Software
Houzz Logo Print
julie_b_roses

Roses in clay

19 years ago

We moved about a month ago and the soil is completely different than any I have gardened in before. I tried to plant things at our first house where the soil was typical Florida sand. Nothing grew. Then we moved and our soil was muck improved through the years by previous gardening. Everything grew and flourished. Now we're in a new house with another type of soil. The top 8-18 inches (depending on the location in the yard) is sandy dirt (fill from the builder), then it's solid clay. I don't know how far down the clay goes since I've never found a bottom.

I know the roses can't stand in water and I know if I dig a hole into the clay the water will stand in the bottom. So if I dig down to the clay and plant the roses in the top foot of decent soil will they do okay? Or am I going to have to dig a very wide and deep hole and remove the clay?

All these types of soil and yet all three of our homes have been within a 50 mile radius. I'll have to learn to grow roses all over again!

Comments (3)

  • 19 years ago

    You can grow good roses in sand if you water and fertilize lightly but more frequently. You can grow good roses in clay if you avoid compacting it while it is wet. Clay holds nutrients and water much better. However, layered soils such as you describe are considered undesirable.

    Where the sand is not too deep, the obvious solution is to mix clay and sand in equal parts (or up to 80% sand) to a depth of 14", which is about as deep as roses on fortuniana will root. Also mix plenty of organic matter into the top 8-10". This should be done over the whole bed rather than in holes. It would be a big job, but would leave you with better soil than most people in Florida have.

    If you are in a flat, low-lying area, there might be some concern about drainage during the rainy season in the areas where clay is near the surface. Raising the bed 6" above grade should take care of that. Digging deep holes does nothing to improve drainage-- the water still has to drain away through the subsoil clay beneath.

    Don't tread on, dig or work the clay unless it is dry enough that clods break rather than mash. Otherwise you make bricks that will stay that way for decades.

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks, Michael. I just started putting in my roses, so far I've only put two in the ground. Basically I did what you suggested, although I haven't worked the whole bed yet. I am putting them in existing beds so that makes the job easier. And I doubt I have 20% clay, probably closer to 10%. When I extend the rose planting area in the rest of the bed, I'll increase the amount of clay.

    I *think* I'll be okay with drainage. The house and beds are raised from the edges of the property. When we first moved in they had been watering every day and the beds were wet, but there was no standing water in them. (Yes, within the first week I had already dug in several spots to see what I was dealing with.) Lower portions of the lawn took over a week with no water to dry out.

    I think someone else has already made bricks in some areas of the yard. In a non rose area I pulled out pieces of clay that I thought were rocks!

  • 19 years ago

    Even 10% clay will improve your soil's fertility significantly.