Software
Houzz Logo Print
nikhilkumar99

Lessons and experiences from a newbie

17 years ago

My daughter (8 year old) and I carried out a "winter sowing" project this winter. I have always been unsuccessful growing from seed (apart from herbs), so I was skeptical.

In summary:

1. Incredible experience. I recommend all dads to do this with their kids.

2. Planted about 20+ different kinds of plants. Failure in only 1 variety

3. Tried 3 types of containers. Best option is the old 1 gallon milk can (of the type we get here in MI from Krogers)

4. Plan on the number of seedlings you are going to have (I am still trying to convince our neighbours and local community groups to take them. Our garden was way too small).

5. Seeds (all flowering varieties) were from Swallowtail and Value Seeds.

1. Containers

Types:

We had 3 kinds of containers:

1. 1 gallon milk bottles. We cut the milk bottles around the center, leaving the handle on. Made drainage holes using a drill in the bottom of the cans. Filled with dirt (potting/ seed mix) and added seeds (to the depth and exposure recommended in their packets). Covered with 1 gallon zip-lock bags with breathing holes on the top.

2. Old plant pots which we got from previous seedling purchases from local nurseries (and which I had cleverly not thrown away). These were washed. Same sequence of pot + dirt + seeds + 1 gallon cover. Similar old yogurt tubs.

3. Burpee and other planter kits. This was especially for some of the veggies which I did start inside and move out.

2. Comparison of Containers:

1. Best and least effort (in decreasing order of effort and success in growth of seeds)

a. Milk Jugs (best shelter for the seeds, best germination, slow germination, least effort except for drilling holes)

b. Old pots (similar to above, but less sheltered. Faster to germinate, but faster to dry out and expose to heat. Lost some pots to heat.)

c. Yogurt tubs (smaller, dried out faster)

d. Planter flats from store (most germinated, but lost a lot of plants due to very rapid drying out of flat). Also costlier (didnÂt have to pay for the others :--)).

3. When sowed

1. Feb/ March (could not spend time prior to that).

4. Plants planted

1. Gaillardias

a. Arizona Sun  Successful germination and growth

b. Razzle Dazzle  Successful germination and growth

c. Dazzler Successful germination and growth

2. Robinsons Painted Daisy  Successful germination and growth

3. English Daisy (including Pompomette cultivar) Â Successful germination and growth

4. Starfire Asters  Successful germination and growth

5. Pansies

a. Blackmoon  limited success

b. Bruning Âlimited success

c. Johnny jump-up  Successful germination and growth

d. Rhinegold  Successful germination and growth

e. Sweet Violet  failed to germinate

6. Carrots  Successful germination and failed to grow (planted in flats, died in one hot day)

7. Hollyhocks

a. Majorette  germinated, growing well

b. Summer Carnival  germinated, growing well

c. Russian Yelllow  germinated, growing well

8. Freckle face daisies  germinated, growing well

9. Sweet William (Holborn Glory) Â germinated, growing well

10. Marigolds

a. 2 Varieties (starfire/ Marietta), both germinated and grew

11. Columbines  in general, slow germination (probably due to the late (Feb/March) sowing as they have a very thick seed coat).

a. Magpie germinated in May 3rd week

b. Dragonfly  germinated, growing well

c. Cameo mix  germinated, growing well

d. Blue Star  germinated, growing well

12. Creeping Thyme  germinated, growing well

13. Creeping Red Sedum  germinated, growing well

14. Scabiosa Ebony/Ivory  germinated, growing well

15. Armeria

a. Laucheana  germinated, growing well

b. Formosa  germinated, growing well

16. Zinnia (3 varieties) Â all died after transplanting. Were started outside, seems to be a problem with transplanting

17. Ipomeas  2 varieties  number died after transplanting (started indoors), seems to be very sensitive to cold, we had a couple of cold snaps

18. Poppy bracteata  failed

19. Cosmos  failed

20. Night stocks  success

21. Dianthus Albus  limited success, slow growing

22. Firefly coral bells  limited success, slow growing

23. Runner beans (planted in-doors/ potted out) Â germinated, growing well

24. Cucumbers (planted in-doors/ potted out) Â Successful germination and growth

25. Pumpkins (Atlantic Giant/ Big Max)(planted in-doors/ potted out) Â Successful germination and growth

26. Coriander  germinated, growing well, harvested

27. Watermelons  germinated, growing well

Conclusion:

I will be doing this again and strongly recommend it to anyone.

Regards,

Nikhil

Comments (5)

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Great info! I did not keep much records. I just have a list of sowed seeds.
    Karen

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Nikhil - I cover my zinnias seedlings with baskets with holes on the sides (Dollar store). When they are first planted out, while they love sun ONCE ESTABLISHED, they can wither in the heat when they are so small. Try them again - it's not too late

    Carrie - (Impressed with your list... you are very organized)

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I'm curious - why did you use a ziplock baggie on the milk jugs instead of just closing down the top and taping it shut?

    And a suggestion for future (because you CAN use those smaller containers - I use toilet paper tubes). This idea is NOT mine - I got it from DaWiff (she's on this forum).

    Use a plastic storage container (like those underbed sweater containers). Drill holes on the SIDES (not the bottom) of that - maybe 1/2 inch to 1 inch above the bottom.

    When it's dry, fill that tub with water. Your little pots will soak it up from the bottom and say much more moist than if you try to water them. You also don't disturb the seedlings.

    I followed that process this year and have been just fine and wished I had done it years ago!

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I'm glad you had so much success! Yep, keeping things moist is a big factor. I think I'll try the sweater-box idea mentioned above, as I have been thinking of trying old seedling 6-packs to make easy-to-plant plugs.

    The next step (in the addicion) is to collect seeds, and start trading!

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Nikhil, I enjoyed reading your post. Maybe you keep good records just like me. I started in 2006 and it's nice to be able to compare years. It's amazing how alike they are althogh you don't realize it when you're experiencing them. I grew Gaillardia Dazzler last year and it was lovely, but unfortunately the plants did not survive the winter, apparently it is a tender perennial. You may want to mulch yours to over winter them. I also had some problems with zinnias, which I grew for the first time last year. I found some of them looking very 'uhappy' while still in their containers, and the same this year and could not decide whether it was the heat or the cold (we have had a few snaps - even last night), but accoding to Carrie it's the sun, so I'll keep them covered and in shade. It's surprising that Cosmos failed. The older varieties re-seeded like crazy, but I've had success with a couple of the newer varieties last year and this year. Congratulations and happy gardening this summer.
    Northerner.

Sponsored