Software
Houzz Logo Print
jbranch_gw

Another Patriot Problem

18 years ago

Here is my Patriot problem. Notice the end of the leaves turning down the leaf material in the margins dying. This hosta along with a couple others are doing this - they are on my screen porch and get very little direct sun light. I have had some tell me it looks like it is getting too much water, but I water it about once a week. Since several hostas are doing this, is it a combination of water and not enough sun?

Jeff

Comments (11)

  • 18 years ago

    It does look awfully wet to me. Normal potting medium will hold a lot more water than is ideal (IMHO), I would switch to a bark mix with better drainage.

    Alexa

  • 18 years ago

    pick each affected leaf.. and trace it down to the crown ...

    i will bet a buck .. its the first 4 leaves to emerge..

    and another buck .. that it was frosted.. when you wernt looking a few weeks back ...

    leave them there for a few weeks.. injured or not.. they are adding food to the fast growing plant ...

    when it doubles in size .... trace the worst ones back dawn .. and snap them right out of there ...

    ken

  • 18 years ago

    I'll cover your bet, ken and raise it another buck!
    Frost damage...
    Linda C

  • 18 years ago

    if you actually succeed in drowning a hosta ... i will send you another buck ..

    impossible...

    ester grows them in pots.. in his pond ...

    ken

    PS: pick better HOSTA friends.. lol ...

  • 18 years ago

    I've had a few look like that in pots with overwatering this year. (We went on a short vacation and I over compensated). And we haven't had a frost here this year. Ken, I have succeeded in drowning several hostas over the years. One year I lost 40 varieties due to winter rains that saturated the potting soil. Do I win a prize? Lots of bark works for me.

  • 18 years ago

    i find it hard to believe.. that one growing hosta in z9 attributes winter failure to water.. and not improper dormancy???

    i have never tried to drown a dormant hosta.. the ground freezes solid for me ...

    regardless.. the issue is whether you can drown an actively growing hosta ....

    ken

  • 18 years ago

    In a pot...yes you can. Some of these potting mixes hold too much water and not enough air. I'm learning to feel the leaves to decide if it is time to grab the hose. Out here (California)they go dormant in late November here no matter what the weather. We've had a very mild winter this year compared to past (I've been growing hostas since the late 90's) and this time I put a tarp over them, gave them fungicide as they went dormant, they woke up again in late February/March. This is my BEST year ever! Moisture during dormancy does make a difference. Or maybe it was the fungicide?

    I have read all the studies in the Hosta (hybridizers) Science Journals regarding temperature and dormancy and heartily agree that a colder, longer dormancy will result in a more vigorous plant, but in the above post I referred to my over watering several plants before we went on a short vacation last week. Perhaps our cool nights contributed? Only Guacamole and Fragrant Bouquet were showing problems.

    Over the years I've managed to kill too many pants with too much love and water. We have zero rain from April to November, so I can fully take the blame for all the water my plants get. Yes, I have (unintentionally)induced root rot on actively growing plants in the past by over watering. Every hosta plant tag I have says to keep them moist. But, they also need air, and allowing them to dry a bit before watering, is making a huge difference for me. Growing them out here is a WHOLE lot different from my roots in Chicago. YMMV

    I'm way out here in left field (left coast), with no hosta societies or groups to conive with. What happens out here is very different from your conditions back East, so what I'm saying is, never say never. Yes, I can drown an actively growing hosta, and have done so.

  • 18 years ago

    I don't think you can drown a hosta

    I have several plants in pots in my garden, the pots are standing in shells. Everytime I water them, I fill the shell 1" high... so the soil is reallly wet

    Almost every single plant reacts very well on this treatment, I have some new plants of last year that went from 1 eye last year to 7-8 eyes this year, and I'm not talking of mini-hosta (combination of a lot of water, alfalfa and a lot of sun). The older plants also thrive on it

    Early september, I take the shells away. I don't want dormant hostas sitting in too much water

    I didn't loose a single potted hosta over winter this year (> 100 plants)

    I have to admit that some plants don't react too well on too much water (the Baby Bunting family tree over here)

  • 18 years ago

    babka-

    I'm very interested in your experiences because I'm trying to grow them in SoCal. As you say, they're not a common plant and information about them in these climates (I've got several different ones in my yard) is harder to come by.

    I'm in the San Fernando Valley area of Los Angeles -- my Sunset zone is probably about 21. I grow mine in full shade.

  • 18 years ago

    imrainey-

    I'm up- north near San Jose, in Sunset Zone 15. All my hostas are in pots under 2x2 overheads. I pick my favorite 10 or 12 and put them on the deck next to the family room sliding doors so I can see them from the kitchen. Those get full, early morning sun for a couple hours, then as the sun rises, the 2x2's on the overhead filter the light by 50%. By noon the house shades them totally.

    All the rest are under 80% shade. I have about 60 varieties currently, down from almost 100 a few years ago. Mine are all in pots so that I can tuck them out of sight when they go dormant.

    You are right, there is little or no info on growing them here,(probably for a good reason!) so it is mostly trial and error. With all the different micro-climates you need to find what works for you. We don't get your hot summers here. Snails and slugs can devour a large hosta overnight, and mites will kill them too, although more slowly.

    But they bring me so much joy...

  • 18 years ago

    Omigod! Do you have banana slugs there? I'm sure one of those big boys could get a plant in a bite or two! We just have the conventional garden snails and slugs here.

    My son is at UCSC. I can't say I've noticed any particular presence of hostas when I'm up there...

Sponsored
Custom Home Works
Average rating: 4.6 out of 5 stars10 Reviews
Franklin County's Award-Winning Design, Build and Remodeling Expert