Software
Houzz Logo Print
nohandle

please help me choose

17 years ago

Location is a tough one, at least for me, and unfortunately it's a very important one.

East side of the northeast corner of the front of my house...first thing you see when come in the driveway.

Spacing: space between the corner of the house and the lower/upper front windows is approx. 4 feet wide and the space between the house and the front walk is about two feet, but the branches could extend a little beyond.

Light: east exposure, but on the other side of the walk is a 25 foot maple, limbed up to about halfway...so bright/dappled shade at best

Soil: the maple and the rain shadow of the house make this a pretty dry spot...sandy soil makes it worse

I have been wanting something evergreen, tall and pyramidal to take some of the monolithic look away from the house(2-story brick with the driveway going right up to and along the north side of the house). I've tried a pyramidal emerald cedar (Thuja occidentalis 'Smaragd', I think), but I don't think I understood how dry that site can be and it was a very dry year, so it died.

Not sure if that was a doomed selection anyways, since I've since heard they don't hold their shape in the shade....although it didn't live long enough to find out.

Anyways, that's probably more information that anyone cared to know, but if you could suggest some conifers that might work based on experience, I would be eternally grateful.

Thanks

Comments (6)

  • 17 years ago

    ...space is actually 4 x 3 feet, not 4 x 2...in case it matters

  • 17 years ago

    Can you post a photo of the area you are wanting information as what to plant.

    Watering is critical to any plant...are you prepared to water as needed to ensure survival of plant? So we are talking about filtered shade and not any full sun at all...as I understand it.

    Stay away from Thuja occidentalis 'Smaragd'. To many issues even if they survive.

    Dave

  • 17 years ago

    Plants for that type of exposure and required dimensions:
    Tsuga mertensiana 'Blue Star'
    Taxus x media 'Flushing'
    Taxus x media 'Sentinalis'

    Not conifers but choice:
    Fagus sylvatica 'Aurea Pendula'
    Ulmus x hollandica 'Dampieri'

    Dax

  • 17 years ago

    Dave...I can post a picture later if you want to come back and have a look.
    I am committed to watering whatever I plant more so than I did last time. In hindsight, I didn't understand the impact the maple had on the soil and was very much under watering...lesson learned.
    And yes, it is mostly filtered shade. It might get a couple of hours of early morning sun underneath the canopy of the maple, but after 10 am, its shaded by the leaves. After about noon, it's fully shaded by the house.
    Should I stay away from Thuja occidentalis in general?...or just the Emerald/Smargard?

    Dax....thanks for the suggestions. I have been wondering about the hemlocks, but wasn't sure if they would tolerate the dry soil or if they would spread too wide...I like them though and would definitely plant one if I can be convinced.
    As for the yews, I know that there are a few that would work, but I'm not a huge fan for some reason...at least not of the stiff and narrow formal-looking ones.
    I have thought about the fagus too, but I'm wondering about its eventual height. I'm limited to about 12, maybe 15 feet before it would look out of place. Would this be a concern for Tsuga as well?

    Mike


  • 17 years ago

    You could plant Platycladus orientalis as well. There's 'Columnaris Aurea' I know but I'm not familiar with the rest. These along with Thuja occidentalis should do OK. The Beech would also do fine. There's certainly nothing wrong with Thuja occ. 'Degroot's'. It's quite choice. Water every now and then. The first year water on a schedule: weekly, etc-. The second year, supplemental water is also needed.

    Dax

  • 17 years ago

    I grow 3 Thuja occ. 'Degroot's'. in filtered shade and they do quite well. These are becoming common place and most of the larger nursery's carry them.

    I'll throw in a photo and then you can decide.

    Good advice Dax.

    Dave
    {{gwi:667759}}

Sponsored
Hope Restoration & General Contracting
Average rating: 4.7 out of 5 stars35 Reviews
Columbus Design-Build, Kitchen & Bath Remodeling, Historic Renovations