Software
Houzz Logo Print
bamateacha

Landscaping and Gardening

17 years ago

Probably a dumb question, but what's the difference between "landscaping" and "gardening?"

--Sharon

Comments (13)

  • 17 years ago

    I think of "landscaping" more of the job of a "contractor" type person who "installs" things like shrubs and grass for a job.
    Gardening to me is something that is done for the love of plants and planet.

  • 17 years ago

    I always refer to all the things that I consider landscaping as hardscaping. Planning where things are going to go, writing plans, Putting in shrubs and shrub rows, trees, walkways, all the things that will be permanent.

    I consider gardening the planning, buying and planting of seeds and plants that will go in various places in the yard to accent the hardscaped areas. Also, gardening could be considered the playground of gardeners ;)

    MeMo

  • 17 years ago

    Ya, after they go in with a bulldozer and destroy the beautiful ground and rip out all the natural trees, they come back in and plant little shrubs, grass and small exotic trees, perfectly spaced.

    Landscape companies also do terracing and fix drainage problems and things like that. That may also install pools and set in huge rocks and larger shrubs and trees - Big structural jobs that often require backhoes and 'dozers.

    Some landscape companies are actually commercial gardening services that plant seasonal flowers and do maintenance gardening for homes and business, municipalities and even churches. It sounds more sophisticated to call themselves a commercial landscape company rather than a commercial gardening business. ;)

  • 17 years ago

    Dunno but I consider landscaping to be the process of putting things together in an attractive manner. I cannot do this (no sense of color or design)

    I think of gardeners more as people who know the needs of plants such as sun, soil, nutrients. I cannot do this either because I am impatient and impulsive.

    I just like to play in the dirt. Plants just give me a reason to do it. So perhaps I am a cultivater... cultivator hmmmm dunno about the spelling. LOL

  • 17 years ago

    Very good question Sharon!
    To me landscaping feels cold, calculated, matter-of-fact-ly. Necessary in many cases. Like a surgery.
    Gardening is a play of one's heart, a dance, a joy, creating something beautiful and unique.

    ~Natalie

  • 17 years ago

    Timely question - I just finished reading "Grounds for Pleasure - 4 centuries of the American Garden", which is as close to a history of American gardens as exists, apparently. She discusses (among other fascinating things) the difference between a Landscape and a Garden, and that lots of landscape designers/landscape architects definitely differentiated between the two. The Landscape was generally the overall plan of an area with trees, a la Jens Jensen, where a garden was a more defined planting with a tighter focus - and that is especially where flower gardens where defined. (I feel like I am missing something in this explanation). But, a landscape focuses more on the space and the large effects, although it can also focus on things like how the trees look covered in snow, etc. It also focuses on the overall site issues, like drainage.

    My backyard is a garden, not a Landscape, fwiw.

    Both a landscape and a garden can have the same degree of heart and soul - or lack thereof, imho.

  • 17 years ago

    For me a landscape is constructed. A garden is born and raised by a gardener who then in turn gets nurtured by the garden.There was landscaping here when I move in 6 years ago but no garden. I like the foundation plantings in the front and I take care of them,but they are a part of the house not apart of me as the garden is.

  • 17 years ago

    delightp is exactly right. The landscaping is the plan. The gardening is taking care of the plants in that plan. You can't really have one without the other.

    Just because landscapers generally put in easy care plants for the general population doesn't mean they don't love gardening!

  • 17 years ago

    IMO: Landscaping is art; gardening is heart.

  • 17 years ago

    That was too simplistic. But it has a nice rhyme, doesn't it? ;-) I think Irene's right, that they both can show heart & soul.

    I like delightp's distinction: landscaping is the overall design, while gardening refers to everything that's involved in the growing of plants.

    Not a dumb question at all, Sharon.

  • 17 years ago

    Landscaping involves designing and altering the landscape. Adding plants to suit an overall design. Usually tradespeople can handle jobs like this - such as laying interlocking, laying down weeping tiles, creating ponds etc, build pergolas and decks. They can provide simpler designs. Landscape architects work with an overall design and oversee the work which is being handled by landscapers. For example Chicago's Millenium Garden was designed by garden designers in close cooperation with Landscape architects, or how about the gardens of the Getty Museum in Los Angeles..

    Gardeners are the ones who actually work the land, plant the plant, maintain it......

  • 17 years ago

    I think of landscaping as 'permanent placement' regardless of who designs and installs it.

    I think of gardening as planting, editing and grooming.

    Nell

  • 17 years ago

    landscaping = setting the dining room table
    gardening = cooking the meal

Sponsored