Software
Houzz Logo Print
maryl_gw

Given the choice question

Given the choice between wet clay soil or sandy dry soil which do you think daylilies would survive the best in? I realize seldom does one plot hold both soil types, but I was wondering if I had to err in planting which side would I choose - wet or dry?

Comments (14)

  • 19 years ago

    i would go for the sand and just water more!

  • 19 years ago

    Maryl,
    Living here in zone 5, I would choose wet clay, because that's exactly what I have!

    But seriously, I have found that daylilies need plenty of water during the first year they're planted. After that, they usually can withstand some drought conditions. I don't know about sandy soil. I'm sure someone else in your zone will advise you whether or not dry sandy soil is O.K.

    Happy gardening!

    Julie

  • 19 years ago

    Ha!
    I see I was typing a response while cody in MI posted an answer exactly the opposite of mine!

    A lot of help we are huh?;-)

    Julie

  • 19 years ago

    Wet clay - it usually has tons of nutrients in it. Sandy soil needs to be amended constantly plus as unending supply of water, which then proceeds to leach the nutrients to China.

    In my next life, I'm going to be a gardener in an area where it is the perfect sandy loam.

    Brooke

  • 19 years ago

    I have beach like sand and I would ammend the soil either way. Lighten up the clay so that it doesn't compact so hard(more for you than the plants), and add compost,etc.,to sand so it will have nutrients and hold the moisture long enough for the roots to take it in. I live on a lake, but pay by the foot for water. How ironic is that?!Bought the well pump 4 yrs ago. Maybe this year...

    Betsy

  • 19 years ago

    At my place we have clay with sand in it, its not dry sand like play sand though. We live close to a river. I have to add lots of crap to my siol, but the daylilies do fine. I noticed though when I got my daylilies from marietta that all of the leaves had lots of sand stuck between them, so they must have sandy soil there, and we know their daylilies do good. I imagine they would probably grow in anything besides a swamp with the proper love and care!

  • 19 years ago

    Id go with the dry sandy soil. I have daylilies coming up in a place that I never amended, never watered, and is dry as a bone right now, since we've had no rain in eons. Fans are up and gorgeous. Go figure.

  • 19 years ago

    I'm with Betsy and would try to amend the soil either way. I think the choice might also depend on your climate. Would crown rot be more of a problem in the South with wet clay?? I don't know.

    Charlie

  • 19 years ago

    Definitely dry sandy soil. I can always add water. I have fought clay for years and now use only raised beds, with sandy loam added. Plant roots need oxygen: wet clay and a little heat makes for crown rot down here.
    Ed

  • 19 years ago

    i think a lot of it depends on where you live. michigan is pretty sandy along the shoreline, but it was also covered by a glacier so a lot of the nutrients was left behind when it melted. i live 10 minutes from lake michigan and the sand dunes.

  • 19 years ago

    Opinions seem to learn towards: Clay bad - Sand Good. The crown rot issue and poor drainage was another thing I thought about in our hot/humid climate. I would think that the structure of a daylily root (rather fat roots) would mean it could stand drought much better then flooding. I wonder if the newer hybrids are more intolerant of growing conditions then the species. After all they were called "Ditch Lilies".

  • 19 years ago

    Newer hybrids are selected for pretty flowers, not growing conditions.

  • 19 years ago

    i had hard blue clay years ago, took all day to hand dig a 6x8 ft area.then i tried tillers the only one that worked was a mantis that has done wonders for my soil along with cow dung compost and top soil this area is excellent for my flowers and one area had a lot of sand i did the same to that side the plants do good but not as well as the clay.i also have a brook in my back yard and have some growing at waters edge.thay thrive there and when the brook floods out the plants go under water for a few days it does not harm the plants at all.

  • 19 years ago

    LOL!!! It appears it doesn't matter either way. Looks like everyone is split! I have the same issue, both sandy and clay. But unfortunantly its not in different areas. I have thick red clay, and it apears that the builders filled with sand on top of it!! Some places have several inches of sandy, and I recently decided to plant in an area I thought was all sand, but as soon as I tried to dig, found out that only 1/2in on top is sand/silt! I ammended where my daylilies are, lots of store baught topsoil mixed in w/ my crazy mixes! But the ones I didn't ammend, mostly sand, seem to be thriving. I haven't tried planting in just clay yet. Did dig a bed yesterday that was all clay. What a work out!! We'll see what happens there.

Sponsored
NME Builders LLC
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars2 Reviews
Remodeling Company in New Albany, Ohio