Software
Houzz Logo Print
winterlager

Fast/slow growing seedlings

18 years ago

I'm wondering what are the fastest vs slowest growing seedlings. In my limited experience (fastest to slowest): Billbergia, aechmea, neoregelia, pitcarnia. If my vriesea's do sprout they'd be last, but not sure yet.

Fastest seedings so far, Billbergia Rosea at 70 days (biggest one already removed as it was hanging over the sides):

{{gwi:453440}}

Comments (17)

  • 18 years ago

    Sounds about right, WL. In my experience Bills are about the fastest to set seed, and the fastest to grow to maturity. Ae. brevicollis is another quickie-- I've gone from seed to blooming plant in just about a year on that one. Aechmeas and Porteas are generally a bit faster than Neos and Orthos, which average 2-3 years to maturity and flowering in our climate.

    At the other end of the scale, Vrieseas and Guzmanias are very slow, and their smaller size at germination seems to make them more vulnerable to disease and predation. Tillandsias are the worst, though-- 7 or 8 years to maturity if you're lucky! I tried it once, but that was enough.

  • 18 years ago

    With the few seedlings I have tried I have experienced exactly all what you say, I can only add Edmundoa lindenii is on the slower side for me, Alcantareas of course similar to Vriesea.

    As I was uncertain whether to fertilize or not my seedlings from the beginning, I did this experiment, bouth pots contain B. alfonsoi-johannis, the right one got very light fogliar feeding from the beginning, the left one not at all. The difference is evident.

    Tomas

    {{gwi:453441}}

  • 18 years ago

    How about puya?
    I have the few seedlings
    {{gwi:453442}}

  • 18 years ago

    I have only experience in germinating Puya and Tillandsia. Both germinated in 2 weeks, but from that point, Tillandsia grow unbelievably slow.

  • 18 years ago

    Tomas, thanks for sharing the fertilizer experiment. I have been watering from the bottom and haven't been putting any feed on the leaves. Of course, I'm not growing in perlite, I'm growing in potting soil.

    I guess I'll hit them with a little foliar feed once a week.

  • 18 years ago

    Tomas, if you say that Edmundoa lindenii is on the slower side, do you mean like neo's, compared to billbergia's or like vrieseas? I got some seeds from a friend this weekend. His plant had a huge inflorescense with ALL berries full of seed and ripe. So we can add this one to the list of selfers. But each berrie only had a few seeds in them, so I had to take quite a number of berries to get a descent amount of seeds. I really hope they are not as slow as vrieseas!

    Japie

  • 18 years ago

    I have Neo, Canistropsis, Vriesea And Alcantarea seedlings to experiment with. Everything I (foliar) feed grows twice as fast compared to the ones I don't feed.
    Fertilizing seems to be a must in the seedling stage.

    Alcantareas and Canistropsis are slow compared to Neos, but Vriesea's are very slow.

    Sander

  • 18 years ago

    Sander_s what medium do you use?

    My billbergia's popped up large in regular potting soil. Some of my Neo Contentrica's survived two major potting mishaps (a drop and a flood) in potting soil. Right now I have most of my seedlings under cover in indirect light with the tops off. Humidity is high so I'm not too inclined to keep them under tight lids.

    I'm hoping to receive my next allotment of BSI seed fund seeds next week and try again.

  • 18 years ago

    Japie,

    I have never grown neos from seed, cannot compare.
    Here is the Edmundoa about 10 weeks from germination, it grows much better now

    Tomas

    {{gwi:453443}}

  • 18 years ago

    Winterlager I use cocos peat with perlite an grow under artificial light. I have had less algae with sphagnum moss as a substrate so I am not to happy about my current substrate.

    Sander

  • 18 years ago

    Tomas, thanks very much. But I made a mistake, the seeds that I am interested in to know how fast/slow they grow, is Wittrockia leopardinum. See, I got two pups from a friend this past weekend and of the one plant, he also gave me seeds from the mother which I now realise is Wittrockia and not the Edmundoa, as the Edmundua is an albo-marginated one and will not produce viable seedlings. So all I had to say in the post above, s really applicable to W leopardinum!

    Any body else that can help me out on this one?

    Japie

  • 18 years ago

    Seeds from variegated or albo-marginated plants can produce green seedlings..I have some growing that are green..the albino's die right away...but you rarely ever get a variegated seedling

  • 18 years ago

    Fertilizing seedlings does move them faster, but there are also advantages in not overdoing it. If you're like me, you like to get a feeling for what's going on as soon as possible, and a bunch of dark green seedlings won't tell you much. If you let the fert wear off a bit you can see colors and markings at a fairly early stage. Too much, though, and they stop growing, so you have to find that happy medium.

    {{gwi:453444}}

    {{gwi:453445}}

    {{gwi:453447}}

    Of course if you're just growing out species and/or planning to keep all of them then it doesn't matter. This is only useful if you're doing hybrids of Neos or some other types with colorful foliage and plan to do some culling.

  • 18 years ago

    I agree with Lisa about early 'look see'..I use bio-nutrients to get them to grow and so far it has not affected what they look like

  • 18 years ago

    You can put Werauhia in the sslloowwww category.

    Germination
    {{gwi:440148}}

    Two Months
    {{gwi:440150}}

    One Year
    {{gwi:440152}}

  • 18 years ago

    I'm going to have to add Pitcairnia to the fast growing seedlings. I think it's even faster growing than Billbergia although the seeds don't germinate as fast. They usually take 2 weeks to sprout.

    This xanthocalyx is 4 and 1/2 months old. I put the seed out 21 January. It is quite a bit bigger than it's grex mates, but they are doing well also. Now what do I do with it? It seems too delicate to plant in the ground. I afraid that it would become snail food within a few days.

    {{gwi:453450}}

  • 18 years ago

    Hi all - I found Acanthostachys strobilacea the fastest of all I have tried - All the best, Nev

Sponsored