Software
Houzz Logo Print
magickiwi

deer resistant help ...

17 years ago

We live in Kalamazoo MI, zone 5, in the city, and we have deer roaming around all the time - big ones, little ones and a 12 point buck - they all belong in someones freezer! Last week we came home to find that they had sucked off every leaf from the sweet potato vines from my gorgeous Mothers Day planter - so sad and really weird looking now! I want to put deer resistent perennials in the front of my deck that faces east. I can transplant coneflowers, variegated Lysimachia, Japanese Painted Ferns, Little Princess dwarf daisies, white Liatris and Red Astilbe. What do you think? Other suggestions are appreciated. I might have something in my other gardens that would work too - I just can't think of what right now!

Comments (9)

  • 17 years ago

    I'm not in your zone, but I garden with deer. Of course, your deer may like different plants than my deer.

    As a general rule, plants in the lamiaceae family, such as lambs ear, salvia and agastache, are the best choices. That said, deer have come onto my patio and pinched back the coleus.

    Cameron

    Here is a link that might be useful: Deer in Your Garden? Meet the Lamiaceae Family

  • 17 years ago

    I feel your pain, I really do! The deer has been destroying my lovely planter with sweet potato vines too! I also can't grow things like rudbeckias and coneflowers around here because they seem to like them too much... Sigh!!!

    What they don't touch at all in my yard are the following:

    - Hardy geraniums
    - Heucheras
    - My Monet Weigelas
    - Japanese anemones
    - tradescantia
    - spireas
    - agastache
    - artemisia

    Good luck!

  • 17 years ago

    I think the deer are likely to enjoy the daisies, liatris and coneflowers. When deer have the run of a property (that is, if efforts are not being made to make the place unpleasant for them) they usually develop a taste for plants that normally hold little interest for them.

    Perennials that are almost always left alone unless the deer are starving include Agastaches, Calaminthas, Nepetas, Achilleas, Lavender, Stachys, Iris of all types, Pardancandas, all Salvias, Geranium maccrorhizum and related hybrids like 'Biokovo' etc. (but not other geraniums), Verbascums, Hellebores, Digitalis. There are a good many others, but these are common ones. List does not include woodies or bulbs.

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks everyone for the feedback.
    I just finished roaming around the Lamieaceae link site - that is really intriguing - I'll head back there tomorrow for another in-depth look.
    A neighbor was walking past as I worked out front this evening and she commented on my gardens and I said that they would look better if it wasn't for the deer. She laughed and said "I thought you invited them - when I come home late at night I see anywhere from 5 to 9 SLEEPING in your front yard." I about keeled over! No wonder my choc lab glues his nose to the ground every time he goes outside - she said "yes, he is sniffing right where they were the past three nights"! Aaaaaargh. If they ever get my hostas against the house I will feed the shelters venison for a year I swear!
    Rita in Kalamazoo MI

  • 17 years ago

    Well, having hostas in deer country is like setting out the buffet and advertising free lunch. Consider getting rid of them and replacing with Pulmonaria and Brunnera. Or at least keep them sprayed with a good repellant.

  • 17 years ago

    After not having roses for 3 years thanks to the deer, I put in perennial beds. The deer had eaten my roses to the ground this spring, then started on the daylilies. This year there are five of them. I found this recipe of a homemade deer deterrent on the internet. It has worked so far. I have seen the deer walk past my roses and anything else I have sprayed. 1 egg, 1c. milk, few T cooking oil, T Dawn, 1 qt. water, Tabasco. Blend egg and milk together, strain, add other ingrediants, mix well. Put in sprayer and spray plants. I reapply every 2 wks. or after a rain. I am keeping my fingers crossed for this fall. This recipe is stinky. I spray in the evening before the deer make their rounds. I am making up gallon batches and keeping this smelly concoction in the garden shed. Hope this helps.
    Jackie

  • 17 years ago

    The deer sleep on my neighbour's front lawn since he doesn't mow it... I've had to live with them foraging my gardens and for the last few years have planted things which others have said are deer resistant. On occasion, they do nibble to taste, but if they don't eat the whole plant or return to that particular one, I know it's safe.
    The following have been avoided altogether or not returned to...

    Daisies
    Liatris
    Coneflowers
    (Laceyvail says "I think the deer are likely...", but I have significant amounts of these and they will eat other plants right next to them or in other gardens, but will not eat these.)
    Cimicifuga
    Eupatorium
    Astilbe
    Brunnera - I am replacing a huge amount of Hostas with a variety of these beauties. This plant is also disliked by the slugs.
    Buddleias
    Asclepias
    Aconitum
    Rudbeckia
    Baptisia
    Aruncus Doicus
    Thalictrum
    Rodgersia
    Poppies of any kind
    Verbascum
    Veronicastrum
    Lupine
    Liatris
    Inula
    Alyssum
    Monarda
    Oregano
    Lavender
    Heliopsis
    Peony
    Dianthus
    Artemisia
    Perennial Geranium

    ... and more. The Hostas which I am removing are being placed at the edge of our property which borders the forest. This is a bit away from the gardens so they have started to forage on those instead of those in the formal gardens. I also think that by introducing other plants which they do not like into the hosta gardens and next to plants they like, it is confusing them and they are staying away from the candy they previously ate. An example of this is the Phlox Paniculata Davidii - which they used to eat several times a season - is now being avoided since Aconitum Carmicheal is planted right next to it and on the other side is the Eupatorium. They also have to walk into a spread of Big Root Geranium which sets off a heavy scent and confuses them. This year I saw the most beautiful blooms on all of my Phlox!! :O)

    I have tried the sprays and some do work, but here we have early summers with lots of rain which washes the concoctions off the plants and I just don't have the time to spray the gardens as often as required. You may be able to so you can try it.

    I realize that it is frustrating. As time goes, you can get the gardens you want. Just play with it. :O)

  • 17 years ago

    Deer will eat anything if they are hungry enough, or if they have developed a taste for it.

    The only thing that really keeps them out is foot-trap fencing, and it REALLY DOES work.

    Get 3-ft tall 2x4" welded wire fencing, unroll it around your perimeter and flatten it out. That's it. They will stand right outside my garden and stare at the peas, corn, lettuce, etc, and they won't get a bite. If your mower isn't set really low, you can mow right over it. Does it sound too simple? Sorry.

    Deer are prey animals. If they get their feet trapped somehow, they are dinner, and they know it. You know those cattle guards they embed in asphalt, and those white stripes they paint on pavement, a few inches apart? They're foot traps to cows.

    Deer, cows and horses can't see their feet. So when deer touch something like wire mesh, they won't step into/onto it, and they won't jump over it because they don't know where it ends. Just like they won't try to jump a canyon in two jumps.

    Granted, if you have a large area, it would be expensive, but my friend just puts it around her flower beds. But she says if the flowers are too tall and lean too far... she finds their heads bitten off, so now she uses 4-ft tall fencing around some beds.

    At least it's cheaper than having to buy posts, too!

    Try it around a small bed and see that it really works.

    Sue

  • 17 years ago

    I just put these same photos in another thread about deer resistant gardening. These are examples of the edges of my large gardens.

    {{gwi:254967}}

    {{gwi:271281}}

    {{gwi:274036}}