junkyardgirl, Creamsickle should have fuzzier leaves and one shouldn't judge the first bloom. I've had doubles that only were singles on the first bloom. Some will be a creamy yellow and then turn white. Now Isabella is surprising as that one grows like crazy here. You have her in more sun than shade?

My Creamsickles have fuzzy leaves and it's not a huge plant but the blooms are quite large. I have one Creamsickle that puts out loads of single blooms. My flowers don't start out yellow but it's not white either, maybe a yellowish cream that changes to a peachy color. KHT is right. Don't judge your plant by the first flush. I've never had Isabella.
Karyn

Thanks. O.K., so they were misidentified when they were shipped, then. The smaller one is definitely the Creamsickle. The one that is blooming has finished blooming now and is definitely Isabella. Beautiful, but not what I wanted. Sad thing is, I would probably have a "Y" on the Creamsickle by now, but I gave someone cuttings because I thought it was Isabella. I know it has to be Creamsickle, because the other was something like Charles Grimaldi, and had the same notched leaves, so since I have a Charles Grimaldi, I gave it away.

Ah, well, such is the life of a brug lover. The actual Creamsickle seems to be growing now, so maybe I'll have blooms sometime this year.

JYG

You'll have blooms in no time! :) Enjoy!

Mike