Software
Houzz Logo Print
meyermike_1micha

Question for toni regarding scale spray?

18 years ago

Hi toni.

I have a friend that has scale on a what looks like a citrus tree. I want to treat the tree for him. But here is my question. Before I say, watch this, I will kill them for you in a heart beat.....Does FE really work?

Was it a fluke thing that this happened for you? What I don't understand is why FE would work and yet something such Neem oil won't?

Is there an answer for this? maybe the stench of fish....Hum

Thanks Toni!! have a great weekend and be safe...

By the way it hit 72 today here in good ole New England!!

Comments (5)

  • 18 years ago

    The reason that the FE might work is because of the oil. You can use neem or any horticultural oil instead to avoid the stench. Just be sure to read and follow the directions on any product that you use. It's always good to know what kind of plant it is, just in case it might be one of the few that oil solutions should not be used.

  • 18 years ago

    I am still dumb founded. I have seen people here say that neem "oil" does not get rid of scale, and yet FE does. What about the FE oil makes it so toxic to scale while neem does not? I am just curious to see if anyone has any clue.

  • 18 years ago

    Mike, it is the OIL in fish oil that smothers scale and other insects. You can use any horticultural oil to the same effect. Trust me, FE is not any more 'toxic'. Everyone who tends to garden or indoor plants should have a horticultural oil of some brand on hand. When used according to directions, these products can break the cycle of aphids, spider mites, scale, mealybugs, and others.

    Horticultural oils have been used for many generations as a safe and effective method of pest control.

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks alot rhizzo....I just couldn't understand why so many on this forum were saying that neem didn't work on scale, unless I just imagined it....Thanks a million for taking the time as always to care enough to explain...Have a happy night and stay warm. As of friday, our temps are going to tumble. Guess you can't hold on to the warmth for ever up here...Today it is a whopping 73 degrees and still my citrus and gardenias are outside...:-). Still no killing frost. I think after this weekend, there will be.:-(

  • 18 years ago

    Mike- You asked the question that has been in the back of my mind all summer.
    I found Fish Emulsion at a hardware store, but it's a fertilizer. Am I supposed to somehow spray this stuff on the plants, or is there a fish emulsion product designed specifically as an insecticide???
    I used the emulsion once as a fertilizer, and very nearly lost my lunch! (that smell is so...sewage)
    I have a Scale, mealy bug and Spider mite infestation on my grapefruit tree, so I put it back outside until I can figure things out. (gotta find Neem Oil soon- I can't get out to Logee's , where I bought it the last time) I used Safer's on some smaller citrus plants and some Gardenias that have Spider mites (ran out of that!), and they're back indoors, but I'll have to Neem the crud out of the Gr. Fr. tree- that tree has been nothing but trouble from day one!!!. Thank goodness it's the time of year when Ladybugs are in abundance- I think they've helped with the Mealy bugs some- I see less of them since I put the tree back out. But they're still there- all in the flower buds :0( Plus- the Ladybugs are leaving....
    Why didn't I spray before I took everything in you ask? Because that would have been the smart thing to do!!
    Any advice on that FE fertilizer? Is this what I should use to (gulp) spray? What ratios should I use to make a "mix"?

Sponsored
AIS Renovations
Average rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars15 Reviews
Custom Craftsmanship & Construction Solutions in Franklin County, Ohio