Software
Houzz Logo Print
sammy_gw

Disease free roses

19 years ago

I looked around my yard yesterday to get an accurate account of what roses do not have diseases.

Here is my list:

No black spot:

none - not a single one

A little black spot:

Cramoisi Superieur and Monsier Tillier (spelling?)

Therefore I will have to spray at least once a month.

I even have Knock Outs with black spot.

Do you seriously have a list of roses that do not get much blackspot?

Sammy

Comments (13)

  • 19 years ago

    Varying conditions in any one year will determine a blackspot free rose. A dry summer with low humidity, gentle breezes, and no night time wet leaves will give you the best chance of disease free roses. Where in your yard they are planted is also a factor. I have two Morden Sunrise planted in different places. One is almost disease free, the other is almost leaf free due to blackspot.
    Unless you spray a preventative fungicide, your blackspot free bushes this year may be covered with it next under different conditions.
    That said, with no spraying, my Knockouts, all types, had very little black spot.
    Berlin, Dublin Bay, most hybrid rugosas, Earth Song, Black Jade, City of York, Clair Matin, Autumn Sunset, Fourth of July, Perdita, Touch of Class, Schloà Balthasar, Carefree Beauty and my Double Delights, depending on where they were planted, all had minimal blackspot.
    Next year could be entirely different.
    They were all watered overhead daily in early morning unless it rained. Just reading this Forum tells how fickle roses can be depending on the growing conditions.

  • 19 years ago

    Jean of TN has an extensive list. Some roses on that list work even in my much worse, coastal humid climate.

    For me Crepuscule is just a miraculous rose
    {{gwi:344566}}

    Jaune Desprez, Aerthusa, Perle d'or are also no spray as well as the Buck Folksinger that is a no blackspot-no spray here. HM Prosperity needs no spray either.

    Of the moderns, some of the new Kordes roses are definitely no spray. Laguna, as matter of fact was "offended" meaning showed burnt leaves when we sprayed it once. The spray mixture was Tebuconazole and Avid. Laguna got sprayed only once and only because it had spider mites, and it would have been too much bother to mix a separate spray regimen. Beside Laguna Papi Delbard also resented spraying. They got over it by now but it just shows that they do not like spraying.Floral Fairy tale was fabulous before the spider nite infestation.

    Check out the ADR labeled roses at Palatine - those were tested against spots, mildew, drought and they supposedly also are self- cleaning.

    Irish Ope is also fantastic although mine is crowded into a tiny bed where Leonardo tries to suppress everything while in the corner in front of Irish Hope Black and Blue salvia proved to be a thug.

    To summarize: there are a lot of no spray roses though they are climate specific and all those I mentioned are gar better than any Knockout.

  • 19 years ago

    I have to agree with Karl. I don't spray regularly. Though I do have a weekly day and time set aside for spraying, I don't always get out there.

    {{gwi:344567}}

    Fimbriata, Hybrid Rugosa

    But I still find that many of my roses seem fairly diseas resistant and some don't appear to need spraying at all. When folks ask me about a good climber in this area, my first response is always New Dawn. I haven't sprayed mine in 4 years and it has never needed it. Good thing too, since this rose gets so big and so full that to spay it is nearly impossible as is pruning. It seems to prefer little to no attention.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Gardening and Other Stuff

  • 19 years ago

    Oooh, Julie, that's nice! I haven't see that one before!

    The only two roses that still have most of their leaves are Rosenstadt Friesing and Baby Faurax. RF has almost no blackspot at all, just a bit on the lower leaves, it just bloomed a bit and has buds. Marchesa Boccella has a good amount of leaves, but a lot have blackspot. Oh, Tawny Tiger, surprisingly, has leaves and not much diesase, but I would not usually call it "disease free" or "disease resistant". I have a lot with buds but not many leaves. I usually spray, but I was not on my regular spray schedule this year hence to many plants without leaves at this time of year.

  • 19 years ago

    Julie, I've had this rose on my mind for quite a while. I do love Rugosas, I'm afraid I'll have to add this one on an order.
    Beautiful picture of Fimbriata.

    Carla

  • 19 years ago

    I did have roses that never showed BS before this year. Last fall I stopped spraying and that allowed BS to become endemic in my yard. It continued into spring (even after removing leaves and spraying) and the easter freeze I belive damaged my roses so they were less resistant.

    The drought, while keeping the BS at bay, lulled me into not spraying as regularly so when it did rain, the BS came on very strong.

  • 19 years ago

    About Fimbriata, mine has extemely small blooms except in latest fall. It can be in bloom and I don't notice the blooms unless I go looking for them. Maybe in cooler climates the blooms are a larger part of the overall picture.
    It is healthy, but it is now along a fence line.

    In this year of exceptional drought conditions, lots of roses are still well leafed out without having been sprayed for over two years. I'm not sure that they aren't holding onto leaves for fear of dropping leaves and not having enough moisture in their neighborhood to replace the fallen leaves.
    Species roses thrive without spraying.
    Many teas and old fashioned noisettes live well without spray.
    Some modern Austins are doing extra well without spray.
    But this may be the only upside of drought.

  • 19 years ago

    Rugosa alba stayed healthy and disease free all summer. Hybrid rugosa Robusta which was next to it, got SP'd this fall because of the black spot. Haven't had any others long enough to be helpful but Ginger Syllabub has been very healthy ever since I got it in the spring. (It has been very busy growing canes and roots too, I guess- too busy growing to bloom. So, I will have to wait til next yr to see what the blooms look like.)
    Martha Gonzales has not shown any signs of bs either- but only got her the beginning of summer. And the chinas are highly recommended as bs resistant.
    Taboo has been much recommended as very healthy, and after seeing Ceterum's bush, it is at the top of my 'to order' list. What a gorgeous rose! Brandy

  • 19 years ago

    We had such a bad start on gardening this year with the horrible spring, and hot summer. By the time the weather was nice, I was in school, and did not have the time I needed.

    Now I have begun weeding enough to get through to see my roses, and they all have black spot. I live in an area of the country where black spot is a problem, and with my neglect it is even worse. Crepuscule, and Rev d' Or have it. All of my Bucks and almost all that I can see easily have spots. The only ones without it are the ones I mentioned earlier.

    This means that with neglect they can all get disease. That is not a great discovery. I want to stop using chemicals, but my solution is probably to wean the roses off of them. Instead of every two weeks, I could go to once a month. Then after that I could go to 2 or 3 times a season besides in the beginning and end.

    I wrote my earlier post in haste since I was so discouraged to look at the yard. Once you neglect your garden, the first thing is to get a path. I resent the time that took since I still did not get into the beds. Now looking around, I have a real mess. I did always see that they were watered well, but that is about all. Now I need to spray one more time if I don't do anything else.

    I appreciate your posts, and do have a copy of Jean's list.
    Must go.
    THanks
    Sammy

  • 19 years ago

    Lots of tall weeds prevent air circulation and drying of wet leaves. Water sitting on leaves a long time and humid weather, promotes blackspot. A thick layer of mulch in spring over newspaper or cardboard should keep most weeds at bay.
    I doubt weaning your roses from fungicide will help. Once you stop spraying them as directed they will be more prone to blackspot.
    To get rid of established weeds, just put cardboard or newspapers over them and cover with mulch. They'll die and disappear under the cover. Checking after a month or so will show bare soil under the cover.
    I did that on a tree covered area next to my house in late summer. It remains weed free.
    AAMOF, I spent the better part of late summer and fall applying 39 yard of mulch, four inches thick, in all areas not covered with grass, one 5 gallon bucket full at a time from the seat of my Rascal scooter.
    I can keep up with most gardening chores but I hate to weed. Although a few rose bushes have lots of blackspot, most are fairly clean.

  • 19 years ago

    I put my roses on 4 foot centers to help with air circulation-- it isn't as pretty as bushes which intertwine but it does help with disease. The few modern and DA's I grow get all their lower foliage stripped. If you remove all the leaves within 12" of the ground you don't get that rapid spread of BS upward thru the plant. This forum has been wonderful in identifying less susceptible roses and I have followed everyone's advice in choosing for the new garden and OBOY has it paid off.

  • 19 years ago

    Sammy,
    You had so much rain this year that all bets are off. I'm surprised that your fence posts don't have black spot.
    Where to start?'
    How about a systemic spray or two this fall, just to try to make the plants healtier.
    Get the leaves off of the bushes once the roses go dormant (Maybe late December) Use dormant strength Lime Sulphur, seven to ten days apart to make the roses drop the leaves and to treat the canes for the spores left behind. Then respray at thirty days with a systemic fungicide (if the LS has washed off, if it hasn't then maybe replenish it at less than dormant strength if the new growth has started.)
    There's an interesting paper from Auburn about the importance of winter spraying of fungicides in supressing disease the following spring and summer. And the above is my attempt to adapt their advice to our conditions.
    (And I don't think it's a good use of time to pull leaves off; I'd rather the rose choose to drop its own dead leaves and the LS will kill the leaves and the abscission layers will form which I think makes where the leaves dropped off LESS of a target for fungal invasions. )

  • 19 years ago

    {{gwi:344568}}

    Wild Spice

    One of my nicest rugosa roses, and one that is absolutely black spot free. It is also one of the best growers I have and has grown from a 1 gallon pot to a 4x4 bush in 1 year. And you gotta love those right red hips! Very nice rose.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Gardening and Other Stuff