Software
Houzz Logo Print
ptp813

using grey water in compost?

19 years ago

We have been in a severe drought so I have been using buckets in the shower and a large pan in the sink to collect more water. What I'm wondering is if the shampoo/conditioner or soap in the water will cause the worms and good bugs to leave the pile if I put this water on it?

Thanks,

Pam in TN

Comments (14)

  • 19 years ago

    I'm not one of the experts here but when I read your post, I thought that your question is somewhat difficult since champoos and soap can vary quite a bit from brand to brand.

    Seems to me the most important thing would be to try to avoid shampoos and soaps (usually the deodorant kind) that indicate "anti-bacterial" on the label.

    I know the plumber who sold me of those enzyme products that if applied monthly are advertised to keep your sewer line clear told me that it would only work if I didn't use anti-bacterial soap.

  • 19 years ago

    I'm in Tennessee, too, and have been "into" water conservation during our drought. I don't use antibacterial soap, either, although the thought never crossed my mind to be glad of it. Anyhoo, my younger son takes baths (and probably doesn't use much soap!) and no conditioner. I've been having him leave his bathwater and sometimes that becomes my lukewarm bathwater, and sometimes it waters my flowers, and sometimes it mops the floors. As luck would have it, I never put it on my compost pile because I also collect the a/c drip discharge in a tub and that's right next to my compost pile.
    I have to say my compost pile didn't have many worms when I collected it. It had a very few. It had one gazillon sow bugs, soldier fly larvae, a few nasty white slugs, two millipedes, and myriad other tiny little things I couldn't i.d. on the spot. Perhaps all those sow bugs are a sign I kept the pile to wet, as it seemed that tub was usually pretty full and everytime I got a gallon for a plant I put a gallon on the pile. I had to spread the compost on a tarp in the sun-- they all evacuated to the unfinished leftovers in my new pile.

    That's no answer, I suppose, but at least the occasional bucket of bathwater never bothered my flowers and my compost pile didn't have any worms, anyway, to be possibly bothered by a bit of soap.

  • 19 years ago

    We have all our gray water plumbed out of the house separately from the black water. We don't use laundry detergents with boron. We use soaps that have antibacterial properties all the time. Our water is softened with potsasium chloride. I find that the areas watered with this gray water (and they have been watered thus for over 15 years now) do not suffer from any problems. I do occasionally (about once a year) add a bit of gypsum to the watered areas to help move out the sodium that otherwise would start building up in the soil. The plants are quite healthy, the soil is teaming with life, and the water all goes to a good second use. When I looked at the information on the antibacterial soaps a while ago, I concluded that unless we were pouring the concentrated soaps down the drain, there was no problem for our system. The materials diluted as they would be from use are benign for us.

    Renais

  • 19 years ago

    Grey water can be used in your compost pile and since earthworms are not a significant part of the digestion process it will have no affect on them at all. Since anti bacterial, anti microbial, soaps (actually detergents) are meant to kill bacteria (and microbs) using them is not a good idea, and since the Food and Drug Administration has already stated that these things are no more effective than any other soap at killing the disease pathogens there is no real good reason to use them anyway. The amount of the bacteria stat in these products is too low to be effective, but is high enough so that the target bacteria, the pathogens, will develop immunities to these low levels of the stuff meant to kill them and for the same reasons you do not want to take unnecessary antibiotics you do not want to use these products. The pathogens are developing immunities to the antibiotics we have and will require stronger antibiotics (that we do not have) to kill them in the future. These types of products are part of the reason we now have the antibiotic resistant super bugs.

  • 19 years ago

    Thank you all for your input. I guess we will just use the collected water and see what happens. Thankfully we try to stay away from all anti stuff such as anti-bactierial and anti-biotic especially since anti means against and biotic is life which equals against life. However, there are times when they have been necessary. :-) Now that was way off of a water question/answer, but we are dealing with the earth and all that we do affects it and us, right. :-)

  • 19 years ago

    I've made good use of the dirty dish water to wash out my compost buckets and poor it into the compost pile. The trick is to not overdo the water on the compost pile as it can easily get too wet if you have lots of water to dump. It is also not a great idea to save gray water for later use (more than a day) because it can become nasty septic black water if left to sit too long. It is best to use gray water the same day or perhaps the next morning from last nights bath.

  • 19 years ago

    There's a member named "Ester Opal" that post on the hosta forum all the time. He has a system where his gray water drains into a mini bog. It's planted with some hosta and other water loving plants. They are thriving. If you want, look him up on the hosta forum, and send him an email. He'll give you every detail of the system including pictures.

  • 19 years ago

    Agree, that slight amounts of anti-bacteria soap will not be overly harmfull to microbes in soil and septic systems. I have a septic system and we don't use any anti-bacteria soaps. Soaps are surfactants (aerify) and will improve water penetration and retention in soils.

    Renais,

    Does your gray water include bleach from the washer? Bleach is a highly effective microbicide and should not be introduced into septic systems and definitely not the yard.

  • 19 years ago

    The grey water I collect is from the showers,kitchen sink, and dehumidifier in our basement. For years we have tried to be more green and not use bleach and other products that harm the earth. We have used mostly Shaklee earth friendly cleaners and laundry products. We use the Shaklee Nature Bright in place of bleach, but we don't collect the laundry water at this point. It would be awesome to set up a pond situation with the grey water being plumbed out of the house. I wonder if the utilities would reduce our sewage charges if we did....yeah right. :-)

    I'm setting up some lasagna beds this fall too so the water is getting used up pretty quickly in wetting down the layers.

    Thank you all for your great imput.

    :-) Pam

  • 19 years ago

    My sister used to water her dahlias with her wash water and those flowers grew like trees! I would expect that your grey water will be just great on your garden or in your compost -- there's bound to be some extra "soil" from your son's bath -- there certainly was from my son.

  • 19 years ago

    Our gray water contains absolutely all the waste water that is produced in our house except what goes down the toilet, and what goes down the kitchen sink. (Kitchen sink water is generally considered black water.) There are two drain systems in the house, one for black (to the septic tank), and one to the gray water field. So yes, all bleach goes into the gray water. However, remember that since all our gray water goes down there, the bleach is well diluted, and I do not observe problems. Note that the active chlorine in bleach would be quickly neutralized by all the organic materials in the gray water field, so it has no chance to kill the bacteria. The first contact of the water with the outside is to a patch of grass; from there, it goes to water other plants. Contact with the grass would get rid of all the active chlorine. This is also why bleach in reasonable quantities cannot be used to sterilze water with lots of organic debris; the chlorine is neutralized right away.

    On another note, I had a first considered using a sand filter to clean up the gray water effluent. What I have found through the years is that no filter is needed. The plants getting the water hide whatever debris comes out of the system; we never see any.

    Renais

  • 19 years ago

    Wow Renais, I'm learning some new things. I really didn't know there was black water until this discussion. I figured when you mentioned it before that it would be toilet water, but what would make the sink water considered black? We mostly wash the food stuff down the drain and do the rinsing out of cups and clean dishes over the basin for collecing. Is it the food debris that makes it black?

    Thanks a bunch.

    :-) Pam

  • 19 years ago

    It is actually the ground food from the garbage disposal that makes the kitchen sink a source of black water. Left to myself, I would probably have plumbed the kitchen sink to the gray water line also, but standard practice dictates otherwise. I would have worked to mitigate the food debris issues. For a quick discussion of the differences, see http://www.greywater.com/. For a more detailed look at the issue, from a New Mexico viewpoint, see http://www.ose.state.nm.us/water-info/conservation/h2o-faq.html. I find that the gray water handbook referenced on this second site is a reasonable introduction to my friends who are considering this route. The good part of us not using our kitchen sink water (which basically only contains the materials that come from the dishwasher, and the little that goes down when we wash food) is that we have absolutely no odors, or critter problems even though our gray water exits the house underground, and is delivered to the surface by gravity further from the house.
    Renais

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Franklin County's Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting