Software
Houzz Logo Print
acmesarah

black leaf-tips on new rose

17 years ago

I'm a newbie to rose growing (except rugosas--which doesn't count). I bought a new David Austin, but shortly after developed blackspot (when it wasn't denuded by the local deer population) We have an irrigation system which I have timed to run at dawn so that the leaves won't stay too wet, but we haven't had a huge amount of real rain. I sprayed with organic fungicides recently using two different products this week, but I just noticed that many of the leaves, in addition to the black spot, have black tips on the ends. I'm in northern zone 7 so the growing season can last till November.

Should I cut off all the black spot and damaged leaves? Should I fertilize (i've been using fish emulsion and coffee grounds). And do you think more water on the roots (as opposed to overhead sprinklers) would help?

Comments (7)

  • 17 years ago

    Overhead watering at dawn should be fine.

    A sharp closeup photo might be helpful if you have one.

    Organic fungicides tend to burn foliage in hot weather, so that could be the cause, especially if one contains sulfur and the other contains any kind of oil. That combination is death to leaves.

    IMO, blackspotted leaves should be removed unless you are using a good systemic fertilizer such as Bayer Disease Control. Burnt leaves do no harm beyond looking bad. If there is substantial green left on the leaf, the leaf is helping the plant.

  • 17 years ago

    Sounds like you have both the disease blackspot, and leaves damaged by a)chemical burn from using two different sprays in one week and/or b) drought damage and/or c) fertilizer burn on newly planted roots.

    Daily sprinklings isn't good for roses. You need to soak them long enough to get the whole root area wet, and then wait for that water to drain off or be used up before watering again. That usually means not every day. Every few days, depending on soil type and weather. You're right to water early in the day, but you're probably watering too short and too often. Roses need about an inch of rain or sprinklers every week.

    David Austen roses are very susceptible to blackspot. That's life. Blackspot can't be killed once it sets in, you have to spray regularly, before you see it, to prevent it.

    Only use one fungicide at a time. Two in one week is too much. More is not better. You can damage plants by misusing fungicides and insecticides. And make sure the plants are well watered the day before spraying, to avoid burning them with the chemicals. I also don't spray when the daytime temp is going to go over 85 degrees as plants can burn in hot temps.

    Leave the rose alone for now. It needs all its leaves on it to prepare for winter, even if they're damaged. The rose will drop them itself if it's necessary. No fertilizer this late in the game, and it's best not to fertilize newly planted plants anyway. Start anew in spring, with fertilizer and preventative fungicides.

  • 17 years ago

    " No fertilizer this late in the game, and it's best not to fertilize newly planted plants anyway. Start anew in spring, with fertilizer and preventative fungicides."
    -----------------------------------------------------------

    This is just a question: I thought you would want to take care of the blackspot this season. If left untreated, wouldn't it harbor spores over the winter, then re-occur in the Spring???

  • 17 years ago

    It is not too late to fertilize in Southeastern zone 7, but the OP has not indicated her location.

    Fish emulsion and coffee grounds are both mostly nitrogen fertilizers, which could be OK if you have good soil (containing clay) with reserves of potassium and phosphorus. That is often the case, but if you haven't had a soil test, it might be better to use a fertilizer with an NPK ratio between 1-1-1 and 3-1-2.

  • 17 years ago

    I see in my first post I wrote "systemic fertilizer" when I meant "systemic fungicide."

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks all for your responses. I took a close look at the tips and they were quite oily and soft. The spray I used contained cinnamon oil, so it may be a leaf burn from over spraying. It is still putting out buds but the blooms are about 1/3 the size of the original. When I researched BS here on the forum, many of the organic remedies contained vinegar--would spritzing the soil around the plant neutralize some of the spores? My soil isn't great--though clay is part of it. A soil test is probably in order.

  • 17 years ago

    No vinegar, it is toxic to plants! Don't worry about the soil. The disease mainly spreads from leaf (or cane) to leaf. To work, organic fungicides need to coat all leaf surfaces preventatively. Since they are not very effective, if you are going to rely on them in the East or South, you need to select somewhat resistant varieties and begin regular spraying at leaf-out in the spring.