Software
Houzz Logo Print
racin_rose

Question about soil preferences for HPs and Bourbons

13 years ago

Just like the title says... I don't have many OGRs, so I am curious what these particular types like:

Louise Odier
Honorine de Brabant
Ferdinand Pichard
Alfred Colomb

I'm not a fan of striped roses outside of OGRs, the two above I REALLY hope thrive. HdB, Ferdinand, and Alfred are 2 gallons from Antique Rose Emporium.
My Souvenir du Docteur Jamain band from RVR gave up the ghost. I didn't think it looked particularly vigorous when I got it, but it's the only band I've ever lost.
I know they like well-draining soil, but...

Do they prefer rich soil, or just average? As much feeding as HTs, or less? I started it in a pot as I do all my bands with the same soil, but it just languished. I didn't feed it anything other than a dilute fish emulsion once when it seemed to be going downhill, but it didn't perk up.

Thanks in advance!

Aaaaaand I see I posted this in the wrong forum.

This post was edited by racin_rose on Wed, Sep 18, 13 at 13:53

Comments (6)

  • 13 years ago

    I have several small Bourbons of the Souvenir de la Malmaison clan, also Mme. Dore and Romaggi Plot Bourbon, and they don't require any special attention. I haven't even fertilized them this year, and the only thing that stresses them is heat and lack of rain. I've heard and read that the HP's like a rich diet, being lusty bushes with big blooms, so once they're in the ground a good organic rose food would probably be of benefit, and I'm sure the Bourbons would like that too.

    Ingrid

  • 13 years ago

    Reading Victorian and Edwardian era rose texts, roses were described as "gross feeders". Own root, I'd imagine their preferences would be as varied as any other class, but you can be sure that huge, many petaled flowers on largish, semi climbing plants are going to require more food and water than "bush" types with fewer petals. Hmm, sounds a lot like many of the larger English roses, doesn't it? I can't provide you with personal information about what makes them happiest because in my soils and climates, in which I have attempted the ones I've tried, very few were anything approaching what you might call "happy". That's why the ones which have hung around as long as they have here, are still here. They don't require much different from the "norm."

    Many grew rather well at Limberlost Roses, the Old Rose specialty nursery which was in Van Nuys, Ca. The vast majority were budded on either multiflora from Canada, or Huey from American sources and all were potted in Bandini 102 potting soil. I just tried searching to see if that soil was still around and found the name owned by Spectrum Brands, a huge owner of many products we all know. Interesting. KIm

  • 13 years ago

    I grow one Bourbon and 2 HPs--in the same soil and with the same care that all my other roses get. They seem to do OK.

    Kate

  • 13 years ago

    Kim, what was Bandini 102 potting soil? Sounds radioactive.....
    Susan

  • 13 years ago

    I suspect the 19th c grower saw all repeating roses as "gross feeders" compared to once-bloomers and perennials. As Kim suggested, yours probably don't have requirements different from other fairly vigorous repeating roses.

  • 13 years ago

    Thanks everyone for the help, I appreciate it. I guess I'll just have to let Docteur Jamain go and move on with my life...hehe

    Thanks again!