Software
Houzz Logo Print
daylilyfanatic4

Hybridizing and Cold hardiness

17 years ago

HI I have a couple of questions if you don't mind.

First of all Is there any way for a home gardener to convert a diploid to a tetraploid? I know the pros expose the seedlings to chemicals and then the seedlings from those parents wil be tetraploid.

My second question has to do with Raspberry pixie. It's parentage is MINIATURE X MINATURE So I was wondering if I crossed Raspberry pixie X Raspberry pixie if I would get MINATURE since it is a F1 hybrid.

MY last question is if EYE -YI-YI is hardy in zone 6 NY (it's an evergreen) I don't really care if the folige gets a bit ragged just as long as it grows out of it in spring. I am fairly close to the border with zone 7 and although we often have some snow cover it is not reliable.

Thanks a lot Jeremy

Comments (23)

  • 17 years ago

    I can only respond to the first part of your question, and that only indirectly. I was curious about tet conversion and did some research into the area to see just how difficult it was.
    From everything I read I found the following:
    a) The chemicals are highly toxic. The word "carcinogenic" was associated with these in most of the articles I read.
    b) The recommendation was that this be attempted only in laboratory conditions by people who know what they are doing.
    Having said that, I also have to add that I did find a site that was an account, with pics, of a workshop where people were invited to bring plants they wanted to convert, and everyone performed the operation under the guidance of a well-known hybridizer.

  • 17 years ago

    HI, I wasn't reallyplanning on using the chemicals that hybridizers use, I was thinking more ofa household solution but i guess none exists,

    thank you so much

  • 17 years ago

    I have used colchicine to try to convert diploid seeds into tets. I can get them to absorb the colchicine, but I have never been able to get them to start growing again afterwards.

    I wear rubber gloves when I handle the colchicine solution and the seeds, and I've never had an issue. I make soap too, and people freak out when they find out that I work with lye. It's like anything-- you have to respect what you are working with.

    If you are friendly with your doctor, just have him write you a prescription for colchicine. He will probably look at you funny when you tell him what you are doing with it, but it's just too weird of a story to be made up! LOL!

    I was going to attempt to convert a diploid scape to get tet pollen, but we moved then and I didn't get a chance. I may try it this summer, and I'd like to attempt to convert a diploid plant as well. Just haven't gotten there yet.

  • 17 years ago

    I've worked with converting dips using the specialty herbicide Surflan. What success this project produces is out growing in the garden... we'll see next summer. One has flowered and some of the pollen grains under a microscope look large enough to be tetraploid. Time will tell if this pollen sets any seeds....

    Converting dips is an expensive proposition.. given the number of unsuccessful outcomes and the cost of the original stock often rendered to compost. It is far more cost effective to buy the F1's from a hybridizer.. the best outcomes of their use of the converted plants. Converted plants most often are dominant breeders... of all their characters... desireable and not so desireable.

    Tet Siloam Gumdrop is one I'd suggest.. brings hardiness, color clarity and decent scape genetics into a cross while being readily pod fertile. IMO a nice podder to set some of your fancy pollen on... I've used it sparingly as space is short here. I have one six inch flower from it via a short cross.... the converted version is taller here also than the reg height. I believe I saw some listed on the LA.

    {{gwi:647979}}

  • 17 years ago

    1. Colchicine treatment of the crown has proved to be the most successful and probably the simplest way to convert diploid daylilies to tetraploid. Method employs colchicine and DMSO, which should be used properly. Anyone passing a chemistry lab should be able to use them safely. You can Goggle the Patriot Daylily Society and look for their article for Colchicine Conversion by George Doorakian. There was also a VHS tape at one time, available through AHS on a clinic put on by Ted Petit. According to Ted, about 1/3 attempts are successful if done properly. You will need a microscope with a measuring graticule to verify pollen ploidy.

    2. A cross of F1's, according to Mendel genetics, will produce 75% offspring with the dominant traits of the parents. 25% will express recessive genes.

    3. Can't help with this one.
    Ed

  • 17 years ago

    "2. A cross of F1's, according to Mendel genetics, will produce 75% offspring with the dominant traits of the parents. 25% will express recessive genes." writes Ed.

    Ed do you think Mendel ever worked with tetraploids? :)

    "According to Ted, about 1/3 attempts are successful if done properly" again Ed.

    That is one outstanding overall average.. if that is indeed verifiable. I've spoke with 3 hybridizers who do allot of conversions.. they report on some they'll try 20 crowns and nothing. Then on others the rate might go 50%.. as it seems each plant reacts differently to the process.

  • 17 years ago

    Mendel developed his theories working with sweet peas. I don't know what ploidy they are, but suspect diploid with a lower chromosome count than daylilies probably. Still the math will hold. Tets just give you more variety in their dominant and recessive genes.

    On the VHS tape, Ted Petit states that you should expect around 1/3 attempts to be successful, 1/3 nothing will happen and the remaining 1/3, you will kill the plant. I have heard that some plants are very difficult to convert. I did meet Don Eller of Eller's Sunshine Gardens last year. He claims to do lots of conversions each year and with a better success rate than Ted's claim. I think it has lots to do with technique. From the figures you site for successful conversion, 25% is pretty close to 33%. Too close to argue about.
    Ed

  • 17 years ago

    This sight gives a decent explainer of what I was referring to per genetics.. the link below.

    Who's arguing :). Simple fact is no objective data is taken per a success rate via conversions. It's much more cost effective for the 99.9% of those growing out daylilies to buy the F1's.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Daylily Genetics

  • 17 years ago

    Good job on the site, except the conversion information is not current.

    True, you won't be able to verify the success rate of conversions any time soon. The ability to successfully convert something is like a corporate secret and not divulged till its breeding potential has been depleted.

    Osie Whatley used to sell conversion kits that included everything you needed to attempt a conversion. Too bad you can no longer get them. It makes it harder for the average Joe to come up with something unique.
    Ed

  • 17 years ago

    "Osie Whatley used to sell conversion kits that included everything you needed to attempt a conversion. Too bad you can no longer get them. It makes it harder for the average Joe to come up with something unique" writes Ed.

    Yes Oscie did for some time.. I wonder if anyone has his instructions for that kit around anywhere??

    IMO the real problem is the lack of high quality diploids to convert. Some odd duck pattern feature isn't often much of a total package. Especially far north.. we pay for tenderness being infused for generations via soft offsring in the cold.

    6F at crown level on my bare ground checking station southside of the house no less. Southside warms via the refracted sunlight off this white house.

  • 17 years ago

    My apologies to Oscie.

    Oscie left lots of conversion information in his 'Art of Hybridizing' Series published in the Daylily Journal and it's online somewhere too. Pat Stamile published conversion instructions at one time. He'd probably have a spare.

    Sounds like there is a need for diploid hybridizing up your way. I'll look forward to seeing some seedlings! ;0)

    I don't understand how people exist at temperatures below freezing. Not me!
    Ed

  • 17 years ago

    The "Art Of Hybridizing" series can be found on the AHS website. MIKE.
    http://www.daylilies.org/AHSArchives.html

  • 17 years ago

    "My apologies to Oscie".. Ed wrote. Just a typo I knew.. I type poorly myself.

    "Sounds like there is a need for diploid hybridizing up your way. I'll look forward to seeing some seedlings!" Here's one below.. yet I don't have the room myself to do dips in any significant way. SURE need one far north.. might well be some doing such.. I am just not aware of them.

    "I don't understand how people exist at temperatures below freezing. Not me!" writes Ed.

    BELOW freezing.. I like to say it was 17 feet below ZERO around here this morn. In fact the airport showed -17F...... My response to the cold is HOW in the heck do you southerners stand 4-7 months of being roasted.. :) One can put clothes on to stand cold... there's a limit the other way... :)

    {{gwi:647980}}

    I set this cross info out for all..... these came from a very short row.. <20 plants.

  • 17 years ago

    "One can put clothes on to stand cold... there's a limit the other way... :)"
    That's why we have air-conditioning, though the alternative is not always bad! ;0)

    Beautiful seedlings. I hope you cross the two of them. The 7" one has a better edge than lots of tets.
    Good work,
    Ed

  • 17 years ago

    Thank you both for posting this conversation. I've enjoyed following it.

    Northerndaylily, Your dipliod seedlings look like they has some Jack Carpenter lines behind them?

    I'm also interested in crossing the dip/tet boundary (unless someone can point me to a diploid with that metalic gold edge you see in tet's?)

    I have small children in the house so don't want to risk having the chemicals around.

    I read in the early years of iris several dedicated hybridizers made many long crosses with naturally occuring tet's to cross the boundary. I know it takes longer but is also safer.

    What options are there along this line for daylilies? There are plants like Ed Murray, for example, that are supposed to occasionally help cross the boundary but I'm not sure the details if it is by accepting diploid pollen or if they will pollinate diploids to produce some tet offspring with unreduced gametes.

    Does it matter which ploidy is used for pod or pollen parent when attempting this?

    Can either of you shed more light on the details of crossing the boundary naturally?

    I think another option is to find someone who will attempt the conversions for you. I've heard of people doing that. Any ideas who and what they might charge?

  • 17 years ago

    berrytea4me,

    If you hang around these forums long enough, you will see lots of claims that certain plants freely cross with higher or lower ploidy forms. It is accepted that given enough gametes, one will have unreduced chromosomes naturally. The unreduced gamete may be either seed or pollen.

    If you wish to try for a natural cross ploidy pollination, I suggest you be very careful and eliminate the chance of outside pollinators helping you. Remove the petals and stamen from flowers you pollinate and cover the stigma after pollination. Keep good records and persist if you want to succeed. A good amount of luck is also needed.

    'Ed Murray' is often cited as a plant to prove the above is possible. If you examine its pollen under the microscope, you will see a portion of its pollen is comparatively, extremely large, and it is thought that these large pollen grains are tetraploid or at least unreduced. There are stories that 'Ed Murray' was treated for conversion, not sure which method was used, and that what exists is a stable chimera. I find this very plausible, as I have seen the same thing occur in the conversions I have attempted.

    There is a gentleman in Virginia, I believe, that advertises in the Daylily Journal, that will attempt a conversion for you. As I recall, you send him two plants and he will attempt the conversion for $150.00, with no guarantee of success. However, his record is pretty good. There are also a couple of others that provide the service and if you are serious about it, email me and I will give you their names.
    Ed

  • 17 years ago

    Stephen Zolock also wrote an interesting arcticle on converting daylilies and hosta.

    Linda

    Here is a link that might be useful: Steven Zolock article

  • 17 years ago

    Thank you, Ed. I'd like to spend some time exploring natural tetraploid for a little while before I decide to pay for a conversion attempt. I would like to put those names in my database though for future reference. I'll mail you privately.

    Here's an example of somebody working with Ed Murray. Nick Chase has a tet out of h. fulva 'Europa' x Ed Murray (pod parent listed first- I always get the convention mixed up). I was curious that he got 'Europe' to set pod. I've only heard that its pollen would sometimes work on other plants if one were persistent enough. I'm also curious about the differences one might experience with this triploid x tetraploid versus diploid x tetraploid. Does the triploid give a better success rate?

    The links aren't working for me right now but did earlier today. Server issues probably. But there is a link to Nick's work on the top navigation bar of this page.

    I've heard that Mary Todd may also have unreduced gametes. Are there others that are well known?

    Here is a link that might be useful: Partridge Hill Gardens

  • 17 years ago

    berrytea4me,
    I think the most favorable of all these unlikely scenarios is the unreduced gametes diploid X tetraploid cross and the reverse.

    I would also point out that one could probably achieve their goals in tetraploid X tetraploid crosses before having any success with the unreduced gametes diploid X tetraploid cross.

    There have been claims that 'Ice Carnival' also freely crosses with tets. I think this would be a good topic for another thread. Diploids that cross easily with tetraploids.
    Ed

  • 17 years ago

    berrytea4me,
    Here's a link to Mary Ann's site in which she studies some of the claims for unreduced gametes.

    It should be noted that in the early days of colchicine treatment, typically the seed was treated. If the seedling was registered, its parents were listed as diploid, even though the seedling was tetraploid. There was considerable animosity among diploid fanciers and tetraploid fanciers, so facts were not always communicated nor recorded.
    Ed

    Here is a link that might be useful: The Quest for unreduced Gametes

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks, Ed. Lots of good information there. Looks like Mary Ann looked at Nick Chase's work too but lost touch before getting results on the seedlings.

    I think the information she was looking for is on his new website but they had a server crash and it is not all the way back up yet.

    At any rate, I was given his current contact information and have sent a query for more information.

    Linda, That Steve Zolack article is great too. Thanks for sharing it.

  • 17 years ago

    Just considering only the idea of cross polidy.. and unreduced gamates.

    Why? Other than the novelty of the idea.. what is gained? Mostly what is gained in some negative fertility issues in your genetics. While the idea sounds intriguing.. the net gain is a phantom.. and the time and energy involved is better used studying the genetics on hand and making sound choices with those parents.

    I can think offhand of one plant billed to be the result of one of these nearly impossible crosses. What is the demand for this plant? Minimal if any. What great features does this plant bring to the gene pool? Are there any.....? Maybe higher vigor.. yet that is easily attained the normal route. Flower quality certainly isn't....

    The other avenue is the odd duck offspring.. some weird or unusual feature not the norm resulting. Yet inbreeding is the tool for that quest.. selfing and full sib crossing. Yet by and large that route makes small rocks otta the whole.. fragmenting the inheritance... thus allowing for not nornally seen expressions. That route only avoids the hard realities of real hybridizing/breeding.. the time, work and intuition required to produce a high grade product.

  • 17 years ago

    northerndaylily, good questions but I think we should start a new thread for this topic. I'll get it going.