Software
Houzz Logo Print
jswhitni

Shamel Ash is dieing

20 years ago

I have a Shamel Ash that is one year old and has suddenly lost it's leaves. I though wooly aphids were the problem. I noticed the leaves curling and getting brown a few months ago. It was small enough to be treated. It has gone from bad to worse. I have 3 of these trees and this is the one that is dieing. I live in Maricopa. Any thoughts?

Comments (8)

  • 20 years ago

    Have you done any long, slow watering lately? Often, brown and curled leaves mean that there is salt build up in the soil. We tend to water new plants enough to soak the root ball and a little beyond - but once a month or so even new plants need a really good - 6 to 8 hour soak to leech the salts below the root line.

    Crista

  • 20 years ago

    I have started doing this. But I've never watered that long. I'll go put the hose on it now, real low for real long.

  • 20 years ago

    Our Shamel Ash is doing the same thing only much faster. It looked great till the last week in June, then we noticed the green leaves started to slowly curl up and dry out. Then we had the heavy rain on July 5th & 7th and then the next 2 weeks the heat shot up to 110+, so we watered it even more giving it a deep soaking at least twice a week. I even was checking the water table down 3 feet and it was nice & wet so I figured it was getting plenty of water. Well it's just gone down hill still and now has hardly any leaves on it and many of the branches are brown-dark brown on the last 6-10" of the branches.
    The Tree was planted last OCT so it hasn't even been in the ground a year yet. I've never seen a tree die so quickly. I called the tree shop. they said the first time that it was just sun damage and to keep deep soaking it twice a week. then after 2 weeks I called back and the Manager there said to deep water it every other day which we are doing and
    wait till the end of august but to me it just looks like it's gone now. I even had our professional landscaper come out to look at it and he said it had too much water and to let it dry out for 1 week, so I let it go without water for only 2 days before starting to give it water again, just not quite as much. I've tried their special fertalizer they reccomended and some of that liqued thrive they said to use once a week, but still no signs of life.

    HELP. I'm about to call the tree place back and make them replace the tree as it under a warranty, but this is the 2nd tree from them that has died only the first one never took root wise which was a diff problem. This one kicked in real fast and was growing very nicely and full. it grew approx 3 feet taller in the past 9 months and about an extra 5' wider

  • 20 years ago

    bluoasis, My Shamel is acting *exactly* the same. I stopped watering it after that July 5th and 7th hard rain, I had just deep watered it that previous weekend and felt it was probably too wet. I'm letting it dry out a bit to see if it will come back. I feel your pain, that's for sure. Love that tree - also planted last Oct.

  • 20 years ago

    aztreelvr,
    My problem is that the tree was planted at soil level, and I am getting 2 diff answers. the nursery where I bought it said to basically add more water than I was (deep water every other day) and my Pro-landscaper said it's getting to much water. I only added the fertalizer because the tree is under warranty so I have to do what they say or I lose my warranty. I paid big $$ for it. it came in a 32" box and I watched them plant it. I had to be doing something right for the tree to grow so quickly both heigth and width wise with no signs of stress at all.

    any idea's on what to do know? we do have at least week of a little cooler weather coming now and I don't want to wait till my warranty is up looking at a dead tree. If it's too late now, then I will call them now and have them give me a new one the same size as before.

    In Surprise, AZ

  • 20 years ago

    For a tree planted last October, deep watering every other day would be too often. As long as the water is soaking down to three feet you shouldn't need to water your tree more often than once a week, but you need to apply lots of water each time.

    An ash tree that has a canopy diameter of about 8 feet would need more than 50 gallons each time its watered. A larger tree with say a 15 ft. canopy would need close to 180 gallons each week in July.

    It is extremely important to allow the soil to dry a bit in between waterings. This is because roots need oxygen in order to process nutrients from the soil. Too much water too often and you basically drown the roots and starve the tree.

    There is an outside chance that something else if affecting your tree. Have you used any herbicides in the last few months? A product like Triox, which is commonly used for weeds, can move in the soil and affect nearby plants. Just a thought.

    I hope this helps.

  • 20 years ago

    I used the moisture meter on my ash yesterday afternoon and at only half an inch down it pinged way over to very wet....and I have not watered in 10 days or even two weeks. Methinks it's too wet. I also took off all the distressed looking leaves hoping it would conserve some energy for the rest of the tree. Hope it makes it through.

Sponsored