Pruning Species Roses

11 years ago

First off. I HAVE to stop and take a photo but.........

The new development that I find interesting in a nutty gardening way planted what looks like dozens of native type species roses that have been happy. Pink blooms, suckers galore and wonderful red hips were rippening until last week when they got pruned and the suckers weeded out. Only rather than maybe take a hedge trimmer to keep them off the sidewalks some one had them pruned on the sides and them rounded the tops. It looks like a half a block of odd giant broccoli statues.

Now maybe there is a reason for it.... But I notice they stopped or were stopped before they reached the next section.

Amazing

Other than "no clue" any one have any guesses what or why they did that to them?

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (8)

jacqueline9CA
11 years ago
The hired "gardeners" around here do that to any shrub that doesn't run away - trim the sides, and make the top round. No idea what they are doing, nor do they care what kind of shrub it is - just appear to be aiming for "neat and tidy".

Jackie
roseseek
11 years ago
That's called "clean up" and it is what the basic instructions are in many instances. You see it frequently on "Crimes Against Horticulture - When Bad Taste Meets Power Tools". Billy Goodnick has a regular presence with this on Face Book. Some of the photos he shares are terrible, but the captions are great. The wrong things are often planted in the wrong places and no one really knows what to do with them, so they "clean them up". Terrible, to be sure, but that's what it frequently done. Kim

Here is a link that might be useful: When Bad Taste Meets Power Tools
Related Professionals
Rolla Landscape Architects & Landscape Designers · Greensboro Landscape Architects & Landscape Designers · Lawrenceburg Landscape Architects & Landscape Designers · Greenfield Landscape Architects & Landscape Designers · Nashua Landscape Architects & Landscape Designers · Wenatchee Landscape Architects & Landscape Designers · Aberdeen Landscape Contractors · Elizabeth City Landscape Contractors · Harrisonburg Landscape Contractors · Muncie Landscape Contractors · Barnstable Landscape Contractors · Concord Home Builders · Longview Home Builders · Kalamazoo Home Builders · Riverside Home Builders
Kippy
Original Author
11 years ago
Kim. Billy is a local so I have been waiting on him to add this to his blog

But boy is it funny.
User
11 years ago
Oh dear. The very nature of species roses militates against rampant pruning. None of these roses will see a pair of secateurs in their native setting...and yet, winds, rain and snow, along with grazing animals, will naturally keep them in good health. I am not intending on doing anything with mine apart from admiring the rampageous growth...but then again, I am not growing these rosey despots anywhere where unwary passers-by are likely to end up in A&E.
jerijen
11 years ago
"Crimes Against Horticulture - When Bad Taste Meets Power Tools".

That's exactly what I thought of.
ingrid_vc so. CA zone 9
11 years ago
I couldn't stop laughing. The captions to all these horticultural horrors are so hilarious. These pictures made me feel so much better about the natural messiness of my garden. You have to wonder about the mindset of people who create these tortured specimens. I do believe nature scares them; no Sierra Club members here.......

Ingrid
jacqueline9CA
11 years ago
To quote Melissa from Italy on another thread: "Tidiness is the curse of those on a quest for beauty".

Jackie
roseseek
11 years ago
Thankfully, I don't suffer from that level of anal retentiveness in my own garden! The only times I prune species and close species hybrids are to either rejuvenate them so I observe significant new growth and its beauty, or to move and replant them. Very seldom, particularly out in the old Newhall garden, I would have to whack something to the ground to eliminate a rat's nest or something. Otherwise, I leave them pretty much to their own devices. Kim