Software
Houzz Logo Print
gardennatlanta

What would you do with this?

15 years ago

Pictured below is a very small band of Careless Love--a rose I've wanted to try for a long time. I got it this spring, repotted it into this one gallon pot, and put it under a tree in my pot ghetto. All it seems to have done is lose its leaves. It does seem to have a little leaf bud on the top but is still only about 2 inches tall.

{{gwi:313426}}

What would you do with this tiny baby? Repot? Fertilize? Just wait?

Thanks.

Comments (14)

  • 15 years ago

    If it drains well, I'd begin feeding it with a weak solution of water soluble fertilizer every other week. All of the Radiance clan are vigorous growers own root. It appears this one is just too little material to be vigorous. If you give it weak feedings, more frequently than you would heavier ones, you just might be able to encourage it to get growing. If the fertilizer says a tablespoon per gallon every two weeks, consider half or quarter tablespoon per gallon every week, or even every other watering.

    I'm pushing along some small seedlings doing this right now. They're in one and two gallon cans. Instead of giving them a thorough drenching with the fertilizer solution, I only give them a couple of tablespoons after every other watering. They're growing, so it must be working. And, I'm not permitting them to flower at all. I want plant, not bloom...yet. Kim

  • 15 years ago

    Have patience and absolutely don't do anything to upset the soil (I would even put something like bricks or rocks on each side to keep it from getting knocked over. And pray the squirrels don't take an interest.) Do not repot or fertilize (if you do it should be weak, like very diluted fish emulsion)

  • 15 years ago

    If it were mine, I would do nothing, except maybe make sure it drains, move it into more light, and make sure it is protected from squirrels and deer. I have grown many healthy large roses from beginnings that looked very like this one!

    Jackie

  • 15 years ago

    If it drains well, I'd begin feeding it with a weak solution of water soluble fertilizer every other week.

    Yes, me too, emphasis on "weak". You want to give it just a little nudge to get it going, then it will take it from there.

    I used to use weak fish emulsion for this very activity, but now I've read the north Atlantic menhaden population is rapidly being fished to extinction for omega-3 and fish emulsion manufacture, so I stopped using fish emulsion.

  • 15 years ago

    Organics are fine, I use them, but for a boost of this nature, any inorganic, water soluble fertilizer (Peter's, Schultz, Miracle Grow, etc.) beats them hands down. The plant needs something immediately available, in "infant" concentration. Kim

  • 15 years ago

    Replace it if at all possible. I've never had anything that dwindled so badly come back.

    BTW, Careless Love, while not a weak grower, seems a bit less vigorous than the rest of the Radiance clan, at least in my experience.

    Rosefolly

  • 15 years ago

    How do you like them apples???
    Is there a conflicting answer you haven't gotten?
    Fertilize. Don't Fertilize. Keep it. Throw it away.

    And why/how would you chose which path to follow? Everyone is sure s/he is right.

    Can you tell that I'm finding this source of information a bit shall we say unreliable?????

    I hope you can sort it out better than I could if I had asked the question (which I wouldn't consider doing for the reasons noted above....)

  • 15 years ago

    I agree that while the rest of the Radiance clan is bulletproof, I'm still waiting for a vigorous 'Careless Love.' (Kim -- if you have one . . . )

    I think I'd put it somewhere handy, where I wouldn't forget to water it, and just let it sit, and see what it does. Then, I'd contact Burling Leong (Burlington Rose Nursery) and ask if she has Careless Love for budding.

    Jeri

  • 15 years ago

    The best clone of Careless Love I've ever encountered was the one from The Huntington, Jeri. That's the one Sequoia, Ashdown and Burlington have all had. I spread it around to as many as who would take it. In Newhall, it was traditionally 4'X 3'. That's the plant pictured in Phillip's & Rix' Quest For the Rose. The plant I have is propagated from that clone but has reverted to Mrs. Charles Bell. I'd prefer the flower of Careless Love in the garden, but I have it as much for breeding as anything else and the genes are the same, no matter which flower it expresses. Kim

  • 15 years ago

    Well, I wouldn't throw it away. But I would not expect much from it, and I would be looking around for a good replacement.

    It is a gorgeous and fragrant rose, so it is well worth a bit of effort. I'm not a big HT fan, but it is on my HT short list.

    Rosefolly

  • 15 years ago

    Looks like maybe a tiny little root system is lost in all that damp potting soil. Sometimes I have this to happen if I step a not-to-vigorous variety up a pot size too quick.

    I would repot it into a band. Probably not much too lose.

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks everyone for all the replies.

    I've sorted through the information and decided the following:

    1. I'm not just going to let it stay in the pot and do nothing. I have a couple of "mystery roses" from RVR that I received a bit over a year ago and they are still fairly small (not nearly as small as Careless Love). With these I've done nothing and they've recipricated.

    2. I'm afraid to repot because the soil is fairly loose and I fear losing some precious roots.

    3. I have some plain old Miracle Gro. I read the box last night and will fertilize with half strength for house plants (1/2 teaspoon per gallon of water) BTW the amount for outside plants is a Tablespoon for a gallon and a half of water.

    If you're interested, I'll let you know how things turn out over the next few weeks.

    Again, despite there being a variety of opinion, I very much appreciate your input. Jeff

  • 15 years ago

    Jeff, I'm interested. : )

  • 15 years ago

    Absolutely, Jeff, please? I found with some of the roses I obtained from both Sequoia and EuroDesert closings, they had them in far too loose soil with a tremendous amount of perlite. That was necessary for their watering systems but terrible for my hose watering. Once I got them into more substantial soil, they took off. Trying to repot them in that nursery mix was a royal pain! It was SO loose, the root balls just crumbled in my hands like rotten styrofoam.

    I think I would cut the concentration from house plant down a bit more than you mention. You can always add more, but it's quite difficult to take some away without drowning the plant. I think you'll find some improvement following this course. Good luck! Kim