago

    Niecey, those big bumble bees are very timid. Honest, they won't hurt you..now a wasp or a hornet different story. Here in Seattle in the fall the little yellow hornets get very agressive...

    Look try it out..go weed by the bumbles and see if they come over to you.

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks Zyp
    OK maybe I'm a big scardy cat
    For you I'll give it a try.
    Niecey