Software
Houzz Logo Print
hartwood_gw

RMV in Austin Roses

18 years ago

I'm just now getting around to posting this, though it's been eating at me for a few weeks. Two of my Austin roses, both purchased this spring from J&P, look like this:

{{gwi:316808}}

The two large leaves are from Pat Austin, and the three small ones are from Molineux.

I am almost ready to completely swear off Texas-grown roses on Dr. Huey. There just doesn't appear to be any concern at all about proliferating this disease through our gardens. There's no solution to this for me, except to toss the two roses in question. Thought about contacting J&P to notify them of them problem -- decided I'd be wasting my breath. What are they going to do . . . replace them with new ones? No thanks.

I just thought you all would like to know, in case you want to go out and check your own roses. This is obviously not just a problem with cheap, bagged roses -- in fact, many of my own bag roses are doing very nicely. These two Austins, however, are struggling. I guess I would struggle, too, if I were this sick.

Connie

Comments (28)

  • 18 years ago

    That's interesting - I have a ~3 y.o. Molineaux, potted, and it has leaves looking like that. I thought it was spider mites, but could not see any other evidence of mites (no webbing or mites that I could see). Not sure if it was originally from J&P or DA.

    My Moli bloomed his head off in Spring, and has just sat there all summer. Not growing, not blooming. I wonder if that could be the issue with him??

  • 18 years ago

    Well, OF COURSE they are virused.
    If they have been in commerce for a few years, and they are on Dr. Huey, they are
    almost by definition virused.

    You probably have many more virused roses than you are aware of.

    If you are in a mild climate (like CA) you can grow a virused rose for years,
    and it will probably perform reasonably well. But of course, it won't
    stand up to stress as well as it might have done, if not infected.

    Jeri

  • 18 years ago

    So then what happens if you buy an own root Austin?

    Are the vendors that propagate the own root roses able to get virus free stock to propagate from?? I don't see how they could.

    Guess I just need more Barden roses (not much chance of RMV there).

  • 18 years ago

    So then what happens if you buy an own root Austin?
    Are the vendors that propagate the own root roses able to get virus free stock to propagate from??

    *** EXCELLENT question!

    Yes, some roses have been "cleaned" through programs at UC Davis, and Florida.
    (Malcolm Manners is "The Man" on this issue.)

    Own-Root plants are as virused (or not) as the plants from which they were propagated.
    So ASK, before you buy.

    Do NOT accept "it must be virus-free because it is imported." Or because it is own-root. Or any other "because."
    The only assurance is knowing that it has been TESTED, and proven clean.

    I bought 2 'Dark Ladies' from Heirloom Roses.
    They were propagated from a "mother" plant imported from Austin, in England.
    I have rarely seen plants so remarkably virused.
    (And no, they did not "catch" it from another plant in the ground here.)
    Providentially, both were in pots.
    And that was even more providential, since both also turned out to have gall.

    Heirloom THOUGHT their plant was virus-free, as it came from Austin, in England.
    WRONG. It tested virused.

    This is hardly surprising, since we have been exporting virused roses to England
    for the better part of 100 years.

    Jeri

  • 18 years ago

    I wouldn't want more of the same thing either, just wanted to let you know that I did get some RMV roses replaced by J&P, they claimed that the new ones are heat indexed, but time will tell. I would be glad to email the contact phone # to you. Calling the customer service at J&P is a waste of time, they don't know what RMV is! Maybe they would give you a credit, but I don't know if you would want anything from them.
    Diana

  • 18 years ago

    I know that Ashdown has reimported budwood from Austin and the late and much appreciated seller in Florida (Ken Muncey ) had budwood direct from Austin. I trust both of them.
    I had RMV problems with all the Austin roses I had from Park Wayside so have avoided buying any replacements of those cultivars from sources who haven't reimported budwood.
    So far, the newer ones from Pickering are growing well. (at four to five years.)

    The old J&P and the new J&P are going to need some adjusting to. Will the roses coming out of SC from J&P be better or worse? One thing for sure, they won't be the same as those grown in Wasco.

    Also check with Roses Unlimited and Chamblee's as to the sources of their mother plants.

  • 18 years ago

    Yes, but remember, Heirloom imported from Austin, and received a virused plant.
    It's probably not common, but it HAS happened.

    Jeri

  • 18 years ago

    Okay...I'm a beginner, only growing roses for 5 years. For sure I could go out in my garden and find a virused plant. I have bought roses from many vendors. What to do?

  • 18 years ago

    I should think that if you bought them from a good own root vendor they should notice if the mother plants are virused or not, but then how would you know where they became virused? i suppose if a vendor gets many complaints they would quit propagating from that plant.

  • 18 years ago

    While the rest of you riff on the RMV and Dr. Huey, I still can't get past the fact that I cannot say these roses are showing RMV. Is there any chance of seeing a larger image? Looks like spider mite and/or leaf hopper damage to me.

  • 18 years ago

    "So then what happens if you buy an own root Austin?"

    I have 6 from J&P, own root, no sign of that but a touch of BS, not nearly as bad as on other ones.

    Graham Thomas which I purchased from a Texas grower has those purple spots on the old growth, can't remember what it is, but no sign of RMV. New canes are clean. That is own root.

    Actually I've seen more chlorotic symptoms on a couple, one is Dark Lady. Also much BS, no sign of RMV on any of my Austins, have quite a few others, but they are grafted on multiflora.

  • 18 years ago

    "Looks like spider mite and/or leaf hopper damage to me."

    I went and looked at mine again and it looks more like spider mite or leaf hopper than RMV. I will post some photos of mine tomorrow, if I can.

    I do think the RMV issue is interesting.

  • 18 years ago

    hartwood--your roses may or may not be virused, but I can't tell from your pics. They don't look like the virus my Earth Song exhibits--more like zigzag lines of a lighter color on an otherwise green and "normal" leaf.

    Since your Austins are new, it is possible that you just need to wait another year or two to see them really thrive. I've had several Austins that sometimes looked a bit pathetic their first year or so--called them my wimps--but now in their third year, they have lost all their wimpiness. That includes my 3 Molineux, by the way, which now, in their third year, just can't quit blooming and pushing out more new healthy growth.

    It's a possibility anyway.

    Kate

  • 18 years ago

    Because Austin has started their own mail order in the US, using plants propagated in the US manner in Arizona, they are now open to all the potential virus infection as all the other major US growers.

    Personally, one of the most virused plants in my garden came from Muncy. No one is immune to this problem.

  • 18 years ago

    As requested, here are some more images:

    These is the reverse side of the same two leaves from Pat Austin as the image above (they were still in the scanner), with three smaller new Pat Austin leaves that I just plucked.

    {{gwi:316810}}
    {{gwi:316811}}

    I left the image size a bit large, and I split the scan in half to get it even larger. As I zoomed in on the leaves using Photoshop, I didn't see spider mite damage. Anyone else?

    Here's spider mite damage on R. glauca and Moonlight. It looks really different to me. The tiny bleached-out spots that eventually make the entire leaf look dry and greyish that you see here are not on the Austin roses at all.

    {{gwi:316812}}

    And here's a closeup of R. glauca, front and back sides of the leaflets . . . gotta go get the hose and give them a shower . . .

    {{gwi:316813}}

    I accept that RMV is a fact that we are forced to deal with in our roses -- I certainly don't like it, though. If this IS RMV, I cannot live with this degree of disfigurement. I'm glad these two roses are in pots -- it'll be much easier to toss them into the trash.

    Connie

  • 18 years ago

    That is not RMV. Now....it could be lurking there, of course, but RMV isn't what is causing the discoloration of these leaves. The reverse of the Pat Austin shows the cast skins clearly. I suppose the rose could also have both leaf hoppers and spider mites.

    All you need is a 10X magnifying glass or a jeweler's loupe. You can see the leaf-hoppers. You can also see spider mites. They look different, and spider mites often show webbing.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Photos of leaf hopper damage

  • 18 years ago

    Great images tho!
    BIG help!

    And the good news is, as Cass says, no virus showing.

    Jeri

  • 18 years ago

    Cass . . . you're a peach, as always. Spider mites I can handle. This is presenting so much differently than I'm used to, so it threw me.

    Jeri . . . the flat-bed scanner idea is the bomb!

    Thanks, everyone.

    Connie

  • 18 years ago

    Jeri . . . the flat-bed scanner idea is the bomb!

    *** We can all thank Fa Shimbo in CO for that dandy idea.
    :-)

    Jeri

  • 18 years ago

    So far so good on my own root Austins from Heirloom, Palatine and Northland Rosarium. I have not seen any RMV yet. The plants I got from Austin's nsy in Texas have not shown the disease. Everything from Wayside has been sick and is being replaced as I can afford it.

    Sadly, my friend down the street has some badly virused HTs. I offered to help her remove them and replace, but she refuses to see that they will not recover. Every year they get more spindly and weak. I see so many cases like this.......it makes me sad.

    P.S. A no-RMV Sonia Rykiel? Anybody know who has one for sale?

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    Kitty: Sonia Rykiel from Roses Unlimited doesn't have RMV, bought that back in 2012.

    I don't see any RMV among my 34 own-root Austins (including the Dark Lady) bought many years ago from Chamblee nursery, Roses Unlimited and Regan Nursery. My recent Austin own-roots (from LongAgoRoses) bought last year don't have RMV either.

    I plan to order Young Lycidas, England's Rose, Gabriel Oak, Boscobel from David Austin for next year, but would like to know if these roses are safe from RMV. Thanks for any info.

    I have seen really bad pictures of RMV on Evelyn posted in HMF, but my 12th-year own root Evelyn DOES NOT have RMV. Below is 8th-year-own-root The Dark Lady (from Roses Unlimited), always healthy in my rock-hard clay with only 4 hours of sun:


  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    Unless you actually test a rose for virus, you can't say definitively that it does not have virus. Many roses grow happily for decades and never show visual symptoms of infection. I know for a fact that my two plants of 'Rose de Rescht' are virused*, but they have only displayed "lightning" marked leaves three times in 27 years. You cannot make a diagnosis based solely on the absence of visual symptoms.

    * it is highly likely that ALL plants of 'Rose de Rescht' in collections and in commerce are virused.

  • 4 years ago

    At our local nursery, a couple of own root Austin roses show clear signs of RMV. They ordered directly from Austin. The rate of infected Austin roses will probably go higher and higher since they most likely use the same tools to trim all roses. And when the mother plant is infected the cuttings will be infected too. So grafted or own root… both will have RMV eventually.

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    I have never bought any plants from David Austin company for my entire life, but I have bought 150+ own-roots from USA companies. Due to this past harsh winter that killed many trees in my zone 5a, I'm thinking about ordering from David Austin FOR THE FIRST TIME.

    Among my 150+ own-roots, there's ONLY ONE that shows RMV: It's own-root Gruss an Teplitz, which I got from Burlington Nursery in CA, back in 2012.

    A friend in my zone 5a informed me that her own-root Lemon Spice from Rogue Valley Roses has RMV. Rose de Rescht was the one that Al in my Chicagoland gave away to the public years ago.

    RMV showed up on own-root Gruss an Teplitz when there's too much rain which leaches out potassium (necessary for disease prevention).

    Gruss has been wimpy since day one when I first grew it in a pot back in 2012, and transferring to my clay doesn't help. I was surprised when Pakistan rosarians informed me that Gruss is THE MOST VIGOROUS as own-root in their country, growing wild at 120 F degree heat.

    This showed up only twice for the past 12 years that I have Gruss, so I took a picture, see below:



  • 4 years ago

    'Gruss an Telpitz' here in my climate is a terrible cultivar: no vigor, Blackspots like no tomorrow, worthless. It needs a HOT climate to prosper. After all, its 100% China/Tea in pedigree, so its need for heat is hardly surprising.

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    For my 34 own-root Austin roses, only one has RMV: Queen of Sweden bought from Roses Unlimited back in 2013. So it's one out of my 34 OWN ROOT Austins that has RMV.

    OWN-ROOT Austins which I bought from Chamblee's Nursery over a decade ago DO NOT have RMV.

    I wonder if the rate of RMV is much higher with GRAFTED Austins on Dr.Huey-rootstock?

    From Houzz and HMF, folks report RMV (rose mosaic virus) on these Austin roses: The Dark Lady, Pat Austin, Molineux,Jude the Obscure, Evelyn, The Alnwick rose, Gertrude Jekyll, Lady Emma Hamilton, Princess Alexandra of Kent, Rosemoore, Huntington, Queen of Sweden.

  • 4 years ago

    @strawchicago z5 "I wonder if the rate of RMV is much higher with GRAFTED Austins on Dr.Huey-rootstock?"


    Oh, absolutely, yes. However, you don't know if a rose does not have RMV unless you've tested it (using the Agdia test kit)and gotten a negative result. There are many, many roses in commerce that are known to be infected with PNRSV (and others) which do not ever show evidence of the infection. Some cultivars simply don't. Unless you can prove that the plant is "clean" then you can't assume its clean just because you don't see visual evidence of an infection.

Sponsored
J.Holderby - Renovations
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars4 Reviews
Franklin County's Leading General Contractors - 2X Best of Houzz!