Software
Houzz Logo Print
strawchicago

BAD topsoil and compost/manure

15 years ago

Everyday I spend time NOT with my roses, but plucking weeds from my tomato garden, inherited from BAD BAGGED compost/manure 5 years ago.

I forget what store it's from, but that compost/cow manure reeked and I could smell it inside the house. It was in a yellowish bag. After that we got tons of weeds that last until this day. Before that my tomato garden was squeaky clean.

This year when I started my rose bed I used Moo-Cow-Manure (in a black/purple bag). I used Earth-Gro topsoil (in a red/white bag), also from HomeDepo. Zero weeds, even after many rains.

I mulched my roses with aged horsemanure. The stable owner warned me that there might be some oat seeds. No smell in the aged horsemanure, and no weeds either, after 2 rainy months.

I use Scotts' Premium Topsoil with peat moss for my annual flowers garden - no weeds either.

When I started my garden 12 years ago, I ordered a pile of topsoil. I didn't realize it was the same hardened alkaline clay soil as mine - it killed two Charles Jolly lilac bushes, and a Japanese Maple tree.

To make it worse, I enriched with bagged Mushroom Compost (even more alkaline, as Michaelg warned). We got so much topsoil left-over that I put up a huge sign, "FREE TOPSOIL" by our mailbox. Luckily neighbors came to the rescue.

At least I didn't get much weeds from that topsoil delivery. Secondly, my topsoil grew from 10" to more than 2 feet deep. The plants have deeper roots, and I don't have to water.

My neighbor has another horror story from the bagged topsoil from Menards. She put a little bit of that stuff, plus some grass seeds by her mailbox. A few years later, the crabgrass grew to a giant area (the size of a school bus). She is considering using a sod-cutter, cut all that crabgrass out, put in new topsoil, and seed the area.

She also killed dandelions with Round-Up spray, and burnt her grass. Then she dug the dead grass out, and put more Mernards' topsoil. Out sprung tons of interesting weeds, besides dandelions.

Anyone else have bad or good experience with topsoil, or compost/manure?

Comments (4)

  • 15 years ago

    Yes I have bought some bagged soil that contained weed seeds before :-( lol

  • 15 years ago

    Fortunately, I haven't had that experience. I always battle the regular old things which are already here and blow in. I cringe when someone knew wants to tour the weed patch, wondering what kinds of wonderful things they'll bring in on their shoes. There isn't a "gardener" to bring things in on his shoes and equipment anymore. I remember reading in a LA Times article years ago they've estimated up to 30,000 weed seeds in a cubic yard of native soil. Some of them only need the small amount of light provided by pulling up a neighboring weed, during a full moon. With odds like that already against me, I honestly don't worry about things coming in bags. But, then I always buy the same product from the same source as it's never failed to please and remains the best deal around for this type of product.

    A fellow Huntington Volunteer many years ago brought in active Oak Root Fungus in a load of compost she bought from Armstrong Garden Centers. Up till it arrived, she'd never had any issues. Within weeks of having it spread, things began dying, including a decades old Ficus hedge which provided her Trousdale Estates home with privacy from the neighbors. From what she said, that was quite a settlement. Kim

  • 15 years ago

    I'm glad to hear from you, Kim - that is interesting regarding how compost can spread Oak Root Fungus.

    I want to thank Moril (zone 5/KS) who informed me that given the right condition, fungi can grow anywwhere. I checked: 1) there are 6 species of fungi growing on horse manure 2) there are at least 25 species of fungi growing on tree bark - the most destructive one is artillery fungus.

    If you google "artillery fungus", there's this YouTube on how this fungi make the house look really ugly. I have black mold growing on my white sidings, which is NOT pretty.

    There's an interesting article on how mushroom compost suppresses this destructive artillery fungus. See the link: http://www.personal.psu.edu/users/d/d/ddd2/images/mushroom_artillery.pdf

    Mushroom compost is composed of straw, dried blood, and horse manure. My guess is that the bacteria in the horse manure suppresses artillery fungus, very much like what Jacklau from CT suggested that the bacteria in horse manure suppress blackspot spores on roses. He grows more than 200 roses, so I appreciate his insight.

  • 15 years ago

    I've had this problem too. I've brought bags home and opened them and there were already green weeds growing inside the bags! How they did that with no light is beyond me! But even if they didn't have seed in them I'd have a ton of weeds anyway. The seeds are blown in, carried in, dropped in from most everywhere and everything out there. They are prolific, resilient and opportunistic. That's why we call them WEEDS!