Software
Houzz Logo Print
dr_deb

OT: thistle (weeds)

17 years ago

I have copious amounts of what I thought was bull thistle. The amount of it has increased significantly over the three years we've been here, although I've worked hard to keep it under control. It's rampant in my big patch of ditch lilies --- haven't had the time to weed that yet.

We had a tree delivered and planted a week or so ago, and the landscaping guy called it "Russian thistle" and said the only way to get rid of it is Roundup. (It doesn't look like the Russian thistle I googled, but that's probably beside the point.)

I normally go the almost-organic route, but I'm getting desperate. If I keep pulling them, will they eventually decrease in number? Are there thistle that spread through roots as well as seed? The roots are brittle and fairly deep, and it is almost impossible to get all of them.

What are your thoughts?

Deb

Comments (10)

  • 17 years ago

    This is bull thistle.

    {{gwi:385157}}

    It spreads from seeds in the thousands. My neighbor thought it was pretty and let it flower. Now, I have them all over the place and so does he. As far as I know, it only grows from seed. They pop from purple flowers and get carried along the wind on little white puffs like dandelions. They can lay dormant in the soil for years.

  • 17 years ago

    Yes, I read that the seed can lay dormant for 10 years. To make matters worse, it has a very high germination rate. After spending some time on google, I *think* what I have it bull thistle, but some of the thistles look alike.

    If thistles all spread only by seed, hacking them off just below soil level (faster than pulling with those brittle roots) will eventually help with the problem, then?

    When I look at that patch of ditch lilies, I want to cry. But I need to get out there and do something with them before they flower. I just don't want to hack off the crowns if I really need to get out the whole root.

    :(

    Deb

  • 17 years ago

    From what I know of thistle, they can regrow from even small pieces of root. Here's how I treat them in the flower beds.

    Shovel prune removing as much of the crown as you can. Then take a paint brush and apply RoundUp to the exposed root. It usually takes about a week to kill it, but it will work. It's an ongoing process. Try to get them as soon as you see them and it will make it easier as time goes on.

  • 17 years ago

    I have some kind of thistle invasion this year -- never noticed it before but I'm just pulling it out like crazy.
    Even with gloves the prickles can hurt. I've learned to hold them at the very base, near the ground. Right after it rains is easiest. And I wear long sleeves.
    Haven't done Round Up yet ...

  • 17 years ago

    Well, I've been pulling for three years, and if they grow from roots that explains why the problem is so much worse this year.

    Since I don't normally use stuff like roundup, I have questions. If I put it directly on the weed rather than spray, will there be a negative effect on the soil organisms? (I would hate to poison my lovely fat earthworms and the birds that eat them!) Also, is this strategy safe for the food garden as well?

    Deb

  • 17 years ago

    The sales reps at the store swear that it will not leech across soil from the plants you put it in direct contact with. And that's been my experience.

    If you don't like using roundup, dab a little household bleach on the root. It should work almost as well and will break down in the soil. I use it all the time to sterilize my cutters and cloning machine.

  • 17 years ago

    Supposedly RU (glyphosate) breaks down quickly in the soil. However it may persist in water and is highly toxic to aquatic life; if possible try to keep it from getting into bodies of water, storm drains etc.

    If applied to the weed, I think the instructions are to make sure the leaves are thoroughly drenched. So applying it to remnant roots/stems after the weed is pulled will mean using less product. The way it works is that it blocks an enzyme that plants use to produce amino acids, effectively starving it.

    I don't know if it's safe for the food garden -- controversial topic, afaict. One danger would be it killing your crops, of course, since it is so broad-range.

  • 17 years ago

    IME unless the thistle is a tiny seedling it is impossible to get it all by digging and pulling the plant up. Seems that more sprout from the damaged root making the problem worse. We have had success in our church garden using Round Up or a simiiar product but it may take more than one application. In my garden I dig out the tiny seedlings as soon as I spot them.

  • 17 years ago

    I pull out every thistle (bull or not) when I first see them. I have very few now compared to what were on the property when I moved in almost 7 years ago, so pulling DOES work. Even if you cannot pull them all, do not let them flower and set seed. When I pull them out, they seldom grow back. They pull most easily after a rain or in early spring when they are young and the roots aren't as long. Hang in there and good luck!
    Kris

  • 17 years ago

    I let a regular one grow one year because I wanted to photograph the blooms w/butterflies and just watch it grow. Too bad it's so noxious and spreads. If I'd cut the seed heads off before they set seed, they wouldn't have seeded, but I wanted to photograph them, too :-( So I got a yard full of them the following spring.

    I just used a long-handled dandelion weeder, loosened all around, pulled up with as much tap root as I could get, got them all, and I hate to weed. None of those came back.

    Only one appeared this year, and I took care of it el pronto. I don't know if the weed 'n feed we put on the lawn will be effective against them, will only use Roundup for the most difficult and stubborn situations.

    It's a shame. I like them. They are the Scottish national flower. I've sure had my fill of dandelions though, they are more pesky and prolific than the thistle to hand weed, some are small and lurking. I think I'd rather dig thistle.

Sponsored