Software
Houzz Logo Print
misssherryg

Mystery Oak

19 years ago

I've been out tagging young oaks/seedlings on my property that I want to keep, and pulling up the usual vast numbers of loblolly pines and Chinese tallow trees. I tag them so I don't step on the real small ones, also I may need to water them soon if we don't get rain, and I may work some chicken manure into the ground around them next spring. This little oak is about 1' tall. Is it a post oak/q. stellata or maybe a sand post oak/q. margaretta? Quercus margaretta does grow in this area - I found one about ?1/10 mile from here alongside the Florida pipeline, but that's the only one. The leaves on this seedling aren't as deeply indented as the leaves on the mature post oaks on my property, but maybe that's just because of its youth? Is it one of these, or is it some other type of oak?

Thanks!

{{gwi:479744}}
Sherry

Comments (11)

  • 19 years ago

    Yep, Looks most like a Post oak (Quercus stellata)
    Most leaves on young Post Oaks are not deeply indented.

    Sand Post Oak is distinguished from Post oak by smaller leaves with lobes pointing toward the leaf apex, more variable lobing, and hairless twigs.

  • 19 years ago

    Hang onto it. Care for it. You have nothing to lose., either way. Great tree.

  • 19 years ago

    Yes, I love the post oaks. The tree that I saw along the Florida Pipeline that I thought was a sand post oak wasn't big, but it was big enough that if it were a regular post oak, the leaves would have had big indentations, roughly in the shape of a maltese cross. This tree had shallowly lobed leaves, I can't remember which way the lobes pointed, but they were fuzzy - I didn't check the hairiness of the twigs.
    There are lots of water oaks coming up, which I, unlike many others, like. And I dug up a little redbay and 4 little wild black cherries that are in bad spots and potted them up to plant next year in good spots. These, plus all the trees I've planted should make my property beautiful again - I hope I live long enough to see them all mature! :)
    Sherry

  • 19 years ago

    Overcup oak also has leaves that sometimes look like a cross.

  • 19 years ago

    Leaf lobing on both Post Oak and Sand Post Oak can be highly variable. I've seen populations of Post Oak in the MO Ozarks with most leaves on most of the trees shaped much more like Sand Post Oak than the typical crucifix form of more typical Post Oak. I'd use the twig hairiness and leaf size as the more reliable differentiating characteristics. But the lobing can be helpful in conjunction with those. Another differentiating characteristic is the leaf surface, which on Post Oak is mostly rough and sandpapery because of widely spaced stiff stellate hairs, while Sand Post Oak isn't. Also, Sand Post Oak's leaf undersides are often soft and velvety to the touch, while Post is often rough and never soft and velvety.

    Most Post Oak seedlings in my area (Eastern KS, and Western MO) have lobing which looks nothing like the adult trees. In fact many have lobing which resembles the lobing of Chinquapin Oak (Q. muehlenbergii) and White Oak (Q. alba).

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks, Kman!
    Your info about sand post oak leaves being velvety confirms what I thought about the SPO on the pipeline - I knew it had to be a different tree with leaves that felt so different.
    Sherry

  • 18 years ago

    The little post oak seedling that was the subject of this thread has made the reddest leaves of any post oak on my property - the others all have orangish brown leaves.
    Maybe young oak seedlings don't color like mature trees?
    {{gwi:479745}}
    MissSherry

  • 18 years ago

    That's correct MissSherry,

    Seedlings and even sapling Oaks often have very different fall colors than the more mature trees do. Usually the seedlings and smaller saplings will have the best, most intense fall colors.

  • 18 years ago

    Could this be a southern red oak, Q. falcata?

  • 18 years ago

    I don't think so, vancleaveterry. I don't remember or see in the picture any bristles on the leaves. According to what I've read, that's the way you distinguish red oaks from white oaks - post oak is in the white oak group.
    Sherry

  • 18 years ago

    It's Not a Southern Red Oak.

    Southern Red Oak leaves(Q. falcata) look like this:
    {{gwi:479743}}

    Young Southern Red Oak leaves usually have about 3 lobes and are sort of triangle in shape (like a 3 toed dinosaur track). Older leaves are thin (both are in the link above).

    Yes, Red Oaks generally are seen having bristle tips and white Oaks have rounded tips.