Software
Houzz Logo Print
naturegirl_2007

Botanically correct terms for conifer seed production

I'm talking with people who insist pines, spruce, etc. are flowering plants because they produce pollen and seeds. I don't agree. Seems like some pretty basic knowledge that they aren't understanding. Can you help me out with simple, yet correct terms to use in describing the so called "flowering" of the conifers. What term describes the time they are producing lots of pollen. And how about some convincing facts to show that conifers are NOT flowering plants. (And feel free to correct me if indeed they are....lots of people I work with have already done so)

Comments (11)

  • 17 years ago

    They're wrong; conifers are gymnosperms, the young seeds (embryos) are not produced in the ovary of a flower, but naked (Greek, gymnos).

    Male: pollen cone or pollen strobilus (plural: strobili)
    Female: seed cone or seed strobilus

    Resin

  • 17 years ago

    consider your audience .. i dont understand resins answer

    no ovary involved ... means they are not flowers ...

    ken

  • 17 years ago

    Here Ken:

    Pg. 51 Conifers by Keith Rushforth:

    Plants raised from seed will be different from each other and from their parents as all conifer seed originates from theunion of egg cell and pollen cell. Apomixis, whereby all the genetic material comes from the mother, does not occur in conifers.

    Mirriam Webster online: "Apomixix" reproduction (as apogamy or parthenogenesis) involving specialized generative tissues but not dependent on fertilization.

    Dax

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks, glad to know I wasn't as mixed up as people tried to make me out to be, but I'm obviously not very good at explaining conifer seed production to others. I'll make another attempt and I'll be well aware of my audience. The adults may hear about naked seeds, but the 7 and 8 year olds will hear it a bit differently or I'll hear about nothing else the rest of the day!

    What would you say the pines are doing when lots of pollen is being released from the male cones? The pollen release happens in flowering plants when they are "flowering." Do the gymnosperms have a "coneing" time? I'm sure they don't since that sounds really stupid, but is there a term for the pollen releasing time?

  • 17 years ago

    Pollinating / pollination is the term you're looking for!

    Resin

  • 17 years ago

    The quote from Rushforth is a red herring with nothing to do with the questions asked.
    Resin is right on the ovary being part of a true flower, and its absence in gymnosperms. Gymnosperms ("naked seeds") have their ovules not in an ovary but on the surface of cone scales. So they are not flowering plants in the sense of bearing flowers. However, the activity of "flowering" is used just the same in talking about gymnosperms. But it in no way implies that gymnosperms have flowers -- just a quirk of language.
    The period of pollen-shedding is "anthesis".

  • 17 years ago

    "The period of pollen-shedding is "anthesis""

    Not for conifers . . . anthesis means anthers, which only flowering plants have.

    Resin

  • 17 years ago

    Regardless of its etymological origin, "anthesis" has historically been used in technical literature for the period of conifer pollen shed.

  • 17 years ago

    Just googled "anthesis pine" and found numerous publications using that terminology. Most are very recent, and include work done in US, Finland, etc.

  • 17 years ago

    That just means sloppy thinking and careless editing is rife . . . Che novità !

  • 17 years ago

    No, it just means that language idealists are doomed to a life of either nit-picking or colluding with evil. OMG, what a fate!