It is hard to tell from what you are describing but I would suggest that you need to put the plants into small plastic pots.
If you area is normally humid during the day leave the potted plant uncovered, covering at night with an inverted jar.
these plants love brightly lit spots with some direct sun for an hour or so each day.
Place your potted plant upon a larger inverted pot before watering and water with the distilled heavily. you may want to put the entire get-up into a tray in order to save the drained off water that can be used for other plants.
Do not let them sit in any water.
read the instructions below.

Here is a link that might be useful: Care instructions

Here's a visual aid for growing them:

{{gwi:562345}}

{{gwi:562347}}

Are those pine needles petiolaris? the VFT in the bottom "rightish?" looks great! Is one of those a fused tooth?

You should use the tray method for VFTs. You don't want them to be standing in water, per se. Put the pot containing the VFT into a tray. Then water the VFT with distilled/rain/reverse osmosis water. Continue watering until you have about 2 cm of water in the tray. Don't let this dry out.

Also, contrary to what many people assume, VFTs are temperate plants, not tropicals. They should be outdoors in the summer if possible (and in the winter too if you're in a warm enough area).

Those are indeed pine needles. I rearranged the container, recently, so I'm not sure which pot was the Fused Tooth.

I've had my venus fly trap for almost a year now. I repotted it in the peat moss about 10 months ago, and only distilled water, water from the bottom in a nifty self watering container I got at Walmart. No cover used. It gets enough light during the day sitting near a window.

The problem is that the traps are supersmall. It keeps putting out new leaves which are decent to small in size, but the traps are just supersmall. The plant doesn't look anything like the healthy ones in your picture.

What can I possibly due to boost the health of this plant.

Has it had dormancy since you've had it? They NEED 3-4 months of dormancy each winter. Is it in FULL Sun outside? If you're growing it inside I won't respond any further, these are not indoor plants.

I just took it out of dormancy. It went 4.5 months in dormancy. I'm slowing reintroducing it back to sun, but full sun in Phoenix will be too much for it. Indoor sun in my living room is like full sun outside elsewhere.

I am pretty sure VFT can not have too much sun. The only issue would probably be the water in the dish heating up to like 150 degrees in the sun. You could solve that by planting it in a white clay pot and top watering it every day instead of putting it in a hot water dish. If the traps are green then it needs more sun. If the entire plant is mostly red then it is probably near maximum sun exposure.