Software
Houzz Logo Print
tiffy_z5_6_can

Feeding different milkweed OK?

18 years ago

I am just wondering if it's OK to feed the Monarch cats different milkweed. I still have a good supply of Incarnata, but the first 12 cats which have now formed their crysalis made me worry about my supply. I have 15 other smaller cats in the house now.

I have some Curassavica in the gardens. They are not big plants, but could be used if I needed them. Since they are an annual here, I thought I might as well try? Can I try mixing them with the Asclepias or is this a no-no for some reason.

Thanks!

Comments (7)

  • 18 years ago

    Its fine

  • 18 years ago

    In fact, I like to feed ALL of my caterpillars a 'salad' of sorts.

    For Monarchs, I mix their Milkweeds.

    For Giant Swallowtails, I mix different citrus leaves and Rue leaves.

    For Anise Swallowtails, I mix Rue, Fennel, and Parsley. Sometimes I even toss in a citrus tree leaf.

    This way, the larvae are not so picky. I also think that they tend to be healthier, but that is just my opinion.

  • 18 years ago

    That's great! I tried growing the Curassavica for the first time this year, but I may not have enough of a long season for them. I'm going to leave a couple to see how they do as our summers go right to the end of September, but I'll mix the greens for the hungry cats.

    I'm curious... By 'Rue' do you mean the plant which I know as Meadow Rue or Thalictrum? I have a lot of those and am interested in trying to get some Swallowtails but haven't seen any in the gardens at all this year. We've seen the odd one in years past.

  • 18 years ago

    Sometimes they will eat other milkweed, sometimes they won't.

    In a drought year, I had soo many cats on the incanarta and the drought had the plants struggling. I had about 12 cats on the plants and it was eaten down to nothing but sticks. We ran out of leaves. I tried feeding them tuberosa, that I had plenty of, that does well in drought, but the cats wouldn't eat it. One died....so then I drove around and found stand of wild incanarta and harvested some leaves before the other ones died.

    The worse part, in this drought year, was that the wild incanarta that I had found was growing in a spring fed ditch, the only moist area around. And when I went back to get more, the highway crews had mowed the ditch and I lost my source. By that time the cats were bigger and had decided that they would A. syrica, of which I had plenty.

    I remember a few stressful days looking for incanarta during a drought.

  • 18 years ago

    Well, they love the Curassavica! I went out in a drenching rain and picked some as well as Incarnata, dried them and filled their humble abode. They went for the C. right away with no issues. Just might grow it again next year as a stand by.

    I can somewhat see why they might not like the Tuberosa if they haven't been started on that one. Just bought one last week and the leaves are not as tender as the other milkweeds.

    I have Syriaca started from seed this year. Looking forward to this one!

    Just trying to keep a couple of the Incarnatas looking half decent for a garden tour this Sunday. After that, I don't care what they look like. :O)

  • 18 years ago

    I don't grow curassavica because I am focusing my landscape on North American natives only. So the syriaca, incanarta and tuberosa are the ones that I grow now. There are several more that I could add including sullivanti and speciosa...

  • 18 years ago

    When I say 'Rue' I am talking about Ruta graveolens.

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Franklin County's Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting