Software
Houzz Logo Print
susanlynne48

Afraid They're Going to Die!

17 years ago

My Buckeyes are still eating altho they are big enough I am trying to force them into pupation. I still have Sleepy Orange, Cloudless Sulphur, and QM chrysalises.

I have never had these this late so I don't know if they will winter over or die. The sulphur chrysalises are still pink and green as tho still alive. For several weeks temps have beem in 40s and 50s with a sprinkling of low 60s. It is supposed to get into 70s this week so maybe some will eclose.

Anyone else in my zone or cooler having these issues?

Also still have a number of BST cats eating fennel (some I moved to Zizia which they are eating). I don't recall ever having them this late or in these cool temps! Many of my plants are turning brown, especially heat lovers, but there is still nectar available from asters, a few zinnias, V. bonariensis, Cosmos, and Lantana. All but the Asters are looking like they are ready to die back soon.

I have tried to find info on the Internet about whether my cats and chrysalises might overwinter, but haven't found anything about my sulphurs or Buckeyes. I feel like the QMs will be okay since they are not tropicals that fly south like the others.

Susan

Comments (8)

  • 17 years ago

    Do you have them inside or outside? I had some BST inside and once they pupated, I put them outside in a metal locker I have. We've been in the 50s here...but may get a few days in the 60s at the end of next week. So I am keeping my fingers crossed that they don't eclose.
    If I were you, I'd let them pupate and move them outside to an unheated shed, garage, or move them into a cool dark spot in the basement. Some put them in the fridge, but my husband would have a fit about that.

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks, Linda. They are outside on the porch that is not enclosed. My question really concerns whether these cats either enter diapause or can overwinter as chrysalises. Some, like the BSTs and GSTs, do overwinter in chrysalis form, but others cannot survive even as pupae let alone cats. That is my question. I have never had or heard of these particular leps wintering over in either form like some of the swallowtails or brush foots that are known to do so.

    I would not keep them inside since they would eclose with no nectar available in all likelihood. Guess I'll just keep my fingers crossed.

  • 17 years ago

    Susan, I don't know what to tell you because I don't know either if those types of butterflies/cats/ can deal with low temps like that. I was faced with the dilemma when I heard that we would be getting snow and freezing temps these past few days and I still had some Monarch pupas. I decided that rather than have them eclose in the house where I had been keeping them (they grow faster inside than outside in the fall) and them not having nectar, I'd put them outside and count them as a loss. I wish they could have made it, but now that it's been as cold as it has, I don't think they made it. I'd guess that the QM chrysalids of yours would be okay, but I haven't a clue about the Sleepy Orange and Cloudless Sulphur ones. I really hope that they will all eclose. Don't we worry about our babies though. ;-)
    Cathy

  • 17 years ago

    Unfortunately, I can't help you either, Susan, because my fall buckeye cats have always, including this year, pupated and emerged before cold weather sets in. I've got one late chrsyalis, and I'm keeping it on the porch - I'll see what happens.
    We're having our first taste of winter/fall now. It got down to 48 last night, and it's supposed to be like that tonight, and then gradually warm up. I'll be leaving the cats in their cages on the porch this winter, because last winter I had quite a few butterflies to emerge before their host plants were making new growth. I've consolidated the many pipevine swallowtail chysalides, so that I've only got four cages out there. I'm covering them all with a sheet at night to keep any excess wind off them, should that occur. If we have abnormally cold weather, like maybe a night below 20 degrees (that happens occasionally, but not in about ?10 years) I'll bring them inside to the unheated guest room.
    Your buckeye cats may survive - I had some gulf frits cats to overwinter one mild winter. They resumed eating when spring came and the passionvines they were on made new growth - that might happen with your buckeyes, I don't know.
    I sure hope they survivie!
    Sherry

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks for your responses everybody. Guess I have no alternative but to take the wait and see approach. Those darned Buckeyes just refuse to pupate. I ran out of Diascian and started them on the Ruellia and two Plantago species, lanceolata and major, which definiately don't appreciate at all. I find little of the leaves eaten and they tend to congregate on the top of the container where they rest motionless. Of course the cool temps may be affecting them, too. We will see and I will keep you all posted.

    I did see a Gulf Frit flying yesterday.

    Susan

  • 17 years ago

    I saw a few gulf frits, sulphurs and a buckeye yesterday, too, Susan - it was a welcome sight! It actually got down to 40 degrees night before last, so this is looking like a cold winter to come.
    I found a buckeye caterpillar yesterday, and I brought it in to finish raising myself. It's a late instar cat, maybe ready to pupate, but I found some nice looking agalinis and put it in the water pick next to the leafless stick it was on, in case it wants to eat some more. It nosed around the leaves for a while, but stayed on the bare stick, so I don't know what's going on here. It'll be interesting to see how my buckeye cat and chrysalis fare over the winter.
    Sherry

  • 17 years ago

    Susan; I'm playing the waiting game with 4 BST's that are in my cage outside. I was more worried about them being parasitized and keeping them isolated from others that I brought inside as youngins that I think are fine. It had gotten pretty cold here a few nights, where my coleus' are officially toast, but other annuals are hanging in there. One has been in pupating position, although no harness yet, for what seems to be 2 weeks. He is still alive; I gave the ole blow test and he twitched. I have 3 others that seem large enough but aren't showing any signs of retreating off the parsley in seek of higher ground for pupation. Thankfully it warmed up yesterday and those 3 actually became a bit active during the day. I might have to bring those 3 in to pupate, but the 4th guy is on his own. Normally the only thing I'm worried about this time of the year is the frost getting my dahlias. Now I have to add these darn cats to the game...

  • 17 years ago

    Heehee, Tracy, the old "blow test". I use the ever so slight "finger flip" on my chrysalises, especially GFs. I have 2 chrysalises that have been pupating for the last month. They still "protest" by twitching so I am assuming there is still life there.

    Not all chrysalis's twitch, but I have found the GFs. HEs, TEs, RAs, to be in-chrysalis movers and groovers when disturbed.

    I think the BSTs will pupate and overwinter fine, just not sure about the others. I have let the BSTs feed and pupate outside, There must be at least a couple dozen cats that have pupated and/or are still feeding just within the last couple weeks. So I should have a good group to start out in spring. The green bulb fennel produces growth and looks lush all winter here, so there will be food available when they emerge.

    Susan