Software
Houzz Logo Print
hzdeleted_8959062

those unfortunate gifts

16 years ago

anyone got a rose(s) which they normally would not give a space to unless it was a gift or some other special memento. I have a really quite good rose but so totally not my cup of tea that I simply have to keep it as a reminder of how little we parents and children really know about each other. Not only was it a mother's day present but it was from my youngest son(and most reliable forgettor of birthdays, anniversaries and any other special days) so I have to keep it. The offending rose - Arthur Bell - astonishingly healthy, probably immortal, luridly, yellowly huge. Flowers look OK in a vase (which is where I ensure nearly all of them end up).

Comments (26)

  • 16 years ago

    Is there another yellow rose you like that could mysteriously replace Arthur Bell? A dark of night swap while plants are dormant, and no one would be the wiser...

    "Oh, son, look how lovely the blooms are on your rose this year!"

    Thank goodness I live thousands of miles from the nearest family, or I'd be getting every horrible HT the box stores have to offer...

  • 16 years ago

    Maybe your DS chose it for its lovely stamens (I like them), but more likely he knows how much you like your Scotch. (Don't smack me!)

    He's a scentimental fellow.

    Sherry

  • 16 years ago

    I'm not familiar with this rose but you son sounds like a real treasure----

  • 16 years ago

    Come now, Companula . . . are you really that much of a sucker for sentiment? If so, I'm quite surprised (based on some of your previous posts). Life is far too short (and garden space far too precious) to squander one's efforts on something that is (to use your words) so totally not your cup of tea.

    To the nether regions with maternal sentiment!! Follow Lucretia's advice and engage in a bit benign subterfuge. Trash the gift, choose a replacement that's (perhaps vaguely) similar -- one that you prefer -- and give your spawn credit for selecting it. Do you really think he'll ever know the difference? Give him credit BIG TIME, for giving you a rose, forgive him (privately, silently) for the poor selection, and move on.

  • 16 years ago

    My 12 year old daughter gave me three Autumn Joy sedum which clash horribly with my pink roses, but I don't have the heart to remove them. My daughter would be very offended too. I think Campanula is doing the right thing. Cutting the flowers for a vase seems like a wonderful solution.

  • 16 years ago

    Keep the rose! You will remember your son every time you look at it. And that's a good thing.

    My DS helped me dig the koi pond, clear the back bed, put in edgings, and hauled many, many wheelbarrows full of mulch. Now that he's departed, I remember him in so many places in the garden.

    My DD gave me a pear tree as a gift one year. I love it, and remind her when she visits that that big tree is the one she gave me. She is touched that I remember.

    The fact that he knows to give you a rose - any rose - is proof he put some thought into the gift. I hope Arthur Bell is planted prominently and that you point him out each time your dear son visits.

    Of course, I am very sentimental and would plant anything if someone gave it to me. :)

  • 16 years ago

    I cherish any and ALL plants that loved ones give to me.

  • 16 years ago

    Ha, Jaxondel! Not really sentiment as such, more admiration for a truly vigorous and healthy rose. It is still flinging out blooms even now, It is true, Tas, my youngest, would not really know one rose from another but I do find it hard to rip a plant for purely aesthetic reasons....and when it has been a gift, then it is a double whammy. Holleygarden, remembering my idling son is NOT an issue since he is still LIVING AT HOME (we call these kids 'boomerang kids' in the UK and they are an ever increasing phenomenon) Hopefully, underneath my sarcastic exterior (there is an equally sarcastic interior?).....no no, I hope you can still detect my abiding love for all my offspring. And yes, it is at least a rose (although he would have to be truly oblivious not to notice that little quirk of mine) - it could have been a puppy, another grandchild, a new fridge, a food processor, a pair of oven gloves.....my god, I really am fortunate (and yep, these are 'gifts' I have recieved at some point). Still, you lot are all being a bit coy here. I cannot be the only one harbouring a less than wonderful piece of plantage??? Anyway, I moved an overgrown Rosa Primula nearby and planted around with red and yellow Lady tulips so it may be a spring symphony next year - we gardeners always live in hope, yes.

  • 16 years ago

    What it is with the yellow roses as gifts, I got one of those too, from my mother, although I even have no idea what kind it is (some HT by the looks). Oh well, anything goes into cut flower garden. ;)

  • 16 years ago

    I've never had plants from family but my son likes to paint rocks in the shape of ladybirds with his children and puts them in much too conspicuous places in my garden. But they are rather cute and easy to move.

    I am constantly given roses by my rose rustling friends and it is quite okay as long as I have room for them. But the latest rose gift was an old vigorous clone of New Dawn given me by a friend who has left his garden and moved to an apartment. He made sure I understood the importance of keeping the last specimen of this rare clone from the 40ies, rescued from the display garden of the agricultural university. Now I worry about it all the time. Is the site too wet, too windy, too sunny? I live in dread of my friend's visit next summer.

  • 16 years ago

    Campunala,
    I very much appreciate your sarcastic sense of humor. It has given me a few laughs which lately are very much needed. Your abiding love for your offspring and their offspring is obvious to me.
    As far as the gift, I think the male of our species need all the encouragement they can get. I would highly praise the fact that he gave you a gift (maybe not the specific rose in fear of getting a duplicate). And next time gift giving time comes around speak loudly and often about what you really do want.
    BTW, the fact that he's a boomerang boy and he still managed to scrounge up some dough to buy you a gift, is pretty special.
    Kitty

  • 16 years ago

    My neighbor gave me a yellow knock-out. Not at all what I wanted, but she loves to visit my garden, and she is a wonderful neighbor, so I will keep the knock out. (Another yellow rose) And,the yellow knock out is planted amongst my Old Garden roses.
    kay

  • 16 years ago

    It is a good thing to have a decent cutting rose that you don't much like in your garden. I can hardly bear to cut roses for the house, thus depriving the garden of their presence. You can cut these from Arthur Bell without pangs of loss.

    Rosefolly

  • 16 years ago

    Thankfully, no one has ever seen fit to give me a rose, probably because looking around they can't imagine I'd possibly want another one. If I received a red rose (I hate red roses!) it would go straight to the cutting garden in the back where the rabbits have decimated the roses completely. I still call it the cutting garden because the rabbits cut off the branches (not exactly my original concept) as far as they can reach.

    Ingrid

  • 16 years ago

    I received a beautiful modern floribunda (Cotillion) that may or may not be BS-prone from the editor of our rose society newsletter. Gorgeous flowers, gorgeous fragrance but not a decent spot left in the garden. So I found an out-of-the-way (I never go there, so I never water it & the irrigation isn't there yet), too shady spot. The last time I looked it had only a few leaves, and I'm afraid to look again. Maybe I should dig it up and put it in a pot. This gift isn't exactly like yours, Suzy, in that I like it, but you pried it out of me. It's the only one I've received since I went heavy into gardening.

    Sherry

  • 16 years ago

    I love the gift of plants! If it were not for them my garden would be empty! I see my garden as ever changing anyway, so there is always somewhere to plant something. The not always timely influx of plants from friends and family makes it hard to plan things exactly as I would want, and it's not always color coordinated. I consider these issues the challenge- How to make the gifts fit with all the other oddities I both want to grow and find (that is, buy cheap!) here and there. I have no problem with moving things around, as you can imagine! I figure by the time I am satisfied my dad will pull in the drive with 6 more divides/culls/sale items for me anyway.

    My father gave me my first rose bush. I had no clue what to do with it. I still kick myself for not moving it with me. What a mistake. I still miss it!

  • 16 years ago

    well, I'm impressed that a family member would give the gift of a rose bush--it really is sweet. However, I don't think people realize that us gardeners have our preferences. It is like picking out a piece of jewelry for a friend--I would prefer that the friend pick out the jewelry before I purchased it.
    If rose nurseries offered gift cards..now that would be a great gift for one of us!

  • 16 years ago

    I think non gardener people simply do not realize that there is some sort of difference between the varieties. For them there is not much difference what name the plant has that they stick to the ground. :)

  • 16 years ago

    Many years ago, my son's former music teacher gave us Charisma, a bright red blend Floribunda with smallish flowers and an appalling ability to fade to brownish tan and hold its old flowers forever. She took it out of her own orange bed of modern roses, which is pretty telling. It grew and clashed in my back yard's OGRs for years, then I moved it to the driveway border with Jacob's Coat - it clashed with it, too, but stayed alive despite appalling neglect. My son, now a grown boomerang kid, would comment on it being "Miss Nish's rose." I kept it because I thought he liked the rose, or at least its sentimental value. One day he said, "why do we still have that rose? It's ugly!"

    A friend has adopted some plots in our old cemetery and has been happy to take my rejects, so Charisma is now blooming its garish little heart out there. I still shudder when I see it.

    Anita
    PS I've also heard them called "bungee kids." How old is yours, camp? Mine is 24.

  • 16 years ago

    Yes, I think most people just don't understand the differences. A couple of years ago I was giving a tour of a local public garden and was told, in all seriousness "In California, roses have names." I had to answer, "They do here, too."

    Here it is easy enough to cheat and kill off the inappropriate roses. The last rose somebody gave me was Frontenac, I think. Like the gallica suckers, it just blends in with the rest of the crowd.

  • 16 years ago

    Hi Anita, mine's 23 but also has girlfriend in tow.....and middle daughter, also at home expecting an infant. Bloody Hell, the (small) house is bulging....which is why I spend a lot of time in the shed or greenhouse. Clearly, despite the hard as nails impression I may give, I am a completely soft touch.

  • 16 years ago

    I hope you're both collecting rent of some sort. It's not really a favor to let them mooch, IMHO. Way back in the 80's DH's eldest son moved in. We told him we'd match what he saved for a down payment...and then he moved out into his own house. Hmmm, sounds like who was paying rent to whom, doesn't it? Oh, well, at least it got him off the dime.

    Sherry

  • 16 years ago

    It's interesting how things have changed with the recession. It seems that extended families are living together more and more (I don't think I could handle it myself). This type of living arrangement is standard in many other countries though. I was in India last year and I would say that it would be extremely odd for a grown child to live on his/her own before marriage (even after marriage sometimes), even in relatively well-off families.

  • 16 years ago

    What's wrong with them? Actually I was a bungee daughter twenty-some years ago.

    My three young children and I moved back in with my parents for two and a half years after I left my first husband. It was economic necessity, and we were welcomed and loved. I didn't earn enough money to cover even child care for three small children, much less rent, bills, clothing, and food. The court system completely let us down as to child support, most of which was never paid. We had a plan. I worked as a waitress nights and went to school days to get a credential which made me employable at a rate that would support a small family, albeit at a marginal level. While I did this, my parents provided us with a home and child care. I moved out of my parents' home once I had my credential and a better job. There were tears on all side when I left. To this day there is great love between my children and their grandfather. My mother is no longer living, but she is treasured in all our hearts.

    When my own adult children needed some time in my home to achieve economic independence, of course I said yes. There does have to be an exit plan, but it is something I am happy to do. We are a family.

    If a family chooses not to do this, it is their right to say no, and no one can fault them. But if a family does want to do this, it doesn't mean that there is something wrong with that decision.

    Now, let's get back to roses.

    Rosefolly

  • 16 years ago

    I think you nailed how the system was meant to work, Paula. The original safety net.

    Sherry