Software
Houzz Logo Print
caterwallin

Do American Lady cats overwinter?

17 years ago

I don't think they do, but I thought I'd ask just to be sure. The reason is that I have American Lady cats on my pussytoes but haven't seen any AL butterflies here yet, so I was wondering if there's even the slightest chance that they might have been here over the winter. Actually, regarding cats that do overwinter (I know that Baltimore Checkerspots can/do), do they overwinter as large cats or smaller ones or both?

So far this year I've only seen one Mourning Cloak, Cabbage Whites, and one Eastern Tiger Swallowtail. I'm outside a lot and didn't think that I'd miss seeing the AL butterfly that must have flown through here, but I guess I did miss her. There are at least 20 rolled up leaves out there.

Cathy

Comments (8)

  • 17 years ago

    I found AL cats too this past weekend and have not seen any adult ALs either, but I also miss a good portion of the day because of work. Wagner says that ALs are early migrants and reach Canada by May.

    The caterpillars I know of that overwinter do so in different instars. Some fritillaries overwinter in the 1st or 2nd instar. Some frits hatch, but don't feed until the following spring--unbelievable that any survive! Harris' Checkerspots feed for a couple instars and then stop and finish in the spring. Red-Spotted Purples and White Admirals also overwinter in an early instar--all of this comes from Wagner and from my own rearing here in NH.

    Have fun with your ALs!

  • 17 years ago

    That's a very good question, Cathy!
    I've wondered how it is that American ladies magically show up in early spring every year - maybe they've been overwintering as cats! Like Bernergrrl said, there are several butterflies that do overwinter that way - I even overwintered some gulf frits as cats one year - but I can't find any information more specific than my Audubon Field Guide that says they're 'reported to overwinter as adult or chrysalis.' So maybe they fly in from points south of here every spring, or there are chrysalids out there I'm not aware of.
    I'd love to raise some in late fall and see what happens!
    Sherry

  • 17 years ago

    According to James A. Scott - The Butterflies of North America.
    He says that "the Adults hibernate (doubtfully also pupae), but only in mild winters or in the south."

    I guess we can't be out there 24/7.

  • 17 years ago

    bg, I guess it was just hard for me to believe that these were laid this year when I never saw any of that type of butterfly (I've actually hardly seen any butterflies of any type this year yet except Cabbage Whites for the most part). I'm here all day and outside a lot, although not all of my waking hours. I'd bring them in, but they're on pussytoes, which I think would be difficult to bring inside. Also, with all my gardening to take care of (planting and weeding), I hadn't planned on bringing any cats of any kind in for awhile yet.

    That was very interesting about the various types of cats and how they overwinter. The kinds of cats I've had brought in other years didn't overwinter in the cat form. I've had BST and GST overwinter as pupae of course.

    Sherry, Like you I really do winter if they can overwinter as a cat. Although I'm not outside the entire day from sunrise to sunset, I am out a good part of the day and have never seen the AL's lay their eggs. I haven't even seen any here this year yet and haven't seen much of anything in the way of butterflies at all. We've had such a cool, rainy spring, and I'm hoping that's the only reason for the lack of butterflies around here. I only got into butterfly gardening a few years ago and had great years the first couple of years, but last year was a dud and so far this year is the same way. It's a pretty disappointing year so far, but I won't give up hope yet as it's still pretty early. Like you, I'm wondering if there were chrysalids out there somewhere that I didn't know about, which can explain the appearance of all of these little AL cats. I hope you get to raise some in late fall and you can see what they decide to do.

    butterflyman, I can't be out there 24/7 but I sure try. :) I've told my husband already that I need one of those headlamps so I can work outside after dark.

    Cathy

  • 17 years ago

    The chrysalids may overwinter, or the AL butterflies may have just been super sneaky, but I haven't seen any either.

    I've not brought mine in yet either--still working, and I still have to disinfect a cage for them.

    It amazing about how many caterpillars overwinter--how do they do that? Some fall down into the leaf litter, while others roll up into a leaf and hang out for the winter--and make it through below freezing temperatures.

    I wonder how things will be affected butterfly-wise because of the tremendous ice storm we had up here in December.

  • 17 years ago

    bg, I don't know how anyone would know the answer to the question of them overwintering or not, but it sure would be nice to know...I'm curious.

    You sound busy too! I think when a person is a butterfly garden, if they're like me, they probably don't know whether they're coming or going. Ha. Right now there don't seem to be enough hours in the day.

    Yes, it is amazing how the caterpillars can manage to survive those low temperatures, that's for sure. It got down to minus 15 here this winter, so if any cats overwintered here, they must be really super tough. I have a whole bunch of rolled up leaves of pussytoes that I just know are concealing tiny AL cats. I peeked in the one and sure enough, there it was! :) My daughter wondered how I know that that's what kind it is. I said that after seeing pics on here and raising them, I'd know them in my sleep...those and lots of other cats. lol I really enjoy seeing other people's pictures on here.

    I really hope that the big ice storm that you had didn't adversely affect the butterfly population if something like that can cause the overwintering chrysalids and cats to die. Our state was hit with that too, but thank goodness this area was spared. I felt bad for the people who had to go through it though.

    Here's hoping that we all have a good butterfly year!

    Cathy

  • 17 years ago

    I remember reading a record of an american lady overwintering in Mass. I don't remember what stage though. I suspect that many things do overwinter that we don't know about. There was a photo journal on the web of a giant swallowtail that overwintered in Michigan. It didn't emerge well but that it survived at all in Michigan is something.
    -Elisabeth

  • 17 years ago

    Late getting into this... but the answer is pretty easy.

    A good general guide to keep in mind is very few species that diapause/aestivate (overwinter/summer sleep) can do so in more than one life history form (as an ovum, larvae, pupae or imago). Vanessa is one of those few.

    The CONUS Vanessa species commonly overwinter as pupae. But some of the adults of a seasons last brood also commonly overwinter, and much farther north than many folks may realize. Most areas are also either repopulated or the colony strengthened each year by either full blown migrations or by population shifts on a smaller scale.

    As suggested, there are quite a few Lepidopteran species that do overwinter as larva in North America (both butterflies and moths). Most common for larvae is as an early instar larvae (1st to 3rd instar).

    The extremes... Some species that first overwinter either as ovum or larvae also must go through a second winter as a pupae before the imagos emerge. Some individuals of these species even go much longer in a repetative cycle of diapause/aestivation that can go on for many years before they emerge. It's all about triggers - those that force the diapause/aestivation, and those that end them. The triggers generally are environmental, but some individuals chose to ignore them for years yet remain viable to eventually emerge as a normal imago.

    When I lived in the frozen north we always looked forward to the early field trips for the larva of several species that had overwintered as such in that area. I well remember many times being pelted with wind driven snow on these collecting forays yet still finding the larva by the hundreds.

    L.