Software
Houzz Logo Print
bigthicketgardens

alternate host for sbs & ps

19 years ago

Most of my butterfly books list Magnolia virginiana as a host plant for the palamedes swallowtail and some list it for the spicebush swallowtail as well.

Has anyone ever found either on of these on M. virginiana or raised one of them on it?

Comments (3)

  • 19 years ago

    My Audubon field guide and Geyata Ajilvsgi books list m. virginiana as hosts for palamedes swallowtails, Shawn - not spicebush swallowtails - but I've never found a single caterpillar on it. Even when I've offered it to moths that are supposed to use a wide variety of host plants, they never eat it, always going to something else.
    Tiger swallowtails of south Florida - pterourus glaucus australis - are supposed to use it exclusively, so they must be the only ones. Our eastern tigers - pterourus glaucus glaucus - sure don't.
    MissSherry

  • 19 years ago

    My copy of Butterfly Gardening for the South list M. virginiana as a host for the spicebush swallowtail it also list redbay as a host as well. It also list the cultivated alvocado for the palamedes. I'm probably going to end up getting some sweetbay to experiment with. Did you ever see if any palamedes swallowtail would eat any of the exotic Persea?

    Have you ever gotten a palamedes cat to eat sassafras, or a spicebush cat to eat redbay?

    Thanks

  • 19 years ago

    Oops, I forgot to look at GA's big list of host plants, I just looked at the section about spicebush and palamedes swallowtails specifically. I'll go look in my book again.
    I'm looking at it now, and I see where she listed tigers, palamedes and spicebush swallowtails in the big larval section as using magnolia virginiana. Like I said, I've never found a cat on it - she also said that red admirals would use hops vines, and they've never used mine, just question marks.
    I planted an avocado seed once and set the plant out for palamedes to use, but they never did. I've never found a spicebush swallowtail on redbay, nor a palamedes on sassafras. Once, when I was raising palamedes and spicebush swallowtails in a cage together, a palamedes cat ate a sassafras leaf - it grew just fine and emerged as a perfect butterfly.
    I've got lots of Asian members of the laurel family growing in pots that I'll be planting out this fall or winter - so far, I haven't found any cats or eggs on them. This is disappointing, because I had hoped to find an alternate host for them if that ambrosia beetle and the disease it causes wipes out all our laurels.
    MissSherry