Software
Houzz Logo Print
lemon_dreams

UGH, scale

20 years ago

Here I was, ALL exited. no pests no problems and then... all of a sudden see scale. I didn't think it was on everything until I really searched today. I hosed them down good, swabbed with rubbing alcohol, but I know theres a lot I prolly missed. they are in all stages... crawlies, ones just forming shells and big shelled ones. Unfortunatly, 3 of my trees are in blooms and I was told the oil will kill the blooms... but then again, thinking that the scale will kill the whole tree. wonder which is worse :( Anyways, I go on wednesday to pick up some hort oil. I hate that I need to do this, but, part of owning citrus.

Curious on whats a good thing to have on hand or do in order to prevent scale? spraying hort oil a few times a year or? I know there are so many posts on scale, Prolly should go ready them. Just SO not impressed. I got a few plants from my mom... thinking they may have come in that way as the scale problem started when I introduced the new trees into my plant room. So... hort oil it is.

Is Hort oil ok for small seedlings? I have 20 key lime seedlings 1-2" tall and same for lemon seedlings. Dont want to lose them!

Any tips, advice... GREATLY apreciated!

Comments (13)

  • 20 years ago

    Lemon, there is ONE ITEM that I SWEAR by for all 'sucking' insects: Bayer's shrub and tree insectide. It is a soil drench which lasts 12 months, and it kills all sucking insects within a week - it's just a miracle insecticide as far as I AM CONCERNED! Those critter can NOT hide from this product - it circulates through the plant's vascular system and they won't return once they are gone.

  • 20 years ago

    Bayer Shrub and Tree systemic insecticide should not be used on edible plants.
    Karyn

  • 20 years ago

    that product scares me. I want to eat the fruit from my tree and preferable not get sick. plus, I'd really like to avoid insecticides and stick with more user friendly oils. I just hope it works

  • 20 years ago

    Lemon Dreams, if you have Fish Emulsion on hand, I'd use that..it's pretty much organic and like other oils is used the same way..It won't burn leaves, and will fertilize the same time..Give it a try. Before my plants come in each are being sprayed w/FE.

    Do you seedlings have scale, too? If so, just pluck them off and swipe area w/rubbing alcohol. They're too delicate to use stronger ingredients. Also, if there are few scale, just pluck them off w/finger and thumb.
    I wish you luck ridding those suckers..it's the babies that hard difficult detecting..Toni

  • 20 years ago

    I've sprayed with FE and I water with it. Its given not much protection. Sprayed twice prior to even knowing I had scale and just last night again. Moreso to prevent any spreading. still searching for my rubbing alcohol. had a lot, sprayed em, now I want to wipe down. I have rubbing alcohol swabs. figured those would be best to use

  • 20 years ago

    That's right, I forgot you mentioned in another thread you tried the FE..I'm sorry..
    Would you say the tree is more than 50% infested? If so, you've really got your hands full..Can u take to the shower, and hose off..then do the rubbing alcohol thing? While hosing, scrape them off..I detest bugs and they do much to ruin our plants.
    I hope the oil helps where the FE doesn't..read directions and follow to a T..Toni

  • 20 years ago

    its nowhere near as bad as 50% maybe 10-15% if that. Its a minor infestation, but its also JUST starting... most of the scale is immature little crawlers. I know what they look like because earlier in the year I got a trovita covered in baby scale. it was cleaned 5-8 times before it got near my other citrus. I got 6 of my big trees wipped down with the alcohol swabs, and didn't see any scale, but not to say there wasn't any. then, teh room became stink bug infested.. yuk, so I left the room.... ok, there were only 3 stink ugs... but those are just gross nasty bugs.

    I'd love to put them in teh tub and shower down, in fact I tried... but... my tub is broken, it wont drain. waiting on teh landlord to fix it. thanfully my sister lives in te basement unit so able to go there for a shower

  • 20 years ago

    Lemon, I'm glad to hear you only have 15% scale..just continue working on this plant and eventually they should die..I hope so..those scale are something..It could be worse, u know? I hate mealy..Those bugs are bad news..or canker.
    Keep wiping w/alcohol 2-3 times a wk until all signs of scale are gone..good luck, Toni

  • 20 years ago

    since rubbing with alcohol, the leaves are wilted and looking... so not healthy. it is weak alcohol solution too. ugh. hoping that they perk up over the night

  • 20 years ago

    Hey lemon_dreams,
    I am by no means an expert but I generally do not care for rubbing alcohol as a insecticide. It is quite harsh and drying on the skin, so I can't imagine that it is delicate on plant tissues. I tried it on some aphid-infested strawberries a couple years ago--the leaves are very ridged and yet soft, so there's lots of nooks and crannies for the little buggers to hide--and promptly burnt the leaves to a crisp. I think I used a 50/50 mix of OTC 72% isopropyl alcohol and water, but I don't recall the details except the mental note to never do that again :) Those prepackaged swabs and wipes are full strength. I still think, since your trees are small, that manual scraping with soapy water swabs and then a rinse to remove the soap--done a few times over a few days--is the least toxic way of taking care of the problem.

    Though, as I recall, tapla uses a fair amount of alcohol in his neem oil mix and has had very good results with that. Maybe the oil or the soap he also adds may somehow counteract the dessication, or the concentration is less than I am remembering. Al, please comment?

  • 20 years ago

    I gave the trees a misting with water and they all seem to look so much better. I think a lot of the issue was it got too hot and the alcohol... (the swabs are a low strength alcohol)

    I'm just frustrated was so happy to have no bug and pests... too happy I think

  • 20 years ago

    Rick 50% alcohol is too much..I wouldn't spray that much on my plants..I'd think it'd burn the leaves. Anytime I used it I just dabbed the area that had bugs..And I only used it for mealy or scale..I have to use FE on my Olive tree..for some reason the scale come back..I thought I rid them once the tree was outside this summer, but I noticed a few hanging on leaves..wish I knew what the babies looked like..I'm worried my citrus will catch these bugs.

    Lemon, do you mean the cotton swabs you have already contain alcohol? If so, where did you find them? That's interesting..Toni

  • 20 years ago

    Hi, LD. I don't know you, but I know something of you, even having had a joke of yours recently taking a circuitous route and landing in my inbox. ;o)

    I see excellent advice above from Karyn1, please heed it (based on your comments, it already seems assured that you will). I also have great respect for RickJames' knowledge and abilities, and especially for the command of all aspects of organic chemistry. When RickJames talks, I listen carefully, and have even had conversation and a chuckle with this grower at the thought of "going about stamping out disease, pestilence, and misinformation".

    Thanks Rick, for the vote of confidence & invitation to comment. I think I have an answer to why your strawberry's leaves crispified under isopropyl (C38HO) alcohol applications & why my practical experience with similar applications on my trees yielded different results.

    The leaves of Fragaria are densely pubescent with uni-cellular and (to a lesser degree) multi-cellular tricomes (This just means they are extremely fuzzy.). These tricomes are both a deterrent against insect attack and a mechanism that slows air flow across the leaf, thus slowing water loss from leaf tissues. Leaves that are structured like this and the tricomes themselves are normally lacking in the cuticular waxes that afford Citrus, and many of the tropical and sub-tropical trees I grow resistance to water loss. I'm thinking the presence of these waxes is what has allowed me to use 70% isopropyl alcohol, often full strength, on 15-20 different genera of trees with impunity, and the lack of the waxes is what caused RJ's crispage in the Fragaria.

    I often use a mix of 1:1 70% isopropyl: hot water with a teaspoon of cold-pressed neem oil and a few drops of dish soap per L as both a preventative and a fixative insecticide, the alcohol providing good "knockdown". It is perfectly safe, and if you'd like to learn more of it, I'll forward or post to the forum, an article I recently updated on neem as an insecticide.

    FWIW - For years, I've used applications of fish emulsion as a foliar feeding at the same time I apply Daconil as an anti-fungal on my garden display containers. I am pretty observant when it comes to plants, and have never noted any insecticidal deterrent from its application. It is my opinion that fish emulsion as an insecticide is approximately equal to sorcery in its level of effectiveness - but it's only my opinion. You and the readers can decide for yourselves, but I hope I've at least left you with a bent toward skepticism at its use.

    Take care, & thanks (indirectly) for the joke.

    Al

Sponsored
Urban Upkeep LLC
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars6 Reviews
Columbus High Quality Painting Expert