Software
Houzz Logo Print
token28001

USDA zone changes 1990-2006

17 years ago

For those of you that don't go into the wintersowing forum, here's something I found regarding US zones.

Animation page.

I'm now in zone 8? I don't want to be in zone 8. WAAAaaaaaa! 7 is the lucky number.

Comments (22)

  • 17 years ago

    Wow, I'm in zone 6 now. I'm gonna get me a palm tree.... :-P
    Kris

  • 17 years ago

    Just remember, the plants don't read maps. They can still die from sudden cold snaps.

  • 17 years ago

    Yeah, they re-arranged all of these a couple years or so ago. It reflects the changes in temps, locally. You will still be able to grow what you have - it changes how the hardiness of what you grow is regarded!!

    Nancy.

  • 17 years ago

    Remember that zone ratings only give you average highs and lows and don't take into account how fast the temps can swing, humidity, snow cover, etc.--all of which can affect whether any given plant can and will survive in your garden. My hero about zone ratings is Ellen Horning of Seneca Hill Perennials who speaks most eloquently of zone ratings and their inadequacies on
    on her website:

    We can repeat this rant until we're blue in the face: hardiness zones do not tell you most of what you need to know to grow many plants. For example, Syracuse, New York and Omaha, Nebraska, are both in zone 5. Are their growing conditions similar? Of course not. The totality of the growing climate, not just the winter low temperature, affects the plant's performance. Snow cover, soil type, presence of pathogens and predators, patterns of temperature change, patterns and amounts of rainfall, drainage, and other things all matter. Is there any simple way to summarize growing conditions? No. A good gardener experiments. A good gardener kills a lot of plants.

    To complicate matters, when you attempt to grow plants from ecosystems very different from your own (some of our South Africans, for example), it may be impossible to predict whether they will do well for you, because too little is known about their cultural requirements. Oswego does not much resemble the Drakensberg, but a lot of Drakensberg natives seem to like Oswego. Why? We aren't sure. Maybe we just have a magical mix of conditions. Doubtless you too have a magical mix of conditions, but perhaps it suits a different set of plants. You must be willing to experiment, because we simply cannot tell you whether any given plant will do well for you.

    The bottom line here is that we include hardiness zones largely to pander to popular prejudice and give you a small degree of guidance. The fact that your zone number is equal to or lower than the one given for a particular plant must not be construed as an assurance that this plant will grow for you.

  • 17 years ago

    I'm pretty sure my zone was changed from 7 to 8 but I still think of it as 7 to be on the safe side as the weather sure is unpredictable from one year to the next.

    Annette

  • 17 years ago

    The best plan is to look around you. We say, over and over, that zone 8 in the PNW, zone 8 in Texas and zone 8 in the deep south are not the same. The PNW does not have our summer heat and humidity. Much of Texas has alkaline soil vs. our acidity.

    "Average" temperatures for the 'new zone 8' won't mean much when that once every few years hard freeze comes where the thermometer falls to less than 5 degrees F. and less hardy azaleas and gardenias split their stems. Grow what is proven to thrive.

    Nell

  • 17 years ago

    And as for me, I will cling to my zone 9a until it freezes over. I usually only use it to give my kinfolks directions anyway.

    Janie

  • 17 years ago

    So now I'm zone 6, yippee! We'll see. I do have a few zone 6 things that have lasted, and I've also lost a few zone 6 things, so I'll gamble if it's not that expensive.

  • 17 years ago

    Well I did find out that the zone changes were not officially recognized by the USDA in 2006. They are working on a new map so don't believe that one just yet. And again, the best advice is to see what others in your area, not just zone, are able to grow. I would never try a palmetto tree from SC Zone 8 here. I know it wouldn't survive.

  • 17 years ago

    I'm pretty sure the climate changes ARE affecting zone designations, as I've kept good records about bloom time for over 20 years. Lilacs and irises, in particular, are blooming as much as ten days earlier than they used to...

    I remember an older woman once told me--while surveying the iris budding all over what used to be her childhood home, which I was renting while in grad school--"they always bloom at Decoration Day."

    The last few years--even though I now live at least 100 miles farther north than then---irises almost always bloom well before Memorial Day. Lilacs, too, used to grace the yards of my college town in central Iowa, AFTER exams were finished, even into the first few days of June.

    Now, the lilac flowers often are dried and brown by the time June arrives.

  • 17 years ago

    The bottom line on zones is not how early the weather warms, but the coldest winter temps an area can expect.

    The American Hort Society tried designating 'Heat Zones' a while back, but they didn't catch on. Continuous days of 100+ will affect plants differently than where the temp reaches 100 maybe once a summer. Factor in the humidity. Humidity in Atlanta and Athens, GA is not the humidity we experience down here near Florida.

    Sunset Zones make sense to me, but they are usually only used on the West Coast.

    The big trouble with trying to stretch your zone is, for me, the fact that a tropical plant will never act here as it does in areas with a warmer winter. My Mandevilla vine comes back eventually, every spring. It only gets blooming by late summer, hardly worth the wait for a lackluster performance.

    I could probably grow peonies if I'd go out timely and give them a daily bucket of ice. I would rather spend my energy on plants that are happy where they grow, blooming exuberantly instead of a tepid blossom or two that I can point to and say, "See, I CAN grow that!

    Nell

    P S Please. Don't mention my tulip mania. I only grow them as a scientific experiment. Yes, I've tried species tulips. They grew great foliage, every year.

  • 17 years ago

    That's true, Nell. I guess I was posting more about climate change, than zone change.

    However, that said, I also have been seeing a lot less winter-kill of my marginal zone 5 plants, over the past five years or so...Recently we've gone many, many years without any of our previously "normal" 20--25 below low temps.

    This year may do them in, though. However, as cold as its been, the thermometer still hasn't broken that deadly 20 below mark, yet.

    I wouldn't rush out and by any plants that are more than a half-zone (or a zone) out of my old designation, though. I'm not one for burning money. :-D

  • 17 years ago

    My Mandevilla vine comes back eventually, every spring. It only gets blooming by late summer, hardly worth the wait for a lackluster performance.


    I decided this year to see if my mandevilla will overwinter. If it doesn't, I did that cuttings that have rooted and have them in the basement. It's just too much trouble bringing plants in and out of the basement and making sure no critters get to them. That was my main issue with brugmansias. Now that I have a couple hardy ones, I can plant them in the yard this spring and let them fend for themselves. Of course, I'll still make cuttings each fall, but they're much easier to handle. Plus, I can trade them or sell them on eBay.

  • 17 years ago

    Token for more tender brugs, I have cut them back after they were frosted on and the limbs got droopy and then inverted a 5 gallon or so sized plant container filled with leaves over the stumps which were mulched with leaves. A brick or two on top of the bucket will make sure it doesn't blow off during the winter. This added insulation will bring any finicky brugs back each spring. The only issue I have with brugs is that ones planted in the ground take so long to get going while ones overwintered in an unheated garage in a pot and then taken back out start growing much faster since the soil in the container warms faster than the soil temps.

  • 17 years ago

    A lady down the street has a Charles Grimaldi. She cuts it down every fall and piles mulch on it. By the end of July, it's 6' tall and covered in blooms. Since July is so hot anyway, I figure if I have to wait til August to get blooms, I won't mind. They'll keep going like hers until mid November. By then, my nicotiana and other scented shrubs will be done. Not sure if I want to smell a brug, a tea olive, and a gardenia all at once.

    Any idea how the Kongmansia and Ecuador White will do here? I have rooted cuttings of both.

  • 17 years ago

    Not grown those varieties before. I have grown Dr. Seuss, Charles Grimaldi, and an unnamed pink and pale yellow variety. Charles Grimaldi has been my favorite so far.

  • 17 years ago

    Do you all have pics of how you integrate brugmansias into your landscape, or are they just stand-alone plants?

    I've only grown daturas and they are hard to place where they don't look like elephants among smaller plants.

    Nell

  • 17 years ago

    Nell,

    This will be my first year growing brugs. I plan to mix mine in with petunias, datura, and butterfly bushes. I was told to keep them away from nicotiana by a brug grower. Tomatoes are also supposed to be bad for them.

    These are my white ones. Still not sure what to do with the yellow and orange I have. May just trade or sell them in the spring.

    So if anyone has white brugs and wants what may or may not be a Charles Grimaldi or a NoID orange, let me know.

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks for the link. I had not thought about nicotiana and petunias transferring blight to brugs and daturas. I had petunias in the bed with a white datura, no problem.

    I bought seeds for a 'blackberry swirl' datura that is probably the purple and white I grew in 2007. My seeds mildewed that I saved, so didn't have it last year. I'm pondering what to plant with it. White snaps, tall white snaps for one. Palest yellow somethings.

    Nell

    Here is a link that might be useful: Past Datura Beds

  • 17 years ago

    Nell, here is a picture of a Dr. Seuss that I had a couple of years back until I got tired of brining the pot into the garage each winter.

    {{gwi:635972}}

    Here it is in the garage one winter.
    {{gwi:282114}}

    I lost quite a few of my older pictures of my brugs in beds back in 2004 when my computer crashed. The Charles Grimaldi I have now is in this bed. You can sort of see the blooms to the left of the big Zelkova tree and through the branches of the styrax tree. I tend to take loads of pictures of my clematis, but fail to do the same for the other flowers in the yard.

    {{gwi:558439}}

  • 17 years ago

    I'm still planning to plant my brugs, datura inoxia, and petunias in a single bed. Just not the one kongmansia I have left. The other cutting got to wet and rotted.

Sponsored