Software
Houzz Logo Print
silverkelt

How hardy is Veilchenblau?

17 years ago

In my continued look at trying to find roses, I really cant grow, anyone experienced Veilchenblau in long cold winters...

I would like to trail it against some mammoth rocks I have forming a wall of sorts.

Any other suggestions?

Thanks

Comments (16)

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Setigera hybrids, particularly the Feast ones, will be plenty hardy. I've got a boursault that should be good, but so far is doing a certain amount of struggling.

    One of my particular problems is that my soil pH is much too high for happy multiflora hybrids. So I'd expect something like Veilchenblau to keel over practically instantly here. I'm currently debating whether or not to keep Dorothy Perkins since it is struggling mightily with the soil and the climate.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    It's been hardy for me, minimal cane dieback, no winter protection but it is right close to the fireplace exterior brickwork and somewhat sheltered on the east side of the house.

    As to performance, it's not done much for me yet, maybe just not enough sun (blocked by large tree across the street and my birch clump when the sun moves more to the southern skies).

    If it doesn't do better, I'm getting rid of it, but maybe nothing will do well there. A big plus is that with all my troubles with chompers, leaf-damaging pests, it stays pretty clean with no spraying. And it does shoot up long canes fairly rapidly.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    aliska, if the soil there isn't too alkaline (& you don't deal with deer) it sounds like a potential spot for a shade-tolerant shrub like an azalea, rhodendron, mountain laurel, Japanese andromeda, Japanese maple, or Clethra alnifolia.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    (Hypericum frondosum 'Sunburst')

    (And now I promise to stop highjacking the thread! ;-) )

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I take that back. Something has been chomping on Veil, but it can take it and doesn't leave the telltale damage of Jap beetles, just have to get those in. They are busy today, and I'm starting to see crispy leaves on the lawn from my birches with the telltale signs . . .talk about hijacking :-(

    Also, this spring some but not as bad as last, something whitish on the candlelabra buds, not aphids, hosed them off, no appearance of damage to blooms once they opened, just didn't do much this spring; winter may have been harder on it than usual. I kind of wished I'd put a Bleu Magenta there instead, didn't know about it then, but wonder if it would do for me what the online photo looks like.

    OK, here's a plus. I got Veil from ARE, southern grown. My roses from them are slower to come into their own, and I figure its partly due to adapting to the climate change even though they are approved for my zone, just a theory.

    I don't care if a rose is shade tolerant or not. Other things being equal, they will always bloom better and have fewer problems in more sun if you keep them watered, mulched and fed. Some roses don't even need but little of that by the third year unless there's downright drought.

    york rose, aliska, if the soil there isn't too alkaline (& you don't deal with deer) it sounds like a potential spot for a shade-tolerant shrub like an azalea, rhodendron, mountain laurel, Japanese andromeda, Japanese maple, or Clethra alnifolia.

    No deer yet to my knowledge or my lilies would be eaten down, nothing like that so far, have been fortunate. Deer are close, however, I guess I'd better not talk about the annual bow hunt for females in the park nearby.

    I just hate to give up on roses yet, and spent a lot of money on a double trellis for Veil. But I will check those out, much appreciated, york. I will tell you, I did my homework on a very hardy Nova Zembla rhodie, they bloom best in a little sun, put them on the east side down where there is more morning sun, beautiful and healthy in their pots when I got them from a good nursery. One is dead, and I don't know if the other one is going to make it or not. They were expensive. There is a more common purple people grow around here.

    Here's another point. Veil sets buds by the time the trees have leafed out, that is an issue. With my other once-bloomers, they set buds while they are still getting more sun to set buds when trees are essentially leafless.

    I've always liked Mountain Laurel, would adore having a pretty dogwood, was told there is one kalmia somewhere around here. When I can get to the nursery, I'll pick up a ph tester. Yellow I don't want there, but the clethra is nice.

    One of my problems there is like I mentioned, sun and also have to fight large tree roots to plant anything, plus feed well, from my nicest trees, a double flowering pink crab and a clump of birches. I won't saw off the larger roots and risk further damage. I fear the birches' days may be numbered, but the crab has formed kind of a canopy over my 4 dr windows which I really like, otherwise pretty upright and tall, hardly ever drops branches to clean up; if any of no consequence.

    As to hijacking, sometimes one subject naturally progresses to another but tied to the main post. If it's a deliberate attempt to disrupt, well that is another matter. If I start a thread like this and it goes the way this one has, it wouldn't make me annoyed. But intentional disruption for the sake of it alone which has not happened on OGR to my knowledge would.

    You know, if worse comes to worse, maybe I could put one of my own once bloomers there that I've rooted myself, plant when fairly small, would definitely wp those now until it's safe not to.

    Now for some more "hijacking". I planted a clematis with Veil figuring I'd get some color when Veil is done. Rosea purpurea or something like that, not happy there.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    put them on the east side down where there is more morning sun

    That is a tricky exposure. I know it may sound counter-intuitive, but having been around as many rhododendrons as I have (& I've been around thousands, having once been a propagator at a commercial azalea/rhododendron production nursery) I can say that in my experience if the exposure gives the rhody unprotected exposure to the dawn and morning sun that is a hazardous place for your rhody if you don't put some burlap (or some other shade source) up for it during the winter. Those days in late winter, the ones where the sun's getting stronger, but the ground is still frozen solid?

    I very strongly suspect that's what does them in. In any case, with the rhodies I've seen in that exposure that get damaged, but don't die, the damaged areas on the plant are always the ones that get the most exposure to the rising sun.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    york rose, thank you for your expertise on that. I knew going in that putting them so close to the foundation was not such a good plan, but there was nowhere else at the time that I wanted them. I wonder if I should move the surviving one? After what you told me, I don't want the survivor there, but it may be too fragile to move. Dappled shade sounds the best, but I'm having taken down my huge maple (sadly but necessary at this point) so practically the whole back yard will be full sun.

    I can get some more, could put them by the north foundation but set out further (3 PJM did well there for several years) or out of ideas. ANY place around my yard is taking a chance.

    I did amend where IT is now with peat which is acidic but had no way to check the ph. Also tilled in compost. They were guaranteed, I don't hold the nursery responsible for that. From what they said, I wasn't the only one; this winter on a new rhodie was bad. I also did what they said, pruned off the dead growth and gave Miracid in the proper mix. Maybe I should give the survivor another dose, not sure. Even the much older different one across the alley took a real beating this winter.

    Maybe I'll just buy a couple more. I'm like that when I want something. But I don't want to put them where Veil is, I prefer something that climbs there.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    This isn't a climber, but I should have mentioned it before and forgot to:

    Fothergilla gardenii.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    (The inflorescences look like small white bottle brushes, and have an aroma that "carries" somewhat and is simultaneously sweet and a little musty, giving the fragrance a vague similarity to honey.)

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    My Veil is very hardy, two years old and so far a big shrub roughly 6' and nearly that wide. Bloomed very briefly. In a corner of my arbor/pergola. Somewhat protectd from deer or perhaps they didn't fancy it. Ate the two roses next to it. Lavender Lassie and Rosarium Uetersen.

    I may get rid ot it if I happen to have something I like better.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I have veilchenblau growing on a fence that faces north. It gets morning sun and some late evening sun. It is 4 years old and about 20 feet wide. (10 feet each direction from the center.) I have no winter dieback but I'm not zone 5. Although it is a once bloomer, I doubt much else would grow in the place I have it, so there it stays... It is VERY vigorous... grows quickly and I prune the laterals twice a year.

    Here it is along the back fence...

    {{gwi:290684}}

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I had it. VEILCHENBLAU is fully hardy in zone 6. I shovel pruned it because of the very short bloom period. Two weeks, tops, then the flowers shatter and drop their petals. After that you have to wait until next year to see another performance. Frankly, I rather plant clematis.

    Still, there is that incredible color, which is like nothing else I've ever seen.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Veilchenblau at a Southern Garden

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    decobug, I fear mine will never look anywhere near like yours. That is so gorgeous even if it does last for such a short while. It provides a backdrop of greenery, and the other plants can take up the slack. Beautiful layout BTW, everything neat and tidy.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks... that was in the spring... now everything is overgrown and too big... :)

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Maybe I'd better take york rose's advice. Veil has shot up such a long cane, it hopped over and is trying to climb the crabapple tree next to the bed. I'm going to leave it be for now.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    After blooming, briefly, I'm ready to dump V. It has nice foliage and that might look good against the wall. However there are other choices. Baltimore bells is a more sprawling grower and blooms much longer. Nice fragrance too. Super hardy. 8' canes hardy to the tips.