Software
Houzz Logo Print
ralphw_gw

Deer Control Using White Grocery Bags.

19 years ago

For the past few nights we have had one or more deer come through our back yard and eat all of the leaves off the strawberries, much of the lettuce and sample multiple other plants. This is the first time we have had multiple visits in the same week, and the damage is escalating. One of my third cousins reported that they solved their deer problem (for now) by tying white grocery bags on sticks and placing them around their garden. I was skeptical that this could work and tried Google to see what I could find about this technique. The following site suggests that white grocery bags may help for a while, but its greater value is in the humor associated with others attempts to deal with the problem. Reading it made me feel a little better, so I thought that I would share it. Anyone else who has had any success short of shooting these critters, please let us all know.

Here is a link that might be useful: Deer Repellant Techniques

Comments (17)

  • 19 years ago

    Last time I was at Niche Gardens I noticed they'd put up deer fencing all around. The fencing wasn't very noticeable because their nursery is located in the woods. It's the only thing I've heard of that works.

    I feel your pain. The deer come through and snack on our garden too. The deer are so used to us they don't even run when they see us coming until we get pretty close. The deer damage is not as bad as it could be because there's a lot of undeveloped floodplain near us, but the land is full of red maple, sweetgum, ligustrum and honeysuckle, which deer don't like. I wish the deer would just eat the grass in the horse pastures and leave my Encore azaleas alone. But they won't.

  • 19 years ago

    We're in the same boat here. We have a neighborhood herd of about 13 head of deer that love to snack on our rose bushes, annuals, and azaleas. The only thing that has worked with any sort of consistency for us is Plantskydd deer repellant. It's working so well that the other evening we watched 7 of the deer walk down the side of the yard and right past 6 rose bushes and two azaleas. They sniffed and then moved right along. We're actually going to have a decent rose show in our yard this year and I'm thanking Plantskydd for it.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Plantskydd web site

  • 19 years ago

    ---I checked the Plantskydd website for retailers and found the closest one listed to be the Tru-Value Hardware store south of Chapel Hill. Anyone know of one closer to Raleigh?

  • 19 years ago

    I'm sorry you are having deer trouble. I had a terrible problem at my last house, so I'm taken different measures here.

    Since building this house in 2005, I've been on a mission to make my garden as deer-resistant as possible. We have a permanent cottage garden fence that obviously works for everything except what they can nip through the fence.

    Outside the permanent fence, I double and triple check what I'm planting to make sure it shows up on 2-3 deer-resistant lists. However, I was still getting the deer traffic through the mixed border during the winter and they would literally pull plants (that they didn't like) out of the ground. So...I decided to use a 28" high (I think) metal edging fence around one shrub that they were picking on. It worked. So, I bought a few more 10' sections and tried that. I ended up spending $100 on the edging to go all the way around our mixed border. Yes, they CAN jump it, but they just don't bother, even though they used to stroll up the sidewalk to where the only opening is located.

    I don't know how long this will work (I think it's been up since February). It may be just temporary. I think it's working because I cut off their traffic route, I'm planting deer-resistant plants, and they are too lazy to jump it. Because 30 feet away from the edging is the permanent fence, it also looks enclosed to them.

    Once you start using repellents, the cost goes up and if you skip an application and/or they adjust to it, you're back to the battle. Can you use electric fence? That's the least expensive fence that I can think of that can be put up and taken down easily. I know someone who actually put peanut butter on theirs to make sure the deer licked it and got shocked. There is a ribbon, rather than wire, electric fence that is more visible and sturdy. The stakes are fairly easy to plug in the ground. You can probably find it at a local Southern States or other farm supply. I think it will cost less and be more reliable than applying repellents all the time.

    Cameron

  • 19 years ago

    i think i saw plantskyyd at logan's, but i might be wrong. mailorder, pinetree garden seeds carries it.

  • 19 years ago

    One thing to realize about electric fencing is that you have to keep the grass and weeds short under the wires. Anywhere a plant touches the wire, unless you get one of the REALLY strong ones that burns and kills the plant, it shorts out the circuit and thus the fence is either ineffective or less effective. You can use one wire, but it has to complete a circle - a single wire going out and not connecting around to itself won't work. That's one reason most electric fences are two wires or tapes.

    They can work for deer, and I'm going to try this summer - I got two beans last summer, out of 3 major plantings! Deer LOVE green bean plants!

  • 19 years ago

    I planted a small garden for my mom in front of her townhouse not even considering deer because I've never had them here. Of course they ate EVERYTHING, so I did some research and found plants they don't like to put there. They still browse it, especially in spring, but it's much better. Actually, the early browsing makes some of the plants fuller and lusher than they grow for me, guess I should do more pinching. Recently we've been seeing deer at the entrance to the neighborhood and I'm terrified they are gonna find me because I have so many deer tasties planted here. I'm sure it's just a matter of time... Hopefully my 5 foot wire fence will deter them. Yes, I know they CAN jump it (and if they figure out how many yummy plants I have they might) but I hope they don't bother. I feel bad for all you guys in deer country. (and probably soon-to-be me!)
    Funny reading on that link Ralph!

  • 19 years ago

    I placed white grocery bags on 5-foot high sticks every 15 feet around my garden Wednesday evening and have not seen any signs of the deer so far. Fortunately, the garden is not visible from the street, so none of the neighbors have complained so far. We are seriously considering fencing in the back yard and getting an outside dog - my daughter and son-in-law will help support it and it will be our grand daughter's dog but live at our house. They only live 15 minutes away and already visit often. If her dog lives at our house, she may insist that they bring her even more often.

  • 19 years ago

    Ralph, I vote for getting a dog. My little subdivision was built in the middle of farm land. Deer frequent everyone elses yard except mine. I've even seen deer directly across the street from my house but they didn't even look at the daylilies planted by my mailbox about 20 feet away from where they were munching. We have a fence but they could surely jump a 4' fence if they wanted and I think I have tastier stuff than everyone else. I think it's because we have dogs.

    Now sometimes dogs and gardens are a pain, but we started early with the big dogs with training. Now they walk all the way around the garden, never going through it. One even stands at the very edge waiting til I throw her a tomato. Last year we got a third dog and she's a little digger. I've never had so much digging going on, but then again she small and its probably in her genes to dig for voles and stuff. Plus I haven't spent a ton of time teaching her not to dig. So far she knows not to dig while I'm outside. I guess that could be considered progress. lol

    Yep, get a dog. They are way more fun than a fence.

  • 19 years ago

    Our deer herd isn't afraid of our dog. Of course, a greyhound is a racer, not a fighter. She doesn't bark at anything. She "goes" in our front meadow and so do the deer. So, dog smell doesn't scare them either.

  • 19 years ago

    I had a time with the deer last spring. I decided to try deer repellent, and after checking the ingredients on several brands I noticed many of them contained eggs. I mixed up a solution of eggs and water, let it ferment a bit and used the strained liquid to spray my plants. Worked like a charm. I reapplied about once a month, and even though I still found tracks and droppings in the yard, they finally left my poor peppers and daylilies alone! Smells awful (at first) but works great.

  • 19 years ago

    Unfortunately, I have alot of experience trying to thwart the deer. All the typical remedies like hair, bloodmeal, string, pie tins, etc.... become ineffective after awhile. They work for awhile until some alpha deer figures them out and tells the others in the herd. Well, not really, but you know what I mean.

    Fencing is effective, but it has to be 7 feet high. The next best thing I've found is the sprays. I use Liquid Fence. I've also used the locally produced "I Must Garden" mint-based spray, which smelled alot better, but it doesn't last as long. With LF, I typically spray about once a month.

  • 19 years ago

    spazz- do you have to spray everything you don't want them to eat or does a wide perimeter work to keep them out as a fence would? how long does the i must garden last compared to the other? logan's sells both and i've considered both so it's great to have some real feedback.

  • 19 years ago

    One of the fellows who leased our fields used the white plastic grocery bags to mark the fence so deer wouldn't run into the fence, knock it down and let the cattle out.
    He ran an extremely hot electric fence (3 wire) that wasn't a deer deterrent but could shock us, just standing next to it.
    A friend in Maine runs a high fence and then where the deer were choosing in the woods to jump over it, a second fence line that was so close that the deer couldn't do a double jump.
    Other friends run fishing line which seems to bother the deer as they can't see the line and it bothers them a lot.

    Two other words: Bow Season.

  • 19 years ago

    I use sprays as well (Deer Off), approx once a month, with more spraying during times of rapid growth. I find that I really need to spray everything I want protected, as opposed to a barrier. They'll sample around the area until they find something that doesn't taste bad. Daylilies are the hardest -- even if they haven't touched the plants in months, I need to spray the scapes/blooms pretty often or they'll take the flowers off the top. I was really hoping to try the Repellex systemic, but apparently they got into USDA trouble and got taken off the market. Argh!

  • 19 years ago

    I agree w/ moka jo. Spray what you want spared. Deer would easily ignore a perimeter spray line. Deer will sample graze around an area until they find something tasty. They'll bypass anything that doesn't smell appetizing. For example, they'll reach over the Russian sage to get to the Callirhoe unless I spray it.

    The I Must Garden only lasted 2 weeks or so for me, and even less if we got alot of rain. The Liquid Fence seems to last consistently about a month regardless. The two products cost about the same. The only problem is the smell of the Liquid Fence. It reeks like a bad septic system for a couple of hours after you spray it (and IMHO, should be called Liquid Sh*t, because that's what it smells like). The I Must Garden is mint-based, so it's odor isn't as objectionable, but I feel that you get a little more more your money with the LF. Of course, you can always make your own spray too.

  • 19 years ago

    hmmm- good description, spazz. will make me think 2x- lol. at least til i get desperate. i may try a homemade concoction. they have so much to eat around here that i think they've just gotten into a bad habit of drifting through our yard because it was easy, since last year a few things were nibbled in the back and this spring is the first we'd noticed anything up front. we ran some twine this weekend and will go back between with fishing line if need be. i'm hoping the slightest deterrent will work since this is the first in 13 years we've lived here that they've bothered anything. if that doesn't work i'm giving serious thought to the plastic deer fences, since in the woods it would be barely visible. before we go that far we'll see how this does. i hate spraying anything for any reason (just don't like the mechanics of doing it) especially once a month, so i think that's a non starter for me. and i don't think i could talk dh into it, either. thanks for the feedback.

Sponsored
Columbus' Home Design Experts Specializing in Custom Cabinets