Software
Houzz Logo Print
jwink246_gw

Aphids are winning

15 years ago

Anyonw with any suggestions? I am hand removing them and using insecticidal soap. It seems I get all the milkweed clean and the next morning they are just as bad. I have seen only one Monarch this year and raised one cat which probably had OE since it couldn't fly once it eclosed. I am frustrated. Help?!

Comments (4)

  • 15 years ago

    All I can say is that these things seem to go in cycles. If the aphids are bad this year, then the beneficials who eat them will move in and hopefully they'll be under control next year. You could try purchasing some ladybugs from some one. I've never done it, but others here on Gardenweb might be able to tell you more about that.

    Martha

  • 15 years ago

    jwink246, the insect pests that usually feed on milkweed plants are not nearly as bothersome as those that prey on some other plants.

    The two types that I find most often are aphids and Milkweed bugs. In the first case (aphids) they are sucking insects and can be controlled with any of the milder sprays such as insecticidal soap, horticultural oil, or just a hard spray of water from the hose a few times a week, or so. Common Milkweed (Asclepias syriaca) is a rather substantial plant and, with aphids, even if you do nothing, there will be very little damage. There are many types of aphids...the one that usually preys on milkweeds is the...

    OLEANDER APHID
    {{gwi:480241}}

    The other insects that feed somewhat on Milkweed plants are the Large and the Small Milkweed Bugs. These are seed-eating bugs and won't give you much of a problem unless you save seeds. Both of these bugs are pretty enough to put up with. I, personally, ignore these because most eradicating products would wipe out the butterflies in my yard.

    LARGE AND SMALL MILKWEED BUGS
    {{gwi:480242}}

    THIS IS A SHOT OF THE LARGE MILKWEED BUG ALONG WITH THE OLEANDER APHIDS.
    {{gwi:480243}}

    Nature will step in to control most insect infestations as the below shot shows.

    GREEN LACEWING larvae feeding on OLEANDER APHIDS. They are voracious feeders.
    {{gwi:480244}}

    Hope this helps!

    Bob

  • 15 years ago

    Beautiful pictures, Bob! I always enjoy seeing the ones that you post. As far as the Oleander aphids, they give me the heebie jeebies! lol Really, I can't stand to see them and squish them when I get a chance. One good thing about not having any milkweed planted yet is that I don't have any of those aphids. Ha! Actually, as far as I can recall, I don't think they show up here quite this early. I think it's more like the end of the month or beginning of July. I wish we had more ladybugs that would take care of them. We're plagued with those foreign ones most of the fall and winter (inside our house), but then when they're needed to eat the aphids, they seem to high-tail it out of here. Anyway, I'm hoping that the aphids aren't too bad this year.
    Btw, do you know if the lacewings would also eat Monarch eggs/cats?
    Cathy

  • 15 years ago

    Becareful what you wish for. Lacewing larvae and Ladybugs do eat caterpillar eggs and 1st instar cats. Best to just use a good stream of water and accept that in butterfly gardening there will be some loss to pests.
    -Elisabeth