Software
Houzz Logo Print
sly33

2-1-6 Fertilizer

16 years ago

Hey All,

I ran into a free huge jug of 2-1-6 liquid fertilizer that they use for hydroponics called FloraGro?. Anyway, I was at a garden center and they had the other two types of Flora with different nutrient analysis that are part of the "3 Part Building Block System", or something like that.

Anyway, I mentioned to the clerk that I had this jug and that I was using it here and there sparingly. He said it was a big mistake and that I definitely needed the other two parts of the system to make the fertilizer "work". He told me to use it for my lawn or something.

I would be happy to get the other parts of the system but they were about $100 a piece so I said forget it.

Now, I usually use a 24-8-16 or a 12-4-8 for the figs, but can I get away with using this 2-1-6 in any way? What if I mix it or just use a little bit?

Isn't the 2-1-6 just another analysis like any other fertilizer?

Let me know what you think.

Thanks

Nas

Comments (57)

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Rather than respond, I'll ask the forum what I should do? There are multiple attacks again in Dan's retorts, and lots of misinformation/inconsistencies. I explained very clearly how and why it's advantageous to use fertilizers that provide nutrients in the same ratio that plants use them - especially in containers, which is what we're supposed to be talking about here, not someone's orchard or back yard. Why do we need to expand every thread for the sake of starting another argument? Scheesch! Too peaceful lately?

    Anyone that is capable of understanding 'Liebig's Law of the Minimum' (which I've explained several times) should clearly be able to see that there is no pet theory at work - but if there was, I'd be in very good company because EVERY commercial grower and propagator, that makes a living selling trees or greenhouse plants, and every plant science teacher pays very strict attention to nutrient ratios .... for more than one reason.

    Here it is again >>> Some of us are familiar with Liebig's Law, but it's a good thing to keep in mind as we approach our nutritional supplementation program: There are 6 factors that affect plant growth and yield; they are: air, water, light, temperature, soil or media, and nutrients.

    Liebig's Law of Limiting Factors states the most deficient factor limits plant growth and increasing the supply of non-limiting factors will not increase plant growth. (This means that having excess of any nutrient beyond what the plant can use in relation to the other nutrients is a negative) Only by increasing the most deficient factor will the plant growth increase. There is also an optimum combination of the factors, and increasing them individually or in various combinations can lead to toxicity for the plant and/or other growth-related problems.

    Anyone who thinks having more of any one element in the soil than necessary, or that concentrations in excess of what the plant will use in proportion to the other essential elements can create a growth advantage or is an optimal nutritional supplementation plan, will have to disprove Liebig's Law.

    Liebig's Law clearly states there is an optimum ratio of nutrient availability. NO ONE is naive enough to believe that the optimum ratio is 1:1:1 (as in 8-8-8, 10-10-10, etc). Thousands and thousands of scientists have accepted the fact that plants use nutrients in the NPK ratio of approximately 10:1.5:7, which (when factored by .43 for P and .83 for K because P is reported as phosphorous pentoxide and potassium as potassium oxide) comes out to almost exactly 3:1:2. It just happens that tissue analysis of all plants is also very close to a 3:1:2 RATIO of NPK.

    So does this musing seem logical?: Let me see .... plants' tissues contain NPK in approximately a 10:1.5:7 ratio, and they USE fertilizer nutrients in approximately a 3:1:2 ratio, which after adjusting for the factors comes out to
    10:1.5:6 ..... so I think I'll use 10-10-10. No - it does not seem logical; and if someone tells you this is wrong, they need to tell you exactly WHY it is wrong - not what someone else might think.

    So the forum understands - when I say someone is wrong, I don't just leave it at that, with no explanation or support for my statements, and I sure don't say, "Someone else is doing it this way and it seems to be working; therefore, you are wrong". I let you know exactly why that person is wrong.

    I have no problem talking about the chemistry of nutrition and soil chemistry if anyone wants to have a meaningful discussion and leave the sarcasm and attacks out of it. If "Something is OBVIOUSLY WRONG WITH THE NUTRIENT RATIO THEORY.......", then tell us what it is. But make sure you address the issues and include why you think Liebig's Law has absolutely no merit.

    Al

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    If your soil already has too much salt to allow native plants to grow even without fertilizer.....maybe it is better to grow your plants in a container. Trees need a certain number of pounds of each Macro nutrient for them to grow properly. You control the pounds of nutrients that are provided to your plants by the DOSAGE RATE of the fertilizer......not just by the CONCENTRATION or chemical ratios of those nutrients in the fertilizer. You can control the amount of salts that you are adding to your soil during fertilization by paying attention to the "dosage rate" and by only fertilizing your plants when they need it. In normal soils, fig trees simply do not need a lot of fertilizer. A young fig tree that does not grow at least a foot or two each year would benefit from some ALL PURPOSE fertilizer. 2-2-6 is a "specialty" fertilizer........you need an "all purpose" fertilizer to give your trees the macro nutrients and the trace elements that they need. An ALL PURPOSE fertilizer will state so on the label. All purpose fertilizers come in the 1:1:1 types (8-8-8 or 13-13-13), in the water soluble types (Miracle Grow), and in the slow release types (Osmocote). Some are recommend for "container" grown plants and some are definitely not.....read the label.

    I still would highly recommend that you get your ground soil tested. Their analysis and recommendations to you will be VERY SPECIFIC and will suggest a good fertilization schedule and correct dosage rate for your particular situation. Salts already present in your soil will be determined and any suggested fertilization program will take that into account. Soil testing by your coount agent should give you a clear path forward to growing fig trees in your particular area and soil type.

    Dan

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    WG - are you talking about trees planted out or trees in containers?

    "Trees need a certain number of pounds of each Macro nutrient for them to grow properly." Wouldn't that be a RATIO? It would be unless someone is suggesting they need the exact same amount of NPK to grow properly.

    Al

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I just ran across the internationally recognized French fig EXPERT.... Pierre Baud's fertilizer recommendations for fig trees. He specifically recommends a 1:2:3 type fertilizer for fig trees. I have attached a link below for you to see for yourself. The link below will open a page on his web site. It will need to be translated from French into English. Click on the sixth box down on the left side of the page that opens up from the below link. Next click on the "Congeils figuiers" (Fig tips) box and read his recommendations regarding fig tree nutrition.

    As you will see...... Baud states:
    "The fig tree is especially demanding in potash and does not require high doses of nitrogen fertilizer, causing it too intense vegetative development and an imbalance in growth and fruiting." Accordingly, he specifically recomends a 1:2:3 type of fertilizer.

    Anyone seriously doubt that P. Baud, who has already published a couple of books on fig culture and who has grown more fig varieties than anyone else, does not know what is best for his fig trees????? It is probable that he too would have a BIG PROBLEM with the aforementioned chemical "nutrient ratio" theory...... As I've stated earlier, whenever there is a conflict between a pet "theory" and real life data.......a real scientist WILL ALWAYS question the THEORY and not the real life data. When a theory doesn't measure up to real verifiable actual facts it becomes baloney........

    Dan

    Here is a link that might be useful: Baud on fertilizer for fig trees

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Scheesch! I guess that shoots your 8-8-8 and 13-13-13 'pet theory' right in the head, hmm? ;o) You could always invite him here to discuss the matter so you don't have to keep guessing at what someone else might think as the sole support for your suppositions.

    BTW - you've presented a plethora of suppositions and conjectures that fly in the face of reason, don't measure up to settled science, and aren't even logical; so it's far more likely they're baloney than some new discovery that will enlighten anyone. I'm not sure why you need to continually pursue this vendetta, never giving it a rest ..... for someone who has never yet been able to call on his own understanding of plants or the plant sciences (even while making repeated claims that he is a scientist) to support all these claims he's been making that have repeatedly been shown to be grievously in error, you're ridiculously aggressive. Don't you know that people can see you're operating at well beyond the limits of your knowledge?

    For someone who conveniently postures that he is taking the high road and not going to argue with a nit picker, just when hard questions for which he has no answers for are put to him, you're doing a pretty good job of looking for another argument. Instead of attacking me, try closing some of the huge holes I pointed to in any one of a dozen or more 'pet theories' you've postulated here.

    As I said before, just saying you're a scientist/chemist/physicist/fig researcher, and whatever other titles you appropriate for yourself doesn't make it so. If there's one thing that can be said about me, it's that I can put up when it's required, and you never ever have. Bluster, obfuscation, and personal attack have always been your hole cards. It continues today.

    Since you so regularly advise using 8-8-8 and 13-13-13 fertilizers in the face of your expert, perhaps you can tell us how you square that, AND how you personally decide whether to use the 8-8-8 or the 13-13-13 ..... or is that nit picking again? ;o)

    I try to avoid you as best I can, but your insulting sarcasm is everywhere. When are you going to give it a rest?

    Al

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I just happened to remember this, from another thread. It's written in English by an AMERICAN expert, and is something Dan chose to completely ignore. Strangely enough, he criticized me for quoting from a book.

    Dr. Carl Whitcomb (PhD), makes 11 key points in the preface to his opening chapter on Nutrition in Plant Production in Containers II. Point 1 is in regard to the small soil volume, so we'll skip it.

    2) "When other factors that can limit growth are not limiting, it is the combination and interaction of 12 nutrient elements that are responsible for energy production and growth in plants." This clearly illustrates that how elements are combined, their ratio to each other, is essential to optimal growth.

    3) "The more precisely the 12 essential nutrient elements are synchronized relative to plant needs, the more rapid growth occurs." Again, clearly stating that ratios are critically important to most rapid growth.

    4) "Excess of ANY nutrient, especially Nitrogen, is as undesirable as a deficiency." Again, this agrees completely with what I set forth above. These contextual points are found on the first page (212) of chapter 9 of Dr Whitcomb's text, referenced above.

    If that isn't sufficient support, Dr Whitcomb goes on to say in point 5 of 11

    5) "When Temperature, growth medium, moisture, drainage, and oxygen to the roots and all other factors are optimum or at least reasonable, all, or nearly all plants grow best with the same proportions of nutrients. Plants grow at different rates, but the rate of uptake and utilization of the 12 essential nutrients is the same." This clearly agrees with what I said about all plants using very close to the same ratio of nutrients.

    This isn't just some crackpot, offering an off the wall opinion that flies in the face of settled science. This is a PhD whose text is on the desk of practically every nurseryman and greenhouseman in the country. If what Dr Whitcomb offers isn't sufficient, I can offer another half dozen texts referencing plant production and fertility that also support the facts.

    I don't know how many times Dan is going to broaden the scope of a thread and take the discussion from one area (fertilizing figs in containers) and broaden it to including things like figs on the French hillsides so he can start another argument.

    Al

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The California master gardeners handbook says for most California soils the only nutrients you need to add are Nitrogen and Zinc. They already have enough of everything else.
    BTW, 2-1-6 sounds like a very diluted fertilizer, must be mostly water. Sounds like a rip off if it costs $30 a gallon.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Well, I read the French article and it was all Greek to me, as I didn't see anywhere I could click on to get it in English! I was able to interpret the amounts of the ferilizer, though. I'm just getting more and more confused about fertilizers all round because last year, I was at a feed store here and asked for a good fertilizer for figs and the man handed me some ferilizer with a higher nitrogen amount. I ended up not buying it because the Parish Extension recommends a straight 8 fertilizer for figs (This is for inground trees.). Several weeks later, I was at the garden of a retired USL/ULL (Univ. of Southwestern La., now University of Louisiana at Lafayette.) prof here, in Lafayette, who has a huge garden with all kinds of fruits and vegetables and he instructed me to give the figs a jolt of high nitrogen fertilizer in the Spring and I didn't know what to think after that and now, my head is REALLY spinning. I think he said to use ammonium nitrate. I can't find my notes! I'll have to go back to him and risk his wrath, bite the bullet and beg him to tell me again, then duck and run. :)

    I'm killing my baby trees just fine all by myself and I think fertilizer won't hurt them any more than I have already, although I'm probably wrong about that, too! I need to decide upon a container fertilizer and an inground fertilizer soon before the plants all starve to death!

    Dan, Al, I like both of you guys and think you each have a lot of knowledge to impart to people and are more than willing to do so. I've already learned a lot, after the fact and will learn more as time goes by.

    For two years in a row, my husband put weed and feed on our lawn where the Celestes were. It made their leaves wilt back for a few days and then the nitrogen hit them and they went crazy and shot up out of control (I gotta love those gals!) Mike didn't understand the root system of the figs and wouldn't believe me. I suppose that's why I've been hesitant about putting a higher N fertilizer on the figs. Is the 3:1:2 ratio a new thing? The inground Celeste, as well as the Celeste in the frame whose bottom is open to the ground, have grown two feet already and are still growing. The branches are "leggy" rather than stocky. What does that signify, if anything? They have figlets all over them.

    Y'all--don't fuss at each other. Please make this a discussion because it's important to get input from both of you. This is a semi-tropical climate down here, so could different rules apply to inground figs? I would imagine that container figs would have the same needs anywhere.

    For what it's worth, there are people who really are intellectual snobs who really do think that people down here couldn't possibly have anything to contribute. I've heard them with my own ears.

    Y'all can butt heads from now until doomsday and it's not going to help anything, but somehow, it is making you both more real to me and I'm getting more and more tickled with you and liking you more and more. Go figure. Now you both will probably go and get mad at me!

    Love yas!

    noss

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Now I know the readers of this forum are truly sick and tired of the in-fighting to prove who is right and who is wrong. For the life of me do not know why....and that's not important. I think you guys (Al and Dan)are taking comments too personal. You are forgetting about why people come to these forums. We come here to learn, communicate, and meet people. That's what its all about! Life is about relationships.

    We all have different opinions....its human nature. So, lets just accept the fact that every one may not agree with another persons recommendations or comments.....its OK, let it go....let's be friends and move on. All these petty jabs at each other is just out right childish and embarrassing. Let's not run people away. Let's welcome them with what we've learned and thank them for the willingness to learn. Thanks, I'll get off my soap box now. Dennis

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    C'mon guys - Dan's sarcasm and continued snide remarks are all over this forum, while I try my best to steer clear of him and ignore most of it.

    FWIW - I already said several times that what you use on trees in the ground is less important than what you use on trees in containers. Some of you may remember my mentioning "W/o a soil test, anything you use on trees in the ground is going to be a shotgun approach and one fertilizer is as good as another; but it does make more sense to supply nutrients in the same ratio used by plants". I then went on to clearly explain why that is so.

    Container media supplies so very little nutrition that you can essentially consider it nearly inconsequential in it's ability to deliver nutrients. For that reason, and because of the small amount of soil volume, small amounts of fertilizer have larger effects in containers, so it makes perfect sense to supply nutrients in the ratio in which plants use them. Why did Dan find it necessary to dredge up an age old argument and broaden yet another discussion about containerized trees to include trees in the ground in France?

    As far as application goes, there are probably thousands of people here on GW alone that are using the 3:1:2 ratio fertilizer on all their container plants. If you want to see real testimony based on real application of 3:1:2 ratio fertilizers for container plants and trees, stop over at the Container Forum and I'll introduce you to a very large group of users.

    Dan quotes little snippets of science when he finds something that suits his purposes, but when it comes to entering a discussion based on anything scientific, he ignores the body whole (of science) and turns to his regular tactics of attacking, belittlement, and obfuscation. How can anyone claiming to be a scientist totally ignore anything scientifically presented and backed with references and disagree - often based only on what HE thinks someone else MIGHT think? That is not the mark of someone in command of the knowledge needed to be operating where Dan continually goes.

    As an example. Dan stated "Those eggshells are a great source of calcium carbonate and will not cause any harm to your trees.....only benefits." I look at that statement and think to myself, "Would a scientist ever say that?" and the answer is "NO". First, calcium carbonate is virtually insoluble in water. That aside, anyone that knows a little about plants knows that the only time it can do any good is if there is a deficiency of Ca in the soil to begin with. Adding Ca beyond the plant's needs has a deleterious effect on growth. (see #4 in a post a little upthread: 4) "Excess of ANY nutrient, especially Nitrogen, is as undesirable as a deficiency." That, from Dr C Whitcomb, PhD. So you see, if CaCO3 is not soluble, it can do no good (nutritionally speaking); if it is (marginally) soluble, it can be over applied, like any other nutrient, and do harm.

    You guys can SEE my other posts and can see that I don't continually roil the water with sarcasm and obvious barbs aimed at Dan. I try to rely on science and reason to make my points, but there never comes a reply that faces the topic head on. I'd love to be able to discuss any aspect of husbandry with Dan, and I'm completely capable of sticking to facts and science, but it takes two to have that kind of discussion.

    Of the hundreds of people who read my posts every day at GW, there is only 1 person who finds it necessary to attack me unprovoked and argue about everything, yet back nothing. I don't need to drag anyone into a fray to enjoy myself here - not my MO.

    Al

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks for the continued explanation of fertilizer science, Al.
    If anyone's a scientist here, I'd say it is you.

    Josh

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Lets just relax and enjoy the great postings. I use a little of this and a little of that. And guess what! My figs are doing great, healthy and very productive.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I thoroughly enjoy the tips and knowledge from both Al and Dan. I've learned a lot from what both have recommended. I just feel sad when I read the jabs. I would like to see the day when both Dan and Al get together propagate and grow 1 bean. Think of it! It would be one heck of a bean stalk!

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Two (castor)beanstalks - May 15 - mid-Aug from seed: ;o)
    {{gwi:3277}}

    Al

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Al. I loved your photo. I never tried growing (castor)beanstalks those are so pretty. Thanks for sharing it. I need to look at growing this myself.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I followed Al's method over the winter, and I now have a blooming Castor Bean 'Impala.'
    It has been grown in a container with about half the volume of a typical soda can.
    The only fertilizer that I've used on the Castor Bean has been Foliage Pro 9-3-6.
    I took Al's information, and put it to the test. I've taken it from theory to practice.
    I challenge others to succeed the same.

    Josh

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Well said Josh. :)

    Al~ Awsome plant! My yard's not big enough for one of those.. LOL!

    JoJo

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Very nice pic Al That landscaping looks great.
    Sal

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thank you guys ..... for the very kind words. They are always very appreciated. ;o)

    Al

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Al says......"Since you so regularly advise using 8-8-8 and 13-13-13 fertilizers in the face of your expert, perhaps you can tell us how you square that, AND how you personally decide whether to use the 8-8-8 or the 13-13-13 ..... or is that nit picking again? ;o)"

    I use 8-8-8 on my younger in-ground trees and 13-13-13 on my larger in-ground trees. There is more nitrogen (and other nutrients) in a pint of 13-13-13 than there is in an equal pint of 8-8-8 fertilizer. I simply adjust the "dosage" rate according to the strength of the fertilizer. One pound of an 8-8-8 fertilizer contains the exact same amount of nutrients as does 0.62 pounds of a 13-13-13 fertilizer. For my containerized figs, I use both Miracle Grow and Osmocote. Also, see the last paragraph below in answer to the other part of your question........

    For information only..... I did not respond to Al's post in another thread regarding the Cation Exchange Capacity (CEC) of a potting soil. I did not want to be confusing to the Frenchman on that thread. However, there is more to choosing the right fertilizer for containerized figs than the CEC of its potting soil. It also depends on the "ANION" Exchange Capacity (AEC) of the potting soil. This is because a significant proportion of a soluble fertilizer (such as Miracle Grow) is tied up in the anionic chemical form. The anions too can be wasted if one is using too sterile a potting soil. For that reason; if I were to grow my figs in containers only, I would definitely use a slow release fertilizer (Osmocote) EARLY in the season along with a regular regimen of a MG soluble type fertilizer.

    Al says......"Why did Dan find it necessary to dredge up an age old argument and broaden yet another discussion about containerized trees to include trees in the ground in France"..............

    Because it is SPECFICALLY RELEVANT to the subject matter of this particular thread.....that's why. Sly33's 2:1:6 (or 1:.5:3) ratio fertilizer is PRETTY DARN CLOSE to chemical ratio of the 1:2:3 fertilizer that Baud recommends. Baud is an authority on the cultivation of figs and operates several Nurseries in France which sell quite a few containerized figs. His recommendations carry significant weight and his ideas were not created in a vacuum...but, come from his many years of propagating and growing figs. My last post is relevant to the subject matter of this thread.

    Too, I am tired of hearing about a nutrient ratio theory that simply flies in the face of field observations of many fig growers. That theory has some problems explaining why many growers obtain EXCELLENT results when using other fertilizers. Their trees do not get yellow from a calcium deficiency. Their trees do not go thirsty from too high an EC/TDS level. Rather, their fig trees thrive and remain productive. Al CLAIMS this theory is based on FACTS and that his claims are based on science. Well........is it??? I am calling on Al to back up his "assertions" on the N:P:K analysis for fig plant material.....i.e. please provide the analytical source data upon which this Nutrient Ratio Theory is based. Please provide us with the actual chemical analysis of fig leaves, fig fruit, fig wood, and fig roots. If you can't provide that raw data, then your pet theory is just a BELIEF that simply is not supported by scientific data as claimed.

    As a analytical chemist, familiar with both the chemical and physical testing of all sorts of materials (matter), I do not believe that the N:P:K data (or nutrient ratio) is the same for each of the parts of a fig tree. In fact, I would be willing to bet that the chemical ratio is quite different in each of these plant parts. New green growth is stimulated by a high nitrogen fertilizer. It would be counter intuitive to not see a higher level of nitrogen in the figs leaves than in other parts of the tree. Same with the other macro nutrients Phosphorus, and Potassium. But, who knows......I'll wait to see Al's data. I seem to recall Al only "INFERRED" his nutrient ratio applicability to fig trees from some vague reference to the testing of some other plant species. In science, INFERRED data is often pure BALONEY....especially when it does not agree with actual EMPERICAL data (i.e. data and observations collected by many fig growers and experts).

    Al, how about you backing up your claims with some real measured N:P:K analytical data??? Given the way you cling to that theory and bring it up so often, surely you have that data ready at hand.

    Bottom line........
    As I stated several times in this and in other threads, it is BOTH the chemical and "PHYSICAL" properties of a fertilizer that determines its suitability. It is really not that difficult to choose the right fertilizer for one's fig trees........

    "Read the label and pay attention to the instructions given on any fertilizer and you should not have any problems with its usage. There is nothing magical about nutrient "ratios" and you sure don't need a calculator when you buy fertilizer. What matters most is the physical properties of the fertilizer itself and whether or not you are growing in the ground or in a container........and the dosage rate."

    Dan

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I guess it's been too peaceful around here again for the last week or so. By way of explanation to the forum: It's not my theory, and whether or not Dan believes it is inconsequential. The information is published in hundreds of books written by people far more educated, intelligent, and capable than either Dan or I - by true plant researchers and scientists. I've referenced these books and quoted from them numerous times in support of the things I've offered, and nothing has been refuted - only ignored or disagreed with and no support offered. You can decide for yourselves whether or not figs in the French countryside are pertinent to Sly's question about containerized figs and whether a 2-1-6 fertilizer is appropriate.

    I've always been very cautious about making sure the information I share is accurate, and I'm familiar enough with what I talk about that I can qualify things when necessary to (hopefully) avoid confusing you. I've backed everything I've offered to the Nth degree, so you can decide what makes sense - something carefully explained, supported, and entirely logical, or the assertions of a lone voice in conflict with hundreds of degreed scientists.

    If Dr Whitcomb and a dozen other authors whose books I reference frequently say that the tissue analysis of all plants is extremely close to the same; and if greenhouse and nursery production operations adjust their fertigation systems based on tissue analysis to reflect increases and decreases of nutrients necessary to maintain the best health and growth; and the target nutrient ratio supplied is usually extremely close to 3:1:2, unless N is intentionally being manipulated to bring on for sale sexually mature plants that are short and bushy, that's good enough for me.

    Tissue analysis of fig tree organs will fall within the ranges shown on this chart. If Dan doesn't believe it, then he can do his own research and show me the error of my ways. ;o)

    N 100
    P 13-19 (16) 1/6
    K 45-80 (62) 3/5
    S 6-9 (8) 1/12
    Mg 5-15 (10) 1/10
    Ca 5-15 (10) 1/10
    Fe 0.7
    Mn 0.4
    B(oron) 0.2
    Zn 0.06
    Cu 0.03
    Cl 0.03
    Mo(lybdenum) 0.003

    For every 100 parts of N there will be 13-19 parts of P for an average of about 16 parts or 1/6 as much P as N ..... and so on.

    I didn't just make this up. ;o) This is ALL basic plant science. I have at least 15 texts aimed at the technical aspects of plant production and problem resolution of plants in production, and they vary very little in the areas in which they overlap - and one of the areas that gets a LOT of attention is, as you might expect, nutrition.

    I've been growing plants in the ground and in containers for more than 30 years, and teaching people how to improve their skills for half that time. I've given hundreds of talks/demos/workshops, and many of them had degreed horticulturists and even a few arborists in the audience .... and I've never had a significant disagreement with any of them. You can believe that if any of them thought I was misleading anyone, they would have approached me, and resolution would have come from the discussion.

    BTW - it looks like most of the most respected growers on this and on the container gardening forum are using 3:1:2 ratios.

    Take care.

    Al

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Al~

    FWIW,
    Many of us continue to learn from you, while you go in circles with others.

    Your plants/trees, and those of the many following your advice are more than enough for new growers like me to take note of what you say.

    JJ

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Al.....the bottom line is that you cannot provide the data that I have requested and your nutrient ratio theory has some significant flaws in it. It is not as scientific based as you think. I could go on and poke more holes in it; but, that is not my intent. My intent is to inform members on this forum that they might get better performance using other fertilizers. Performance that is measured by increased productivity and not just pretty trees.

    Al says......"BTW - it looks like most of the most respected growers on this and on the container gardening forum are using 3:1:2 ratios."

    Well that does not mean they wouldn't see some IMPROVED benefits from the use of other fertilizers. Baud and LSU are very knowledgeable and EXPERTS on FIGS. As I've stated before, LSU has been growing and studying figs for well over a hundred years. They have accumulated a vast KNOWLEDGE base on its cultivation. Here is a relevant snippet of what their experts have to say from one of their PUBLICATIONS ON FIGS.....pay special attention to what I have CAPITALIZED. This may have SIGNIFICANT RELEVANCE to all forum members who grow figs in a COLDER climate. No one has surfaced this issue on either forum before.......likely because they would have been shouted down by Al. I have no such fear. This deserves discussion and is an interesting "fertile" RESEARCH area for you Northern growers.

    ["Cultural Practices and Fertilization of Figs for Commercial and Home Production:

    Shallow cultivation is recommended to control weeds
    and grasses. A thick layer of hay or straw mulch will help to eliminate unwanted vegetation and conserve soil moisture. Nematode damage appears to be less important where trees are mulched. In addition, mulches help maintain desirable soil temperature and aeration. The fig is well suited to this practice, since roots are shallow in most soils. Never cultivate deeply around figs.
    A general fertilizer recommendation is 1 pound of 8-8-
    8 per year of age of the tree up to 10 years old. This
    maximum of 10 pounds should be continued for trees 10 or
    more years old. Apply fertilizer in late winter or early
    spring. A good indication of the need for fertilizer is the
    amount of shoot growth obtained. A satisfactory amount of
    shoot growth is 1 to 1 1/2 feet per year. ONE COMMON CASE OF FRUIT NOT MATURING ON FIG TREES IS OVERFERTILIZATION OF USING NITROGEN FERTILIZER (AKA a 3:1;2 type????). Four to 6 inches of mulch and regular watering will often produce adequate growth of trees without sacrificing yield and quality. Do not fertilize trees in late summer, since succulent growth is more susceptible to cold injury. Vigorous late-season growth is not desirable. Figs are shallow-rooted and often come under stress during dry periods. The Celeste variety, in particular, drops early fruit after spring droughts. Late summer droughts may
    cause early defoliation and induce dormancy. Regular
    irrigation is CRITICAL in producing quality fruit. Extremely late irrigation promotes succulent growth going into the winter and can cause the tree to be more susceptible to cold weather injury. It should be avoided."]

    Note that the above is a direct quote from the real fig experts at LSU.....not me. Notice that the information is directed to both COMMERCIAL producers of figs and to the Home Gardener. Production is important to many commercial growers in Louisiana. Dr. O'Rourke bred his figs at LSU for increased PRODUCTION.

    Those of you "respected" forum members who try to grow figs in a short season should take heed to what the LSU experts have to say. That 3:1:2 ratio fertilizer may well have too high a nitrogen content that causes your fig fruit to be DELAYED in ripening its fruit. If your goal is to ripen more figs, then you might consider reducing the nitrogen content of your fertilizer. Both LSU and Baud know a few things about growing figs and do not make such recommendations in a vacuum.

    Bottom line......

    It is HIGHLY LIKELY that using a lower nitrogen content fertilizer will cause more figs to ripen for you forum members growing figs in a SHORT season. If I grew containerized figs in a colder climate like yours, I definitely would take Baud's and LSU's advice and lower the nitrogen content of my fertilizer. I would practice "pinching" too.

    This is a very valid viewpoint and I am suggesting it to forum members for their consideration......not to be "inflammatory"......but, to perhaps open another area of fig research. I am a dedicated fig researcher. My viewpoint is valid and I'm sorry if it conflicts with others.

    I've attached a link to the LSU fig publication should anyone care to see what REAL FIG EXPERTS have to say. Those of you who have green figs left on your trees in the fall and are seeking ways to have them ripen sooner should give consideration to lowering the nitrogen ratio of your fertilizer. I hope that someone gives it a try and reports back to this thread.

    Dan

    Here is a link that might be useful: LSU's Publication on FIGS

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Dan - I quoted verbatim, sources from current university level texts that support what I said - several times, but you conveniently side-step that or ignore it. Once again - this thread is about fertilizing trees in containers, and that is where I centered my discussion - on topic; but you find it necessary to drag in-ground trees into the discussion on this threads and at every turn, when containerized plants are the topic. You just like strife.

    I already allowed early in this thread, and in others before this discussion, that it is less important what ratios you use on in-ground trees, though I built a very strong case that fertilizing at the same ratio in which plants use nutrients is desirable.

    I also discussed the efficacy of reducing nitrogen supplied to trees once they have reached the size the grower prefers, so it's not as though I'm ignorant of manipulations of N to achieve an end, or that I just missed it. You probably ignored that, too. If you remember, I also discussed such manipulation when I contrasted the 2:1:2 ratio greenhouse growers often employ to produce stout and sexually mature plants for the market with the 3:1:2 ratio normally used for nursery and plants grown for foliage; this, in illustrating that nutrient ratios ARE important.

    This stuff has all been researched and practically applied to figs and hundreds of other plants alike, so there is no need to lay claim to the credit for breaking new ground should you decide to embark on more "research".

    If you want to be a hero, refute this:

    Dr. Carl Whitcomb (PhD), makes 11 key points in the preface to his opening chapter on Nutrition in Plant Production in Containers II. Point 1 is in regard to the small soil volume, so we'll skip it.

    2) "When other factors that can limit growth are not limiting, it is the combination and interaction of 12 nutrient elements that are responsible for energy production and growth in plants." This clearly illustrates that how elements are combined, their ratio to each other, is essential to optimal growth.

    3) "The more precisely the 12 essential nutrient elements are synchronized relative to plant needs, the more rapid growth occurs." Again, clearly stating that ratios are critically important to most rapid growth.

    4) "Excess of ANY nutrient, especially Nitrogen, is as undesirable as a deficiency." Again, this agrees completely with what I set forth above. These contextual points are found on the first page (212) of chapter 9 of Dr Whitcomb's text, referenced above.

    If that isn't sufficient support, Dr Whitcomb goes on to say in point 5 of 11

    5) "When Temperature, growth medium, moisture, drainage, and oxygen to the roots and all other factors are optimum or at least reasonable, all, or nearly all plants grow best with the same proportions of nutrients. Plants grow at different rates, but the rate of uptake and utilization of the 12 essential nutrients is the same." This clearly agrees with what I said about all plants using very close to the same ratio of nutrients.

    I'm sure these points will be ignored or discounted because they don't fit your observations. ;o)

    Then there's always that nasty little Liebig's Law (Justus von Liebig is generally credited with being the "Father of the Fertilizer Industry"), that is just so unsupportive of the 1:1:1 fertilizer view.

    Without a soil test, 1:1:1 ratio fertilizers are as good as the next fertilizer, because it's a shotgun approach - a guessing game trying to cover all the bases, but it's always more likely that you will cause toxicities with fertilizers that are not synchronous with plant needs/usage. It can be no other way.

    You are the only one who has ever argued these points in the face of so much evidence, and you have never argued from a scientific perspective - only from the perspective of what someone else has said. Yes - there is considerable advantage in MANIPULATING the N supply of trees in order to curtail vegetative growth, but that is a tool - a way of stressing the plant to bend it to our will. I often talk about the same type of manipulation in tomatoes (for many years) to slow vegetative growth so the plant directs more photosynthate production to fruits instead of vegetative growth - absolutely nothing new, and something I've discussed here many times in my years at this forum.

    Al

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Excuse me........I have remained on topic. After the above discussion, the original poster may well choose to use his surplus fertilizer rather than discard it. His fertilzer is close in ratio to what Baud recommends.

    ...........The bottom line is that Al CANNOT provide the fig specific analytical data that I have requested and his nutrient ratio theory has some significant flaws in it. It IS NOT as scientific based as he thinks. Northern fig growers who end up with unripened figs at the end of the year, should consider LSU's and Baud's advice and try reducing the nitrogen content of their fertilizer. The 3:1:2 (high nitrogen) fertilizers may be the actual cause for some of your figs not ripening before the cold weather arrives. Both LSU and Baud have years of empirical data (real fig specific scientific data) that suggests fig ripening can be DELAYED when using a high nitrogen fertilizer. This is good information for those of you with a short fig growing season and want to encourage your figs to ripen sooner!!

    Dan

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Still not convinced that a 3:1:2 high nitrogen fertilizer may not be the best choice for growing figs in a colder climate. This quote is taken from Joe Morle's fig website and contains more empirical results that a LOWER nitrogen fertilizer works just fine for fig trees that are growing in a Northern climate. Note that he invites phone calls to discuss figs......

    Dan

    "I would like to share my 25 years of experience on how to grow fig trees in containers. Container grown fig trees yield as much fruit as those planted in the ground, but they require different care. They need more fertilizer, lime, and water. The best fertilizer to use is one that is lower in nitrogen, but heavy on the calcium and phosphorous. The first feeding is done in the Spring, as soon as you move your plants from their shelter to the outdoors in a sunny location. The fertilizer consists of, 1 part superphosphate 0-20-0, 1 part 5-10-5, 1 part bone meal, and 1 part garden lime. Mix these ingredients thoroughly. Apply the fertilizer by making 4 holes at the edge of the pots, 1" in diameter and 3" deep. Fill the holes with the mixture and water thoroughly. A fig tree, three quarter inch caliber and 4' tall in a 12" pot requires 1 cup of this mixture. One month later you will begin a liquid feeding with a well balanced fertilizer, 20-20-20. Mix 1 tablespoon with 1 gallon of water, repeat this feeding every 20 days until mid-August. The last feeding will be a top-dressing done in October. Mix 1 part superphosphate, 1 part bonemeal, and 1 part garden lime. Make sure that during the summer months you water your trees frequently. Keep them moist and do not let them dry out or stressed. This is why they may lose their fruit. By the end of August you will start cutting back on the water, this prevents the fruit from splitting. You should change the pot every year, going only 2 sizes up each year, until you reach a 24" to 30" diameter pot. At this point every 4 years you must root prune your fig tree. Take the tree out of the pot and cut one-quarter of the roots away, making a root ball. Replant the tree in the same pot with 3 parts potting mix and 1 part organic compost. This must be done while the plant is dormant, either in the early Spring or late Fall. If you have any questions, feel free to give me a call. I will be happy to answer all your questions. Enjoy your fig trees!"

    -Giuseppe "Joe" Morle'

    Here is a link that might be useful: Joe Morle's fertilizer regimin

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Dan - I don't jump through hoops at your command. You're the one in perpetual argument with what I said - not the other way around, and I don't understand why you so desperately need people to believe you? They either do or they don't - so let it go.

    If you want data that shows tissue analysis is different for figs than all other plants, or figs use more x than y - it's up to you to produce it. What I said is well documented, and very logical ..... very plain, straightforward, and easy to understand. You're in disagreement with hundreds of PhDs. Again, you completely ignore the references and Liebigs Law. As a self-proclaimed "researcher" you might be familiar with, and could certainly bolster your credibility by adhering a little more closely to, the principle of 'lex parsimoniae' (Occam's razor).

    I really don't even know what you're arguing about any more. It changes so often it's difficult to keep track.

    FWIW - you have never once rebutted anything I've ever said with anything even remotely resembling 'analytic data', much less 'specific analytic data', so that's an extremely weak hand you're playing ..... but I hope you're having fun - the rest of us aren't.

    Al

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Al

    You're too funny. You can't provide any FIG specific data so you set up a straw man argument. Whenever THEORY is in conflict with real measurable data, real scientists will always question the THEORY and not the data. Why do you so desperately cling to your theory?? Let's face it.......your nutrient ratio theory has some giant holes in it simply because it is not based on science. I know that it is hard for you to admit that your 3:1:2 (high nitrogen) fertilizer regimen is very likely delaying the ripening of many forum member's figs. I know that it is hard for you to accept that other viewpoints are just as valid as yours and actually may well produce better results. Lots of empirical data exists that suggests a high nitrogen content fertilization of figs can significantly DELAY fig ripening. That is a verifiable fact.........too bad if it is in disagreement with your pet theory and fertilizer recommendation.

    Regarding real science.....

    In Math:
    Two plus two equals four. It is the same anywhere in the United States, anywhere in the world, it's even the same on Mars or anywhere in the entire Universe for that matter. Anyone can verify this for themselves because mathematics is a REAL SCIENCE.

    In Chemistry:
    A given weight of Hydrogen plus oxygen produces an exothermic reaction that always produces the exact same amount of heat and exact same amount of water. It is the same anywhere in the United States, anywhere in the world, is even the same on Mars or anywhere in the entire Universe for that matter. Anyone can verify this for themselves because Chemistry is a REAL SCIENCE.

    In Physics:
    The speed of light is always the same and Force equals mass times acceleration. It is the same anywhere in the United States, anywhere in the world, it's even the same on Mars or anywhere in the entire Universe for that matter. Anyone can verify this for themselves because Physics is a REAL SCIENCE.

    In Horticulture:
    A fig tree plus water and fertilizer DOES NOT always produce the same results. Nor does the rooting of fig cuttings by any method produce the exact same results. Results are NOT ALWAYS the same anywhere in the United States, anywhere in the world, and not the same on Mars or anywhere in the entire Universe for that matter. Results vary widely because Horticultural practices are NOT A REAL SCIENCE. At best, horticulture is simply an ART AND A CRAFT.

    That is why one sees such diverse approaches to the propagation and growing of figs. That is why my viewpoint is just as valid as yours......in some cases even better than yours. In science THERE ARE NO AUTHORITIES....."verifiable" data speaks for itself. The information that I post can ALWAYS be verified by anyone. Can you say the same??

    Your highly recommended 3:1:2 high nitrogen fertilizer may actually be delaying the ripening of forum member's figs in colder climates with shorter growing seasons. By reducing the nitrogen content of their fertilizer (as suggested by LSU, Baud, Joe Morle, and me) they may actually be able to ripen more figs before winter arrives. Care to comment on that?? Are the fig growing and fruiting observations by LSU, Baud, Joe Morle, and me......all wrong???? Isn't it our goal to produce more ripe figs?? Forum members ought to have information that affects earlier fig ripening don't you think??? Or does that type of information qualify for a "stamping out" campaign too???

    Continue to read my posts and I promise that you will learn a few things about figs as I continue with my research activities.

    Dan


  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Dan - You're extremely misguided. I'm not attacking your viewpoint - I'm perpetually defending mine from you. I've said over and over that manipulating the N supply in plants is a useful tool, but you'll use any platform from which to mount an attack. You just will not let anything go.

    What I've learned from your posts, and what I expect I'll continue to learn, is not about plants.

    Al

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Al - When it comes to the proper application of science, it not me that is extremely misguided. Sorry if you view alternate "verifiable" viewpoints as personal attacks. They are not and you should know better.

    IMO....This thread should have been enlightening to some open minded forum members. They now have another VIABLE avenue for them to pursue to have more figs ripen for them by simply LOWERING the nitrogen content of their fertilizer. The fact remains....in a short growing season, the 3:1:2 fertilizer that you ALWAYS recommend.......may not be the best choice if the goal is to ripen the most figs before the cold weather arrives. This is not a personal attack on you......this is both an ENLIGHTENING and EDUCATIONAL bit of information. You can expect to see me post this information often......because it is helpful to many forum members. To believe that this is misguided in any way is absolutely ridiculous.

    Dan

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    It's time to sound off, fig-growers!

    How many of you are following Dan's recommendations?

    How has it affected/increased/hastened your container crop?

    Are there any anecdotal studies in effect right now?


    Josh

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Forum members,

    the original poster of this thread Sly33 has not posted anything since this thread was started April 26th.

    Perhaps a new thread should be started in such a way for members to share there experiences and we can see many more thoughts on the subject.

    It can be a great discussion in a new thread if we can get more members to talk about it .

    There are many growers to share information across all the lands if its done in the right manner , its my doubt there will be much said in this thread by those members.

    Time will tell if it can be done properly or not.

    Martin

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Josh,

    Science is not a popularity contest decided by a show of hands or allegiance to a particular forum member. It is a discipline that can actually be verified in real life.

    Not many forum members are even aware of what I've just recently posted.....namely that a high nitrogen content fertilizer (such as the one Al recommends) CAN ACTUALLY DELAY the ripening of figs. Al has been recommending a 3:1:2 nutrient ratio fertilizer FOR YEARS to fig forum members. Whenever anyone mentions any other fertilizer type, he instinctively go into his "nutrient ratio" speech and shouts down any further discussion. It is time to bring forth over viable fertilizer choices that WILL PRODUCE MORE FIGS for certain forum members. To my knowledge this is NEW INFORMATION that has not been discussed on any FIG forum. It is great news for those of you living in an area with a short fig growing season!!! By simply changing your fertilizer, you may have more figs ripen for you before cold weather arrives!!!!!!

    Dan

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Dan,
    I'm not sure what popularity has to do with this?

    I'm asking if anyone has implemented this science. Empirical evidence.

    If not, then who *will be* following these practices next season and what controls will be in force.
    I am curious in *application* - as I've read considerably about the theory.

    Josh

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    This is ridiculous. A THEORY is NOT a guess. It is built on observed facts. And using a 3-2-1 RATIO is NOT high nitrogen - it is a ratio - the relationship between the elements. For instance 6-4-2 is lower nitrogen than 8-8-8.

    Dan, you were all for whatever growers with good results on the forum were doing - until you realized they were doing what Al recommended. Ooops - about face.

    Now you are declaring that Al's fertilizer advice will result in a delay in ripening. I'd like to see you back that up with specific fig data. It's not a theory, it's a guess and utterly irresponsible without proof.

    This is fig growing as a competition - he who has the most followers is Fig Guru #1??? Al isn't running, he's just doing what he's always done. I wish you'd stop Dan - there is no Fig Guru position. Many growers post their results - bare facts - without ego and we all benefit. This is just ridiculous.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    How bout those figs!!!! and fertilizer...

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    First, I'll point to the fact that 3:1:2 ratio fertilizers are not high N fertilizers. They are fertilizers that supply nutrients in the same ratio that the plant would use them were it left to it's own devices in situ (where they naturally occur). I have already said many times that it can be useful to limit N applications to manipulate plants, including figs, to achieve a certain end. It is not new information, no matter how eager Dan is to lay claim to it. ;o)

    Induced N deficiencies at certain times during the growth cycle can free up some current photosynthate, which would normally go to increasing vegetative biomass, that can go into fruit production. Hort 101. This should be seen for what it is - an intentional manipulation that may or may not help fruit to ripen under certain conditions. Dan acts as though I argued against that possibility, when I've been discussing intentional nutritional manipulations for years, and practicing it longer than I've been discussing it.

    It's entirely possible that if you have trees, the size of which already suits you (because reducing N supplied is going to curtail growth), and you want to manage N in an attempt to affect fruiting habits, it might be helpful. I have no argument with that; but it's important to note that now we have shifted gears from practices that allow our trees to grow best, to using nutrition to hopefully curtail vegetative growth in the hope it has a positive affect on fruiting. These are two decidedly different things.

    Reducing N to deficiency levels may or may not have a + effect on fruit ripening, but we can be certain that reducing the N supplied to the point where it is low enough to inhibit vegetative growth influences o/a growth .... period. If the N supply is not reduced to at least that point, it is not a deficiency and would have no influence on fruiting, making Dan's supposition invalid.

    I'll state the obvious here because it's been overlooked: It's not actually the RATIO of the fertilizer that limits the N supply; and simply changing to a 1:1:1 fertilizer will not limit N unless you abstain from applying it.

    Your trees will grow best in containers using 3:1:2 ratio fertilizers (20+ years of practical experience + the support of hundreds of PhDs), but if you wish to experiment by reducing the N while still trying to maintain other nutrients at adequate levels in the hope it will have a + effect on fruiting, I'd be the last to stand in any one's way.

    Al

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Yee-Hahh ! Ain't life grand ! This fig forum is more fun than Judge Judy !
    Wasn't it the old monks that argued , how many Angels could dance on the head of a pin ?
    I guess, that I'm just not "Up on things".
    I buy a bag of 8-8-8- or 10-10-10 and in February, I throw a coffee can full around the drip line of my Fig trees. Seems to work for me!! Enjoy life, folks!!

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hello All,

    I appreciate all the work put into this thread. My intentions when I posted was to get feedback on alternative fertilizer ratios, and man did I get it. Martin, I didnt post anything because it was like watching an intense tennis match. I didnt want to stop the action!

    To be honest, Im yet to confirm from my experience,whats best for ripening figs in 6A. However, I am using the 24-8-16/12-4-8, etc ratio. Not because I am sure it will work, but rather because I have followed some of Al's suggestions in relation to container soils and so far overall growth performance has been strong.
    I know another respected collector in zone 7 PA (everyone knows him) and he uses the 3-1-2 in slow release form. However, the Canadian Legend uses 24-8-16 in the spring and MG Blossoming (the red container, cant remember the ratio, but its high P and K) the last time we spoke.

    I will ask though:
    Al- have you ever used the high p/k formulas with your figs for increased/earlier ripening and yield?

    thanks again,
    Nas

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    LMAO Sly (JIT) while the French open is going on, to bad Federer got knocked out another Nadel vs Federer would have been fun to watch. I love long points in tennis but even those come to an end.
    Sal

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I'll talk about the primary macro-nutrients here, but the secondaries and minor elements follow in lockstep what I'll share.

    Somewhere along the way, we curiously began to look at fertilizers as miraculous assemblages of growth drugs, and started interpreting the restorative (of normal growth) effect of fertilizer as stimulation beyond what a normal growth rate would be if all nutrients were adequately present in soils. Its no small wonder that we come away with the idea that there are miracle concoctions out there and often end up placing more hope than is reasonable in them. In couplet with the hope for the miracle tonic is more must be better ..... let's add extra Ca because it does X for plants, or lets add extra Fe because it will make my plant greener .... extra P because it's good for roots and we all know we need extra P for extra blooms - right? Wrong.

    If you pick up any basic textbook that deals with plant nutrition, you will soon discover that plants basically use the same nutrients, in the same ratios, and they maintain these ratios with only minor variance from plant to plant and from one part of the growth cycle to another.

    There are no plants that use more P or K than N, so it makes no sense to supply an adequate amount of N, and super adequate amounts of P and K. I CAN see certain benefits in curtailing the amount of N and keeping P and K at adequate levels, but when I do that, I simply use 3:1:2 at reduced rates, and add a little Pro-TeKt 0-0-3. You can achieve the same results by incorporating a teaspoon of potash per gallon of potting soil when you pot the plant.

    It wouldn't be altogether uncommon for a fertilizer with a high P content to be appropriate for in-ground trees (after a soil test), but because plants use approximately 6x more N than P, I can think of no case where it would ever be appropriate to supply more P than N in containers. I'm not saying it will cause irreversible harm, or even that it will have a particularly noticeable effect on vitality, but we Know that excess P competes with other nutrients (Fe, Mn, Z, and N,) and can cause antagonistic deficiencies of these elements even when they are adequately represented in the soil. Excess P also contributes unnecessarily to the EC/TDS level of the soil solution, making it more difficult for the plant to absorb water and the nutrients dissolved in water, while at the same time elevating pH unnecessarily, which also affects the solubility of (primarily) micronutrients.

    No, there is no advantage in supplying an excess of any nutrient. You can manipulate plant response and in some cases bend them favorably to our will by subjecting it intentionally to deficiencies (usually limited to N), but it's not wise to supply nutrients beyond the adequate-luxury levels. Also, plants grown at luxury levels of many nutrients frequently need weaning off their 'diets' or they actually exhibit deficiency symptoms when nutrient levels fall back into the normal range.

    Before I knew anything about fertilizers and nutrition, I tried the organic soil amendment approach for my containerized plants, and found it lacking. For no particular reason, I then started using 20-20-20 soluble fertilizer, and used it for several years. When I switched to the 3:1:2 ratio fertilizers, I saw noticeable improvement in growth rates and vitality. I've tried other fertilizers, but my studies and my own observations, along with the input of the (literally) thousands of growers I've helped here at GW, leave me very convinced that a 3:1:2 ratio offers the best opportunity for growth, and you won't improve growth or fruiting by adding an excess of any element, though there is something to be said for experimenting with N at deficiency levels. I've discussed this in making my case for the importance of nutrient ratios many times. It's not a new idea.

    Al

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks Al
    Your approach to discussion and arguments is scholarly that helps avoid further degeneration of the thread.

    I had skipped this thread from the beginning for whatever reason but later I saw the number of posts going up and I said to myself that it has to be Dan and Al involved, and surely it was just like many such threads before and it does not take much to figure out at what particular post it moved from plain discussion and idea presentation to 'one-upmanship argument' that makes most readers uneasy because of respect for both Al and Dan. I believe the readers can spot the unnecessary part in a statement with burrs that should be avoided and keep it as amicable discussion.

    Nas, I hope you know more now what to do with your 2-1-6 tonic before the frost days come closer.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    fignut says......."Now you are declaring that Al's fertilizer advice will result in a delay in ripening. I'd like to see you back that up with specific fig data. It's not a theory, it's a guess and utterly irresponsible without proof."

    What part of REAL life empirical data don't you understand??? Did you not read what LSU, Baud, and Joe Morle have to say based upon many years of growing figs and their observations? In the case of LSU.......they have been studying figs for well over one hundred years. They keep records on the actual PRODUCTION and FRUITING DATES of their trees. Production and time/duration of fruit ripening are very important parameters for commercial fig growers in Louisiana. Fig research at LSU is geared towards COMMERCIAL production. When the FIG EXPERTS at LSU say that a CAUSE FOR FIGS NOT RIPENING is often due to too high a nitrogen content........do you not believe their data?????? Did you even look at the nutrient ratios of what LSU, Baud, and Morle recommend........NONE recommend a 3:1:2 ratio. I wonder why that is.....could it be becasue this fertilize type has too high a nitrogen content?? These are FACTS supported by many years of empirical data, not just another THEORY.

    I'm sorry; but, it is VERY RESPONSIBLE, INFORMATIVE, and EDUCATIONAL to suggest to some forum members that by reducing the nitrogen content of their fertilizer, they may actually get more of their figs to ripen before the cold weather arrives in their area. Notice even Al does not disagree with that statement as he stated at the end of the above post "there is something to be said for experimenting with N at deficiency levels". In other words there may well be an benefit to lowering the nitrogen content of your fertilizer if your goal is to have more figs ripen before winter arrives......

    I stand firmly by all of what I have written in this thread and hope this new information actually helps some forum members produce more figs!!

    fredfig,

    You are using fertilizer types that LSU recommends for fig trees. Me too. I fertilized many of my fig trees today with a 1:1:1 ratio fertilizer. I actually used 8-8-8 today. Tomorrow I will be using 13-13-13. My figs trees absolutely LOVE this type fertilizer. The BELIEF (or theory) by anyone that a 1:1:1 type fertilizer applied to my in ground fig tree will hurt or cause damage to them in any way IS PURE BALONEY.

    Come to think about it......in my yard, I am able to fully ripen Col De Dame Blanc to absolute perfection. Hmmmmm.....wonder if my "low nitrogen" 1:1:1 fertilizer is partly responsible for SHORTENING the ripening period and helping make that happen for me. hmmmmmmmmm..... interesting thought!!

    Dan

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks for the kind words, guys .... to each of the several who offered them. I DO appreciate .....

    Al

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hi All,

    I'm weighing in--I still like both of you, Al & Dan, and am getting useful things to think about from both of you.

    Al, you have been so helpful to me and very patient and kind. I can't tell you how much I appreciate the time you have taken with me, to help me with the new "babies." You are sooo sweet--Thanks so much!

    Dan, you are my homeboy and live in the same climate that I do and are researching all kinds of figs to see how they do here. I think that's great and want to hear more of what you grow here. I wish I could visit with you and see your trees and talk with you about them some time in the future.

    I'm going to add Gene in with this because he's such a fine person and has been welcoming and an inspiration to me. He's my "Homey," too and I'm thankful for him and his gentle kindness. God bless you and your family, especially at this difficult time.

    I think my grasp of figs has been so enriched by the people on this forum, as well as Figs4Fun and I thank all of you who have taken the time to post here and there, as well. What a great bunch of people you are.

    I want to also thank, Celeste and Legacy for showing me how much heart fig trees can have in their spirit to live, no matter what I've done to the poor things over these past nine years! They have reached for the stars with very little fertilizer and adequate care and are just awesome trees. I'm learning how to take better care of them through all the people on the forums.

    Thank you all so much,

    Vivian

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Nas

    Watcha gonna do with that jug of 2-1-6?

    Dave

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Nos,

    There is a lot of good information to be found on this forum.....and more to come as forum members continue to improve upon their growing practices & methods and develop/share information about those lesser known cultivars. I highly recommend that you follow LSU's fertilizer recommendations that were outlined in detail in their fig publication.

    FYI......I'm planning a trip (with another forum member) to visit a fig/fruit orchard in your area sometime in July. If available, perhaps you might want to join us.

    (Also--my email is not working properly right now.....I can only receive messages until I get time to resolve my outgoing email problem.)

    Dan

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hi Dan,

    That would be great. I would love to join you. Are you talking about Eddie Romero's orchard in the New Iberia area? (Coteau?)

    Gene has told me about some orchards there and gave me their phone numbers and talked about meeting there to enjoy the different figs.

    I've already called Eddie Romero's orchard and talked with him and he said they have all kinds of different figs, which ripen at different times. Mr. Romero was very friendly and I'm looking forward to meeting him. He said some of the figs I'd love and others, I would probably never want to eat again. He didn't tell me which kinds they were. Now I'm really curious to go there.

    There is another orchard across the road from Eddie Romero's orchard, but they said they don't have a lot of different varieties, only Celeste, LSU Gold and LSU Purple. They were very nice, as well.

    The people at both orchards have the same last name, but I didn't ask if they were related.

    Thanks for the invitation,

    Vivian

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Yep, that's the place. Gene obtained their contact information from me last year. Ed and Dan are brothers. FYI, they have two of the nicest fruit orchards that you will ever see. We can ask them about their fertilization program. They have Smith in their collection.....so, if you haven't tasted that one.......that will be your chance.

    Gene from the bayou wants to make the trip with us too. I'll be in touch with a tentative date when I get my email problem resolved. Anyone else interested in making the trip with us is more than welcome. Cecil are you interested??

    Dan

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Yep, that's the place. Gene obtained their contact information from me last year. Ed and Dan are brothers. FYI, they have two of the nicest fruit orchards that you will ever see. We can ask them about their fertilization program. They have Smith in their collection.....so, if you haven't tasted that one.......that will be your chance.

    Gene from the bayou wants to make the trip with us too. I'll be in touch with a tentative date when I get my email problem resolved. Anyone else interested in making the trip with us is more than welcome. Cecil are you interested??

    Dan

Sponsored