Software
Houzz Logo Print
plbarlowe

Update Ugly Wainscoting in Family Room in '80s House

13 years ago
We have a mid-1980s house and I am trying to update the family room on a budget. As was typical for the time, there is stained pine crown molding, trim around the doors, and horizontal wainscoting. A couple of my neighbors have painted the wainscoting but honestly I don't think it looks that great. The boards run horizontally instead of vertically which I never did like. At first I thought I would like to replace the wainscoting with bead board but that seems like such a huge project. What if I filled in the spaces in between the boards (where the edges of the wood are beveled) and painted all the woodwork which is how I am leaning right now. What product would I use to do this filling in? I suspect I would have to smooth over where the knots in the pine are as well. Would you paint a different color below the chair rail?
Ugh, and then there is the fireplace. All brick wall and all brick hearth. We put in a rather nice antique mission/arts & crafts oak fireplace mantle about ten or so years ago which I kind of like but I'm still not crazy about all that brick. My intention was always to put some thickset tiles around the opening. Also, one of my neighbors painted all of her brick and put built-in bookcases on either side of the fireplace which I thought looked really nice. Also to note, I have a lot of antiques but in this room they are limited to the accessories. Any hints/suggestions for me??

Comments (13)

  • 13 years ago
    for some reason my photos didn't upload on the first go around :(
    I'm worried that removing the wainscoting will cause damage to the walls and therefore more work in the long run.
  • 13 years ago
    for some reason my photos didn't upload on the first go around :(
    I'm worried that removing the wainscoting will cause damage to the walls and therefore more work in the long run.
  • 13 years ago
    I would have suggested painting the wainscoting, but it's too bad you don't like how that turned out for your neighbors. Once it's painted properly and with a color you love above the chair rail, do you think it would be less noticeable to you?
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    Your wainscoting and your fireplace are both beautiful and are perfect together. I'm usually a fan of painting wood wainscoting, but not in this case. I like the brick as it is also.
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    last modified: 13 years ago
    Use 1/4" bead board panels and simply install over the existing wainscoting. Since you have a fair amount of extension on your baseboard and chair rail trim, you should be able to hide the raw edge of the bead board. You could even use paneling adhesive to apply the beadboard and a fine line of caulk to cover the top and bottom edge. Then you will be ready to paint.

    Paint your brick it will allow for your wonderful antique mantle to stand out.
  • 13 years ago
    last modified: 13 years ago
    I agree with Scott.

    A few suggestions to make things easier. Regardless of whether you wish to paint the wainscoting white or stain it to match the oak you have, prime and paint or stain the pieces first, then install. After it in, you just do a little touch up. From your pictures, it looks like you just have to remove the quarter round on the top of the baseboard, and the bigger trim piece under the wainscoting cap, you can cut the panels to the top of the baseboard and cover the cap with a flatter piece of trim. I never am in favor of painting brick, but after the painted beadboard is in you may wish to consider it. It will make the beautiful mantle and surround more of a feature in the room. I also suggest leaving the cap in it's existing color since it matches your crown molding. Tiling the inset of the surround is a great idea, in my opinion, and would allow you carry further the antique look you like.
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    I would suggest painting the walls a different color and leaving the wainscoting. I think that the wainscoting and the fireplace are beautiful!
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    I think if they were going to paint the wainscoting,you would also paint the crown moulding, plus door and window trim.
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    I'm with Carolyn on painting the waincoting,crown,and the door and window trims .
  • 13 years ago
    I don't like that paneling either, it's narsty. Filling in the boards or removing the paneling would be a big job. If you fill, you have to sand and you'll probably have sanding dust in your home for at least a week. Removing could cause issues, too. I had an ugly tile backsplash that I covered with a heavily textured paintable wallpaper, it worked great and you cannot see a grout line at all, you could try this approach. It's very inexpensive, $12.99/double roll at Home Depot and I think there are 4 different designs available.

    For the brick fireplace I would paint it. Brick is nice, but painted brick is nicer. Vacuum it well, then use a good quality primer first so the brick doesn't bleed thru. Have fun!
  • 13 years ago
    I love the wainscoting and the fireplace too. I'm another that would vote for a painting the drywall a different color. The natural wood would pick up reflections from the paint color and change the whole look of the room.
  • 9 years ago

    I am no pro but I have a good eye. There is an old world charm to the wainscot and fireplace. One can tell it was work well done long ago. It has a warm and comfortable feel. If it was done by a hack, I would suggest changing it, but it clearly wasn't. I feel you should paint the drywall. Embracing the the timeless elements in a space and changing the things that can easily be changed can transform a room.