Software
Houzz Logo Print
lynn2112

Own root shrub Vs. climber... SDLM ... Need help please

The answer to this question may seem obvious, but I have always been told to ask what may seem like a dumb question in some situations. Thursday afternoon I received SDLM own root plants. My hubby watered them and then carefully potted them up for me. I had surgery Thursday so my activities have been extremely limited. Today, I went out with him as he watered the plants for me, and I placed my own tags ( my potting soil related comparisons) and I noticed that the label read Souvenir de la Malmaison CL.

I double checked my order to ensure that I had not inadvertently ordered the wrong roses; I hadn't. To make a long story short, in terms of an own root plant, just how different is the climber from the shrub? Or better asked, is there something inherently different in the climber that will make it grow to leaps and bounds when it is still a SDLM. I am thinking there has to be (plant genetics), but I am new to own root plants, and the difference in grafted roses is usually obvious. The own root SDLM climbers do not appear different than my new own root shrubs in any way that stands out or is patently obvious; or maybe the meds are impacting what I see.

My husband is so busy and I would not ask more of his time and have him repot a new batch. I used really good potting soil. I just am hoping that these SDLM climbers were mislabeled CL. or that own root climbers be pruned down to shrub size and easily maintained.

Thank you in advance,

Lynn

This post was edited by desertgarden561 on Sat, Jul 27, 13 at 23:16

Comments (14)

  • 13 years ago

    Hi Lynn, I hope your surgery has gone perfectly and your recovery is speedy and complete! I've not seen a climbing Malmaison pruned to keep it "shrubby". I would expect for it to work, the plant would have to be very large, perhaps six feet or more, to provide the necessary foliage mass to nourish the plant and enable it to pump out the flower power you expect from it. You may also have to stake the canes initially until they thicken sufficiently to support themselves. Good luck with it. Kim

  • 13 years ago

    Thank you. I am feeling better than anticipated, but must follow the doctors orders for the next several weeks. I will likely have to gift the SDLM Cl. to my sister in law along with the grandmothers hat I ordered for her. Nice start for her garden, which is good, and should be lovely, but my plants will require replacement.

    Lynn

  • 13 years ago

    I recommend AGAINST attempting to grow Climbing SdlM as a bush. It's a strong grower & definitely wants to climb. Also, it's infamous for its "naked legs"; I seriously doubt that efforts to prune it into submission would alter that unfortunate fact.

    Altho some gardeners who grow the climber report a good fall flush, for others (including me) it flowers heavily in the spring with few, if any, blooms thereafter. The bush form, OTOH, blooms well all season long.

    Another difference between the bush and the climber are the flowers themselves. I find those produced by the climber to be a bit larger, a bit more "loose" and with even less petal substance that those on the bush. Consequently, under rainy conditions the roses on the climber are hopeless -- they ball like crazy.

    However, Climbing SdlM can be absolutely spectacular -- even with those prominent naked legs. It's unfortunate that you can't accommodate it because your warm, dry environment would suit it well. The nursery worker who pulled and packed your order undoubtedly made an honest mistake -- one that any reputable nursery will be anxious to correct. I encourage you to contact them.

  • 13 years ago

    Windeaux,

    Thank you for the information. It is what I thought but needed to confirm. i really love SDLM, and at this point I wanted to be watching and nuturing all of of my little beauties with them being in the same growth phase too. I contacted the supplier via email as soon as I determined my order was correct, and there was a shipping error. I contacted this grower last week regarding another issue with a different shipment, and they are rectifying the issue. I am confident they will rectify this problem too; it just threw a monkey wrench in my growing/fall planting plan, but how often do things actually work out precisely in the manner of planning? I'm getting over it:) I will actually be a little heartbroken if I do not get roses that I am on wait lists for.

  • 13 years ago

    This error perfectly illustrates how it is so easy to accidentally package a climbing sport in bush type packaging; collect and bud one type for the other as well as mis ship one for the other. Sometimes the mistake is the rose's fault. Some years ago, at a specialty rose nursery I managed, we received an order of budded Malmaison which were all Kronprinzessin Viktoria, the white sport. The producer didn't grow the white sport, but one (or more) of his Malmaison plants sported and I received over a dozen white Malmaison bushes. It should honestly come as no surprise to anyone who receives a climber of a type when they expected a bush of the same rose. This kind of mix up happens so easily and will only increase as costs continue to rise, profits continue falling and producers have to squeeze tighter and tighter to remain in business. Kim

  • 13 years ago

    Comments by windeaux are right on. It is a rampant climber. While a cane is growing out to 15', it is not going to be blooming. That's the basic reason why climbers give less repeat than bush roses of the same kind.

    Climbers are not strong enough to make climbing canes until they are well established, so they may look like bush roses during the first season.

  • 13 years ago

    Lynn -- There is another issue.

    In our garden, a short distance South of Ventura, we "grew" four different plants of SdlM -- 3 Bushes. One Climber.

    Of the four plants, we NEVER -- and I mean NEVER -- saw an open bloom. It is long-gone.

    Souv. de la Malmaison is a lovely rose in Sacramento, and it is a lovely rose in San Jose, and it is doubtless a lovely rose in many other places. But in coastal Ventura County, it is an unattractive mildewy plant with rotting clumps of un-opened petals.

    Jeri

  • 13 years ago

    Roseseek, it is sad to see the shift that is occurring with some suppliers. I am new to own root and OGRs. I may not be able to acquire some of the beauties made available by A.R.E. for example.

    It also speaks to man power or Q.A. as the stick in the 3 plants ( souvenir de la malmaison Cl) clearly did not match the order. What is also interesting is that they show the climber as being out of stock, but not the shrub.

    I had another issue with a shipment from the same supplier two weeks ago, I received a plant that was extremely wet and it had a horrible stench. I couldn't revive it, but it is being replaced,

    Jerijen, my husband suggested that I place the two SDLM on the arched wall by the porch, one on each side; I just did not want a SDLM there in terms of color or growth. I had planned for a shrub that was taller than it was wide.,I actually have one of 2 Paul Neyrons for that location. Thank you for the information regarding SDLM as it is unlikely to work for my sister in law residing in pretty moist Ventura CA. I will definitely have to figure something out.


    Lynn

  • 13 years ago

    This kind of decrease in care and "pride of ownership" is, unfortunately, increasingly common in nearly all businesses these days. "Customer service" is more "customer inconvenience" and we are expected more and more to perform the function of "quality control."

    If the stick with the label doesn't appear to have been original to the pot your rose grows in, perhaps it isn't and you DO have the bush form. It's unfortunate your climate and conditions aren't conducive to growing it in a pot a season or two to make sure. "Warm roots", not cooked or hot, push the plant to perform significantly faster than cooler conditions in the ground. American Beauty nearly wasn't the legend it became until it was slated for disposal and gathered next to the boiler at the grower who introduced it here. It was forgotten a while and when noticed, it was in glorious flower. It required more heat. The Romans forced once flowering roses into bloom for their orgies and other "celebrations" by passing steam pipes under the bottoms of potted roses. If you can accomplish it, growing that in a pot for a while may well answer your questions as to the authenticity of its ID. Kim

  • 13 years ago

    Also be warned that Paul Neyron is notoriously a martyr to fungal disease in many areas of California. Here, again, is a plant that may be wonderful somewhere.

    The question often has been whether he mildewed more, or rusted more. I HAVE seen older plants of it, grown inland, that were not diseased, but he can be a real problem.

    In your conditions, he may be just fine.

    Or not.

    Jeri

  • 13 years ago

    Roseseek, the stick label in the pot I received had SDLM CL. written on it, but whatever I can imagine they used to pull inventory, especially if it was generated by my online order, should have read and had the stock number for SDLM. I agree with you. It seems that not too long ago there was a real trend toward customer service and now that trend is less prevalent. I must say it has been a pleasure working with Burling:) thank you for the recommendation.

    So many businesses have come and gone due in part to a lack of focus upon the consumer, and others have not learned from their poor example. There has been such a large shift in values, integrity and ethics etc. in our country, I remain optimistic as I see the new generation in my family, my kids etc., but some issues and attitudes are spreading and that is very troubling.

    Jerijen, the Paul Neyron was on the list formulated by the local rose society of OGR' s to grow here. I have read that Paul Neyron can be TROUBLE, but a lot of what I read are conditions like black spot and rust which I rarely have issues with; probably due to the dry conditions. I have read about people "pushing it" with certain roses, zone wise etc. P.N. Could likely be one that I will be "pushing it " with due to my horrible soil and heat.
    If it goes well I will be very happy, if not, well, I have purchased one and have another on order so relative to the fairly complete re-do of my side and front yard I won't complain.

    This post was edited by desertgarden561 on Sun, Jul 28, 13 at 20:37

  • 13 years ago

    I don't know -- How recent is recent?

    Early in the corporate life of one well-known rose company, their catalog was a magnificent treasure trove, and we shoveled a lot of $$$ their way. But we got more mislabeled roses than correctly-labeled roses. Nor were they good about replacements.

    So we quit ordering from that source.

    But I've never held one mistake against a company. Have you notified them that you probably have the wrong rose? Because that's the real test. Like my grandmother always said: "We all make mistakes. That's why they put erasers on the end of lead pencils." :-)

    If they recoil in horror, and say:
    "YOIKS! We have failed you! The correct rose will be in the mail to you tomorrow!"
    I'd say they were a good company.

    If, OTOH, they say: "Tough luck. We don't make mistakes." Well, that's a different kettle of fish, and I would tell everyone in the rose world.

    Anyhow -- Souvenir de la Malmaison in either of its forms is not a good choice for coastal Ventura County.

    Jeri

  • 13 years ago

    Hi Jerijen,

    The rose was either mislabeled and actually is SDLM or they sent the wrong plant; a SDLM Climber. I realized the error yesterday and sent an e-mail as they were closed yesterday. I am hoping that the plants were just mis-labeled, but if it is an error, I feel pretty confident that a correction will be made, as the supplier is a reputable company. If a mistake was made, it could have been avoided by reading what was on the invoice versus their tag; it clearly does not match. If this was an error; someone dropped the ball so to speak and we are all human, but it is an inconvenience for me the customer and my hubby potted up the incorrect roses for me.

    The SDLM is for my garden in Las Vegas, but I have no real use for a climber ( could possibly find a home for two of them) and contemplated sending the incorrect plants to my sister- in -law in Ventura if the supplier does not want them returned; I am not sure what their exact protocol would be, but this same supplier sent a rather unhealthy plant that died and they are sending a replacement in October; kind of apples and oranges in that one plant is dead and the other three are healthy just incorrect so I have no point of reference.

    After your advice, should I remain left with the incorrect roses, I will not send a SDLM CL to my sister in law as it would not be carefree in her garden.

    If the roses are not replaced then I will definitely seek recourse and never order plants from the supplier again; but I have no reason to believe that this will be the scenario with them regarding this situation.

    Lynn

    This post was edited by desertgarden561 on Sun, Jul 28, 13 at 23:11

  • 13 years ago

    :-) Soldier On. We'll all hope it works out well. And I'm happier to have spared Sis the frustration of wrong-rose-wrong-place.

    Jeri