Software
Houzz Logo Print
barbarag_happy

Own-root Floribundas -- Wimpy???

18 years ago

I have several thriving own-root floribundas-- Hot Cocoa, Lavaglut, Coffee Country but Playboy is still small in its 2nd year despite lots of water and feeding every 3 weeks. No sign of virus. I always thought Playboy was a vigorous rose (likewise Playgirl & others). I just received Honey Bouquet & Oklahoma, also on their own roots. If it takes 2 to 3 years for them to develop I can live with that. Just wondering what y'all's experience is with own-roots. (I also grow a lot of antiques and older shrubs & they are all fabulous on their own roots with the exception of Sombrueil..)

Comments (10)

  • 18 years ago

    barbara, i have found it to be all over the map with no rhyme or reason. even the same cultivars can be so different. I just leave them to do their own thing and yes some even die. but i have had some that didn't do anything and wrote off and then overnight they send up a huge 3' cane.

  • 18 years ago

    Barbara, we grew Playboy for years, and yes, grew it own-root.
    It was really pretty vigorous here, and bloomed well. It stayed with us
    until we stopped spraying, at which point both Playboy and Playgirl
    demonstrated an ability to rust and mildew unattractively, most of the year.

    The one that was dependably vigorous and CLEAN was Ralph Moore's 'Playtime.'
    If you can find that, and you don't mind vivid red-orange, it's a good 'un.
    At least, it is here.

    Jeri

  • 18 years ago

    I have lavaglut on it's own roots and it's doing well. Of course I had to wait three-four years.

  • 18 years ago

    It took six years for Playboy to show RMV zigzags here; mine was grafted and did well for four years. Then I went into denial, then RMV showed.

    As a general rule, the only floribunda that seems to be a universal hit in the southeast (without the high care normally given to 'show' roses) is Eutin. There are several roses called Eutin in the southeast; all have become passalong plants and are doing it on their own roots.

    You won't see old Floribundas in my part of the world; they don't last all that well. They don't choose to go own root.
    I have a Dickie that was dug from an exhibitors garden where it had become a huge plant on a graft, but the graft was starting to rot as we dug it up. When dug, it split up into multiple plants, the offspring haven't rebounded to the size of their parent. (It's been six years, aka long enough.) I understand one Dickie that I shared with someone in CA has grown vigorously. Different soils for different roses.

    In my soils, I do find Orleans Rose kin surviving well on their own roots; something in them loves acidic red clay; but there aren't any FLs that seem to be close to Orleans et al and that may be the hitch.

  • 18 years ago

    Len, thanks-you've convinced me once AGAIN to give 'em time. My garden is in its 2nd season. Guess this post borders on whining huh?
    Jeri--have only seen pics of Playtime, sure hope it remains in commerce.
    Ann--went straight to hmf to look at Orleans Rose which I've never seen in person--what sprays! Several other polyanthas do well here-- Perle d'Or, Marie Daly/Pavie, and various Fairys. Thanks for mention of Eutin-- I do like to direct people towards the bulletproof ones!
    Both Lavaglut and Escapade do very well here, tho I suspect Escapade might be bigger and bloom more in a cooler climate.

  • 18 years ago

    I'm on the fence about Own root roses. My experience with them has been good and bad. No different really then with grafted. Therefore I was surprised when Tuscan Sun took off like gangbusters on its own roots. No whimping around for 3 years at all. It's a beautiful rose, and it's proven very popular all across the country. Blooms start out an attractive burnt orange with apricot yellow reverse and change color to a silvery pink. Most attractive. Anyway, it has proven to me that some own root roses can be just as vigorous as grafted even from the get go.

  • 18 years ago

    ent straight to hmf to look at Orleans Rose which I've never seen in person--what sprays

    *** A "Found" Polyantha we have here came from a Gold Rush Era (and later) cemetery.
    It has been identified as 'Orleans Rose,' and I am told it makes a beautiful ball
    of sprays of bloom.
    {{gwi:307669}}

    These roses don't really like our pH, but this is worth a little soil sulfur.
    We also grow and love 'Lady Reading,' another vigorous beauty on its own roots.

    Jeri

  • 18 years ago

    IMO, we have a problem. The problem goes back to when regional nurseries were overwhelmed and undercut by the 'big guys' growing roses far from our soils.

    I've started collecting info that could fit into a "What did we know and when did we forget it" about what roses grew well and where they grey well. (And I dare not omit 'when')
    The found roses that Jeri talks about are proven survivors in their corners of the world. I think the word is spelled terroire, I see it in reference to foods grown near where they are cooked, but I'm not sure what the ramifications of the real meaning might be.
    Even with species roses, what do we really know?
    An example: I was searching for something else last night and found a reference from the mid 1800s that said (as if everyone would know this) that the writer KNEW the soils there were drier because Rosa blanda was growing on them.

    It was news to me.

    That's one of the reasons I think Eutin (or the many roses called Eutin) are interesting- they've become passalong roses. Roses that fail locally don't get passed along more than once.

  • 18 years ago

    I was happy to see Anntn bring up Eutin, particulary her comment that there are several versions of it.

    I wish I had kept track of where I got mine as I would like to get some more. My current one is an own root that I grew and as I said I've forgotten where it came from.

    Anyway mine is an 8 petalled flower that is very pretty when open. Unlike the pictures I've seen of Eutin. More petals that open out showing stamens. It is a marvelous rose!

  • 18 years ago

    Ann, well said! Not very scientific, but if I am considering a rose I often look up where the suppliers are-- and if I see TX, MS, SC I am encouraged. The only book on my shelf that makes regional recommendations is Ortho's All About Roses (Tommy Cairns), at least in my copy which is dated 1999. I don't know of any floribunda whose performance comes close to that of say, Caldwell Pink (Pink Pet). I may end up with a grouping of polyanthas eventually. I was never a big one for SP'ing up north in Ohio, but here in the SE it seems to be a fact of life.

Sponsored
High Point Cabinets
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars21 Reviews
Columbus' Experienced Custom Cabinet Builder | 4x Best of Houzz Winner